Travis - probably too wet. The critical time - first couple of weeks - if you keep them under the dome - I put an a Icrylic mat on the bottom of the tray , pots with leaf cuttings and dome on the top and it goes under the light. I keep the mat barely barely humid. You want your soil juts a tad humid, never wet.

You're probably right. What do you use for your substrate?

1/3 coarse perlite, 2/3 Promix HP mycorrhizae/biofungicide. And i put a layer of perlite on the bottom. This way I can grow them on wicks... for a while.