Software
Houzz Logo Print
angelica_santiago_townshend

Will insurance replace granite if backsplash breaks? cabinets?

Our contractor told us it will be near impossible to save our matching granite backsplash when they reconstruct our kitchen (post water damage). Since this is an insurance claim, Should insurance cover new granite so that it will all match? Also, it looks like from the estimate that insurance is covering to replaced our damaged lower cabinetry, but just to remove and replace the upper cabinets. Our cabinets, however, are a discontinued style, shouldn't they cover the cost of them as a set, both upper and lower?

Comments (8)

  • 7 years ago
    We just went through this in Houston and insurance would not cover upper cabinets. I had a lot of neighbors argue that they would not be able to match the uppers any longer but were not successful. There may have been some that were able to get them approved but I just didn’t hear about it.
  • PRO
    7 years ago
    It depends on your specific insurance policy. If it specifies “replace with comparable quality” you might be able to get what you desire. Read your policy. Get help interpreting language from qualified insurance expert. They can be very helpful.
  • 7 years ago

    ^^^ agree - you need someone on your side here. I had a friend that was an adjuster - there are rules about making things cohesive (like you can't paint one room that is fully open to another, or re-roof a small section...) but there is wide variability in interpretation. And I suspect there are metrics for adjusters these days on giving out the least amount of claim $$$ possible.

  • 7 years ago

    I had water damage to my lower cabinets. Originally my insurance co. covered what yours does. I fought it(on my own) and got them to cover replacement cost for all the cabinets. They also paid for the granite which was broken when their remediation crew broke it in several places. I have a Nationwide replacement cost policy.

  • 7 years ago

    Insurance companies are under tremendous pressure from all the flooding and fires of late. Hiring someone to help you press the right buttons makes a lot of sense to me, as I am sure the insurance company is going to do everything it can to get you to accept less than what they may have to fork out.

  • 7 years ago

    Public adjuster all the way. Our insurance tried this with us but our public adjuster fought and got replacement of everything. Our insurance agent’s face fell when she saw our public adjuster walk in. She knew the jig was up. The adjuster took 15% but got us so much more that we came out well ahead.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    I am a fabricator. We do several water damage jobs a year. We always explain to the customer that even with the best available techniques and tools there's no way to guarantee no breakage will occur when removing previously installed granite. In every instance if something did break the insurance company paid for new tops. I once had a contractor tell me I was responsible for breakage since I was "the professional". I passed on the job.