No pics posted.

You can add a piece of stainless trim or if you still have some of the same tile you can trim pieces and add them to the backsplash.

Thanks. We do have some extra tiles. For someone who has never tiled before but is fairly handy, how difficult would trimming/adding the tiles be with a manual tile cutter? I think we will have a tough time getting a pro in here for such a small job.

You will be fine. It's a small area. You need a ruler, manual tile cutter, tile glue. You can do it. Just measure twice and cut once. Follow the pattern of the rest of the tile in terms of spacing. That would be the ideal way so everything will blend and you are not adding another element or something that will bring your eye to that area.

Thanks for the advice! I think I'm going to make an attempt at it. I'll get a few inexpensive "practice" tiles until I get a hang of the cuts. If it doesn't work out I'll give the stainless trim a shot. Wish me luck!

I would check to see if your tile has a matching 1 x 6 pencil liner. If that fits, I think that it will look more finished than a small sliver of tile.

Even a pencil liner in a close color would be fine. It’s not an area of high visibility.

Is this a pencil liner? This my current tile

1 x 6 Sheeted (FireClay Tile)

Try the quarter round (under the "Trim" pulldown) - that'll be closest.

A pencil liner is a long skinny tile. 1/2” or 3/4” usually, x 12” or 6” in length. It’s what makes those great “pencil lines” in the old tile installations where you have an small accent tile running through the field.

Maybe the round liner would work as well. Probably best to call the mfr and ask which piece would work with the space you are filling.

Thanks everyone, I just shot the mfr an email to see what they think. I'll post an update once we make a decision. It's always something with a kitchen reno :)