Software
Houzz Logo Print
jay6a

BS cat, what should I do?

8 years ago

I took a few rue cuttings a couple days ago, and when I looked at them last night I discovered a half grown BS cat. I don't have any live rue plants here to put it on, but I have 4 fennel plants. I went looking for tuill at the fabric store and everything they had was heavy and non see through. I'm going to order some on line for cheap. In the meantime, I was planning on moving the cat to a fennel plant, and fitting my butterfly cage around the plant until I get the tuille. Do you think the cat will switch to fennel with no problems. Please, someone let me know. I haven't had these cats in a long time, and I don't want to mess it up. Thanks

Comments (31)

  • 8 years ago

  • 8 years ago

    Thanks Sherry. I stuck a little piece of rue with the cat on the fennel. Then I covered it with the tent.

  • 8 years ago

    Actually, it appears your cat is ready to form a chrysalis: that's ^^^ how they typically look beforehand. I wouldn't worry about providing an alternate food source. FYI, I was able to switch mine from dill to fennel w/o issues, and vice versa.

    I'm back in town and found 20-30 BST eggs just on one fennel! Yikes. Purchased some organic carrots (with full green tops) and will experiment to see if the BST cats will take to carrot tops.

    Jay 6a Chicago thanked javiwa
  • 8 years ago

    PS within the next 24 hours, it'll attach its hind end to the branch, then spin/build itself a silk harness from which it'll hang. This is one of my guys:

    Jay 6a Chicago thanked javiwa
  • 8 years ago

    I think the photo makes it look bigger, but it is still going to need to feed more, and get bigger.

  • 8 years ago

    Interesting, rue is the preferred host plant for my BSTs!

    To answer your question, I have switched my cats between rue, fennel, dill, and parsley at various times in the past. (not all 4 plants, just from one to another, so 2 host plants for each situation.) I have had no problem at all with switching. As my mother used to say: "If you're hungry, you'll eat it!"

    Jay 6a Chicago thanked weed30 St. Louis
  • 8 years ago

    weed30: When you switched between hosts, did you move baby cats soon after hatching, or did you let them grow to the 2nd/3rd instar first (at which time they may have acquired a taste for the original host plant)?

    Yesterday, I brought in two tiny cats (so, newly hatched) as well as a 2nd/3rd instar and placed them onto carrot leaves. The larger cat has been crawling and searching for 24 hours, and it's not taking to the carrots yet. One of the two newborns has started munching the carrot leaves. The other found the tiny nub of original dill I brought it in on, so it's starting life on dill. Just trying to figure out if there's an opportune time to move between hosts.

    I'm also heading to the nursery to see if they have parsley in pots.

    Jay 6a Chicago thanked javiwa
  • 8 years ago

    Nibbles on the carrot tops definitely happening right now, but not sure if this is the same little guy who feasted overnight. Regardless, I can't say he's eating with gusto (reminds me of a small child being forced to eat his broccoli!).

    Jay 6a Chicago thanked javiwa
  • 8 years ago

    Some of you say it's easier raising BS cats outside. Do you mean they just do better outside, or because out there, they can eat live plants? Will the cat eat leaves that are in water?

  • 8 years ago

    Jay: It ended up being easier for me to raise SWTs outdoors once I figured out the trick of using tulle netting to protect and entire (fennel/dill) plant from lizards and wasps. This saved me the trouble of manually feeding the cats (snipping branches from the yard, bringing them indoors and setting in water). ^^ I guess that answers your final question: yes, the cats absolutely will eat branches stuck in water.


    This being my first year with BSTs, there were too many variables for me to figure out why my tiniest cats were simply dying (indoors); and quite a high percentage of eggs (if not all -- cannot recall right now), once brought indoors, never hatched. And yet, I recall all seven of the eggs laid on the outdoor fennel plant this spring hatched. Very early on, I stopped harvesting BST cats and bringing them in, as my outdoor pots worked great. HTH.

    Jay 6a Chicago thanked javiwa
  • 8 years ago

    I've moved them at all instars, depending on when I ran out of the plant they hatched on. If I recall, they might have gone on a hunger strike for a few hours, but then relented and munched away.


    Jay 6a Chicago thanked weed30 St. Louis
  • 8 years ago

    Jay - I raise all of my butterflies inside. I have cages and put cuttings in vases and in floral water tubes as well.

