Software
Houzz Logo Print
lynnstrider

Tile installation: how picky is too picky?

7 years ago

Most important question: Does replacing a tile in the shower damage Redguard waterproofing???


Backstory and more detail: We just had a bathroom and ~500sq foot area tiled on the lower level of our home. We chose a contractor who made us the most comfortable (good communication, seemed skilled and knowledgeable about waterproofing, highly recommended, etc). He was the second-most expensive bid, out of the 4 we obtained. He used Fiberock and then Redguard for the shower.


We paid half up front, and he offered that we could examine the tile job over Thanksgiving weekend, note anything we disliked, and he'd come back to make any fixes and pick up the final check this week.


Overall, I love how the tile looks (evenly spaced grout lines at 1/8, thoughtfully placed niche in shower, etc).




However, there are a few places where I'm considering requesting changes:


1. Along the 2 side walls of the shower, the tiles closest to the threshold are about 1/8 inch longer than the tiles next to them, and the shorter tiles in the rest of the row leave a pretty big gap between wall and floor. Should I ask him to fix this, and will it ruin the shower waterproofing if he has to pull tiles off the wall to fix it?




2. This chipped tile near the drain bothers me (and it does not get hidden when the drain cover is installed). Is it too picky to ask him to fix it? Will it mess up the shower waterproofing to ask him to replace it?





3. There are a few places on the floor with lippage as deep as a quarter. Should I ask him to fix these?




A wider perspective of the flooring in the main room, with blue tape on the corner shown in detail above:


Thanks for your time, Houzzers!

Comments (26)

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Who advised you to tile the entire basement area?

    lynnstrider thanked JudyG Designs
  • 7 years ago

    I am always too picky, so keep that in mind.

    I'd have him fix the floor.

    I'd have the shower tile fixed if it doesn't impact the water proofing. (I don't know if it does!)

    What bugs me most is where a tile is used right next to its twin. This bothers very few people though!

    lynnstrider thanked Fori
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Judy, I appreciate you taking the time to comment, but could you answer any of my questions?


    To answer yours, we made this choice ourselves because our downstairs is a multi-purpose space with a bathroom, workout area (elliptical), kitchenette, guest bedroom, and office. The bedroom and office are carpeted, and the rest is tile. We didn't want to chop up the space with many kinds of flooring in a small area.


    Also, we have pets and wanted something durable and easy to clean. We love the look and function of the tile. :)

  • 7 years ago

    Thanks, Fori!


    I always notice tile "twins" next to each other, too! I spotted a few places where our tile setter did it, but they don't bug me enough to ask him to change them.

  • 7 years ago
    It looks like a good tile job. Big picture the effect.
    lynnstrider thanked wvspinner
  • 7 years ago
    Some lippage is to be expected. Overall it looks like a really good job. I would not have them rip up the shower. I might have them make a few changes to the floor, which is a much easier thing to fix. Beautiful tile!
    lynnstrider thanked K R
  • 7 years ago

    Thanks, wvspinner and Karen Rose! So nice to hear that you both think it looks like a good job. Given my lack of experience (this is my first home, and first ever experience hiring a tile contractor), I appreciate your input!


  • 7 years ago

    I like the tile in the big room a lot. It looks sterile now, of course, but once you move in it'll be really nice. Whoever advised you to tile the entire basement area knows her stuff. :)

    lynnstrider thanked Fori
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Haha, Fori! Our interior designer (yours truly) feels a lot better about herself due to your kind words.

  • 7 years ago

    Laura, it helps to know that the shower drain would bug you, too.


    I hope someone can advise about the potential impact on the waterproofing. I can talk to our tile contractor about the pros and cons, but I'm not 100% sure he'd be completely honest, since of course it is in his interest to tell me it would damage the shower as an excuse not to do a fix. He seems very honest, so I don't think that would happen, but it's hard to be sure.

  • 7 years ago

    It might be less apparent when the drain cover is screwed on. Or it might look worse!

  • 7 years ago

    More important to me is that a)the water-proofing was done correctly and b) the grout lines are consistent, level, and plumb. The tiny chip at the drain wouldn't bother me at all because the only time I look at the drain is when I'm cleaning it. The gap at the floor wouldn't bother me at all except that I believe caulk is supposed to be used when there is a change of plane. The important thing is that all the grout lines are perfect. There is a height difference along the wall and it's much better to put that larger spacing at the floor!


    Look at how all the little triangles around the drain are almost identically sized. I'm not an expert and I'm not particularly particular (lol) and to me this shower looks nearly perfect.


    Overall I think if you leave it no one else will ever, ever notice these things and I think you will quickly stop seeing them too.

    lynnstrider thanked miss lindsey (She/Her)
  • 7 years ago

    Thanks, Lindsey. The shower did pass the flood test, and as best as I can tell (from reading online tutorials to try to educate myself), he seemed to do the Redguard waterproofing appropriately.


