Agree with you that no shutters on the middle window above the portico looks best.

https://www.lifeofanarchitect.com/residential-architecture-101-shutters/

Please read the above...and size your shutters appropriately.

Oh, yours are the slimmer? was going to congratulate you for having beefed them up to a size that might almost be able to cover the windows. Ah well...

Hmmm...I almost always say no shutters when they're not appropriate. My only issue is that window looks kind of naked without anything. Maybe someone can come up with a no-shutter suggestion.

Let’s all re-read the question. Instead of voicing opinions on my home in areas I didn’t ask, I would rather appreciate just a simple “yes or no” vote on the subject requested. At the end of the day, it’s an opinion, we all have them and none are right or wrong. I would just appreciate that if you give yours, they’re helpful & constructive, not snarky. Thank you.