    Jay 6a Chicago thanked weed30 St. Louis
  • 8 years ago

    Thank you, weed30. I've got a couple of cats that have gone past 24 hours without eating. I even put in rue (from the garden) and organic parsley (from the grocery store) -- no go. And the one picture above on the carrot leaf hasn't eaten since this morning.

    Jay 6a Chicago thanked javiwa
  • 8 years ago

    At what point to you have to worry? They wouldn’t starve themselves to death if they have food in their hostplant family awailable, right? Obviously I don’t know much. Just read today in the Humane Society magazine that a new study shows that Monarch caterpillars are stressed out by traffic noise. Or lawn mower noise and such. Never thought of that.

    Jay 6a Chicago thanked Iris S (SC, Zone 7b)
  • 8 years ago

    Here's an update. The cat is doing great. It's gotten bigger and looks healthy and happy. Thanks everyone for helping. This is the first cat I've had in a long time. So glad I planted the four fennel plants. I'm rooting rue cuttings now, starting more dill, and my tuille should arive tomorrow. :)

  • 8 years ago

    They wouldn’t starve themselves to death if they have food in their hostplant family awailable, right? One would think so, Iris. That's what I'm counting on.

    At what point to you have to worry? The Mom/parent in me has been worried all day long. These cats have gone quite a while without food. I'll let you know how it goes. (Googling "how long swallowtail caterpillars survive without food" yielded nothing helpful.

    Jay: Nice! :)


    Jay 6a Chicago thanked javiwa
  • 8 years ago

    Jay, glad your caterpillar is doing great. Javiwa, I hope it turns out well. Keep us updated. Trying to find an answer on Google when you really need is can be so frustrating.

    Jay 6a Chicago thanked Iris S (SC, Zone 7b)
  • 8 years ago

    Iris: Regarding monarch cat stress, I wouldn't doubt it. We keep our monarchs indoors and I see them twitch (then hold completely still for about 10-15 minutes) whenever there are loud, high-pitched, banging noises -- say, when DH loads the dishwasher and clangs the dishes. o_0

    Jay 6a Chicago thanked javiwa
  • 8 years ago

    Javi, what kind of plant did you find the 2 cats on?

  • 8 years ago

    Jay, they will stop eating and stay pretty still before they molt - for a whole day at least.

    Javiwa, Be careful with organic parsley. It can still be treated with Bt and considered organic. Bt will kill caterpillars. In the past when I have run out of host food, I put one cat on the organic grocery store parsley in a separate container. If it's been treated with Bt, the cat will stop eating and die within 12 - 24 hours. I hate doing it, but sacrificing one is better than killing all of them.

    Whole foods used to have safe organic parsley, then one year, not safe. I finally found some at Lucky's Market that year. But I always test, even if it was safe in the past.

    And keep in mind, the more you plant, the more eggs you'll get...it's a constant challenge. A happy challenge, but some years it's stressful!


  • 8 years ago

    Jay: The two (now four) cats I brought in from outdoors were on fennel plants.

    weed30: Thanks for the reminder (to always test each batch) and warning about Bt. I just glossed over a few online articles about Bt: would washing the leaves in a diluted soapy water solution, then rinsing thoroughly not wash off any Bt residue? The parsley I purchased is labelled non-GMO, so hopefully that points to no systemic Bt use, only surface/foliar spray (if at all).

    I notice more frass at the bottoms of my indoor containers than I did last night, so that's a good sign. Now I need to figure out which cat is eating what (kinda difficult to see them through my tulle bag, but I didn't want the cats to crawl away).

    And keep in mind, the more you plant, the more eggs you'll get...it's a constant challenge. A happy challenge, but some years it's stressful! For sure! :) With my first batch of SWTs, once I found a fennel/dill plant had a good # of eggs laid, I actually wrapped that plant in tulle so no other eggs could be laid. I recently left town for 11 days, so didn't think to wrap all my plants. Really, though, who knew one plant could have so many eggs? Yes, I'm feeling the stress. I'm hoping I'll be much better prepared next year.