    You are right; it is nice how he made all the little triangles around the drain the same size.


    One more question:


    For the transition between carpet and tile, the existing carpet had a metal transition piece. The tile contractor used a metal transition piece at the edge of the tile, and we ended up with 1/8" gap between the two. I don't like how this looks (or feels underfoot), but I have no idea if or how it could be improved.


    Any thoughts about this transition, and whether the gap is OK or could be improved?




  • 7 years ago

    How was the shower pan built? If its a mud pan with the ater proofing under the mud the tile could be removed without damaging the waterproofing membrane...

    lynnstrider thanked Elizabeth B
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    with the drain cover on, can you even see the chip? if yes, then he can carefully cut out that one piece and replace without affecting the waterproofing.

    for the uneven tile bottom in the shower, that should be filled with 100% silicone caulk (not grout) in matching grout color. you really won't be able to see it once it's done.

    tile lippage. is it just that one? you might have had a high spot on the floor, or he could have piled on too much thinset on that one tile. ask him if it's fixable.

    the carpet transition. your tile is thinner than the carpet side. nothing you can do about that except to have floated the entire floor to be even w/the carpet. it's a nice job w/the metal piece. I'd leave it.

    overall, it's a good tile job. head and shoulders above most of the disasters we see on here. Give him a chance to fix what he can. No tile job is 100% perfect. the one you got is pretty close. be happy!

    lynnstrider thanked Beth H. :
  • 7 years ago

    Thanks so much for your time, Beth!


    Yes, the chip is visible with the drain cover on. I will ask him to replace that piece, if he can.


    I think he actually did put caulk along the base of the shower, but it looks to me like he put it very deep in there somehow. Or maybe he has a bit of grout deep in there. Perhaps it will be less noticeable if he adds a bit more caulk. We bought caulk in a color that matches the grout from the same tile store; he told us to buy 'sanded caulk'. Is that the same as 100% silicone?


    There are 5+ tiles that have similar lippage to that spot I pictured. I am thinking about asking him if he can fix the ones that are in the high traffic areas (1 in the middle of a hallway, 2 in the main traffic area through the room). Does that seem reasonable to you?



  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    sanded caulk?? no, that's grout. you want the 100% silicone because that will give you the waterproofing you need in the joints. grout is not waterproof. look for the caulk that matches your grout color. Custom carries it. and RTV carries grout caulk in any color


    and yes, if the lippage is too high and bothers you, ask him if they can be fixed. however, if those areas had high spots, it's too late now. those should have all been leveled out before he started.

    lynnstrider thanked Beth H. :
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Hi Beth,

    For the caulk, he told us to get this stuff: "Mapei Cobblestone Keracaulk Sanded Siliconized Acrylic Caulk", since it matched the grout. (He had told us to pick a color from Mapei's Ultracolor Plus FA line, which we did.) Do you think the caulk is OK?

    Thanks again for your time.

  • 7 years ago

    I just read the label and it doesn't say 100% silicone. the others do. the tile guys over at the forum always specify 100% silicone for those shower areas.

    The one he mentioned does say it's fine for the shower. up to you what you want to use. you could always use a clear silicone deep in that space first, and then when dry, use the colored stuff. sometimes the other stuff tends to shrink and crack after a few years. that's why the 100% is recommended. look at some of the other brands or try RTV. they will match any companies color. search RTV color caulk and you'll see it.

    lynnstrider thanked Beth H. :
  • 7 years ago

    Thanks again, Beth! I will see if I can find the 100% silicone RTV and get it colored to match our grout. Gosh there is so much to learn!

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    No, my question relates to the size of the tiles and if you got professional advice on using so many tiles to cover a basement floor…that’s all.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    JudyG Designs, why would you ask that question? It seems completely irrelevant to the questions I was asking about installation details, which you made no effort to address.


    What answer are you looking for? It sounds like you just stopped by to imply that you don't like the size of the tile we chose, without actually saying it outright or offering anything constructive or useful. The project is nearly complete; we can't go back in time and change our choices (even if we wanted to). What purpose does your question serve, other than expressing your condescension?


    Most people are so kind and helpful on this site, but I suppose there are always exceptions.

  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    http://www.mapeihome.com/mapesil

    Use #103 to match your grout.

    lynnstrider thanked Creative Tile Eastern CT
  • 7 years ago

    Thanks very much, Creative Tile Eastern CT. If our tile setter has already used some of the 'sanded siliconized acrylic caulk', should we put some of this over the top? Or do we need to get rid of the other caulk and then apply this?

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Topical application will not work.

    lynnstrider thanked Creative Tile Eastern CT