Software
Houzz Logo Print
94nyrangers

Mixing Countertops in Kitchen

8 years ago

We are about the sign on the dotted line for our cabinets and I am curious what countertops to use. Granted we have several weeks before the cabinets will be made so I have a little time. We are having our perimeter cabinets finished in Cloud White with the island in "coffee." Can I use a solid counter on the perimeter (maybe quartz) and go crazy with the island? I am thinking a "busy" colorful quartizite for the island.

Comments (9)

  • 8 years ago

    I’ve seen many examples of the island ountertop different than the perimiter , its a fun and interesting way to go.

    94nyrangers thanked auntthelma
  • PRO
    8 years ago

    Two cabinet colors, one countertop color or one cabinet color, two countertop colors. Anything else would look busy. If the cabinets haven't been finished yet, go out to the stoneyard and see if you can find some absolutely smashing piece of granite for the island, then make that the centerpiece. The cabinets would be all one color and then you can do a different, more sedate top on the perimeter. Don't use four different colors in your kitchen, it will make you dizzy.

    94nyrangers thanked Carolina Kitchen & Bath
  • PRO
    8 years ago

    I'll just repeat what others have, either TWO cabinet colors and ONE countertop, or ONE cabinet color and TWO countertops.


    Don't forget you have a ton of other elements besides the counters and cabinets like the floors, backsplash, cabinet hardware, paint, not to mention decor and dishes. If you want a show stopping stone for the island it needs to be the star, which means rethinking the cabinets.

    94nyrangers thanked Sina Sadeddin Architectural Design
  • 8 years ago

    Thank you for all the advice. The cabinet doors will be 45 inches with upper panel a leaded glass because there is not enough room to add stacked cabinets to look half way decent. I would say the leaded glass is going to be the show stopper. Good point to keep counters less crazy - I didn't even think of that.


  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    Here are some images of 2 cabinet colors AND 2 counter top materials, it can be done. The back splash in each case relates to either island counter or the floor, it's not a show on its own.







    94nyrangers thanked lucky998877
  • 8 years ago

    I think you can easily have two different counter tops if you like it and if you can find colours that work well together. I have seen white cabinets with grey caesarstone tops together with grey island with whitish marble looking caesarstone top and I think it looks fantastic. I think the trick is to make it work together and not look like you ran out of one choice or cheaped out on one choice.

    Many islands I've seen have dark stained butcherblock type counters and I think that looks fantastic. But it will depend on your style and your needs as butcherblock may be more maintenance than other countertops. All of this also has to work together with your flooring, backsplash and paint choices too. Not a small job to pull all of that together but definitely doable. Perhaps at this point it would be worth your time and money to hire a kitchen designer to help you pull some choices together and provide you with some ideas and options.


    I'm personally a huge fan of soapstone and I think it could look really nice (there are many colours/tones of soapstone) see here and then it can be enhanced or not by using mineral oil or wax or other similar products. Then maybe a lighter colour on your perimeter cabinets.


    Look through some Houzz pictures for inspiration - you should likely be able to find quite a few.


    94nyrangers thanked mvcanada
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    We just combined two different counters! (One color of cabinets though). Blue Pearl granite and Glacier White Corian.

    94nyrangers thanked Donna E
  • 8 years ago
    last modified: 8 years ago

    I think it is possible to have 2 cabinet colors and 2 different counters, but it requires a skilled and confident eye. It also requires a fairly large kitchen to pull off. And also will make other choices of floors, wall color and backsplash significantly more challenging. Luckyblueeye's photos above illustrate this. Just MHO, but I think one of the three pictured kitchens works, and the other two don't.

    Does the OP and/or her designer have the degree of confidence and skill to combine all those elements? Is the kitchen large enough to support the disparate elements? If there is any hesitation on those questions, then do either one counter+2 cabinet colors, or two counters+1 cabinet color. If on the other hand you are sure of your skill, then go for the 2 cabinets+2 counters.

    94nyrangers thanked Miranda33