  • 8 years ago

    By way of update (at the risk of repetition, as I posted similarly to another thread):

    This morning, I brought in ~ 10 very young (one-day old, at the most) cats off the too-crowded fennel in the yard; then plopped the new ones directly onto the parsley. So far, they appear to at least NOT be crawling away from the parsley, looking for their original fennel. Phew...fingers crossed. I'm noticing a lot of frass beneath this parsley grouping, so hope it's not just leftover 'activity' from their original life on the fennel. :)

    I have these branches in small water bottles (spice jars, originally), all set inside a repurposed 5-gallon acrylic fish tank. I walked away for about 1/2 hour (to tend to the monarch cats) and this resistant 1/2" guy (from yesterday) is just bound and determined to find its dill!

    Going on 48 hours with this one ignoring carrot and rue, despite my continually putting him back onto the plants when he crawls away.

    I again moved him (this time, onto the new parsley) and, to my relief and surprise, it started to eat -- not a lot, but I could tell he was nibbling at the leaf margins.

    So far, it's looking like I might have more success with parsley, as well as moving the cats onto the parsley sooner rather than later (based on the 10 I brought in this morning).


  • 8 years ago

    Bt that is sprayed on and not systemic is supposedly able to be washed off, but I still don't trust it.

  • 8 years ago

    Just reporting in -- BS cats are doing great with the parsley and carrot tops!

  • 8 years ago

    Wow, that sure is a lot of cats javi! Have you ever tried growing rue. It can handle drought and hot weather very well. I checked on the M. cat I moved from the swan milkweed. It was still on top of the hamper. I moved it onto the plant and it craweled off and dissapeared for awhile. I found it on a Salvia leaf, and put it back on the tropical milkweed. It started to crawel off again, so I put it back on the hamper top, and put the hamper back over the milkweed. It's been such a long time since I've had cats, that I'm not completly sure when they are ready to crysalize. I thought the cat wasn't eating because it wasn't swan milkweed, but maybe its getting ready to change. I'd say it is about an inch long. I'm praying the other 2 that disapeared made their crysalises somewhere safe. I found 2 new Monarch cats today, so that makes 9 so far. I just saw a Monarch flying around, so I'll have to keep my eyes open. Here's a pic of my ravaged swan milkweed and one of the troublesome Monarch cat.

    .

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Javi, I was thinking that you could grow the 13 ft. tall Calotropis milkweed tree, and use the sap to make poison darts, so you can shoot lizards with your blowgun. lol. The leaves are so thick and sturdy, that the Monarch cats will just make their crysalises on the leaves. You would need an aweful lot of tuille though lol.

  • 8 years ago

    Hmm, Jay. At least for my monarch cats, they grow to 2-2 1/2" before the chrysalis stage. It was probably getting ready to molt. But let's still be hopeful, shall we? :)

    I did plant three rue earlier this spring, as well as took some cuttings (rooting in water, as we speak). I mainly put these into the ground for the Giants; as luck would have it, a Giant laid eggs on my Blood Moro orange tree instead. I haven't seen any action on the rue yet, but I don't check as often: they're waaaaayyyy towards the back of the yard, and I make it back there just to water. At least they're not dying. I researched growing rue in Texas and, not to beat this into the ground, our heat is like no other. Rue will only survive down here in part shade conditions. So far, so good!

    Unfortunately, my fingers hit the business end of those danged Moro thorns twice (!!!), so I think I'm A-ok for supplies if I need to fashion an anole deterrent. ;)

  • 8 years ago

    How long do the cats stop eating for before they molt. I need to learn more about the instars and all that. Some of these cats could possibly be the children or grandchildren of the butterflies you released. I just saw a Monarch again. I will have to look for eggs tomorrow morning. We are in a drought and heatwave up here. Temps in the 90s, very humid. I have 4 cats on 1 common milkweed. Still has a lot of leaves. They can devour the thin leaved milkweeds very fast, but it takes a good while to finish off a syriaca.

  • 8 years ago

    Congrats to Jay and Javiwa on all that caterpillar activity!!

    Sherry

  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Jay: My monarch cats crawl away to find a hiding place and sit still for about 8-12 hours before J'ing. They might J for, dunno, 6-8 hours, then chrysalis. Between molts (i.e., instars stages), they sit still for several hours before molting, IIRC. (It's been a while since I kept track, frankly.)

    I would love to think the monarchs you're seeing are in the same family tree as mine -- 'cause they're sure not hanging around my yard! :/

    It hadn't rained for quite a number of weeks around here, with 95+ temps every day for months, it seems. As we speak, it's raining. :)

    ETA: I bet your swan starts sprouting in no time -- at least there's a bit of one leaf left for some photosynthesis action!