Software
Houzz Logo Print
poundridgepainting

Cedar Roofs v.s. Asphalt

Cedar roofs are exceptionally beautiful, eco-friendly, resistant to storms, and energy efficient! However, lack of consistent treatments can lead to cracked or curled shingles, making cedar roofs a high-maintenance commodity. If given the opportunity, would you go for traditional asphalt shingles, or choose a cedar roof?



Cedar roof! Too beautiful to pass up.
Love cedar roofs, don't have the patience.
Asphalt! Love the simplicity.

Comments (18)

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    My neighbor decided that her house "needed" a cedar shake roof. She spent a fortune putting one on it and it's been nothing but trouble. She had to have it all replaced this year (after only 20 years) and this time tried having the shingles treated with some sort of preservative. Our climate (NOT on the ocean but in the midwest!), is hot and humid. It's the humidity that is the problem. When I asked a roofer how it could be MORE humid than right on the ocean, he reminded me that all that ocean humidity has lots of SALT in it and that salt is the preservative that turns all those Cape/Vineyard/Nantucket shingle houses that lovely gray. He also said that the cedar is different today than it used to be and I see that even on the Vineyard - shakes age to a dark/rotted color, not that lovely gray.

    My asphalt shingles look fine and were not nearly as expensive or as much bother. Now, if the question had been about slate, that would have been a different answer!

  • 7 years ago

    A cedar shake roof is beautiful. We had one for 18 years and never had a problem with it. But we live in the woods. In the west. I'm happy we replaced the roof 20 years ago. A little less to worry about in the summer.

  • 7 years ago

    Have you thought about a metal roof?......lots of different shapes and colors....lifetime....

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    They are not very pretty when they burn, they have been a problem for many home owners and honestly cedar burns better than almost any wood why take a chance there are so many nice roofing materials

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Metal?

  • 7 years ago

    I have a Dutch Colonial so when we replaced the roof in 2006, we replaced the 25 year old cedar roof with another cedar roof. Ours has weathered nicely (5 miles from ocean) but our darn roofers went cheapo and used nails that rust on the top where we can't see so shakes are blowing off as the nails rust. On the visible parts of the roof, they used the proper nails and all is good. I need to get a roofer on top this year to do repairs.


    There cedar really won't last as long when it is applied over sheathing like regular roofs. The proper way to do cedar if to lay it over the open slats (not sure of the name) so they breathe. When water hits it, it swells and closes any small openings. My neighbor's 40 year old cedar roof is constructed properly. He said you can see sky though areas but that it doesn't leak.

  • 7 years ago

    Wood shakes are not appropriate with every house style.

    SLATE would be most appropriate for our house, but that wasn't happening! We're fine with architectural asphalt shingles that give a passable impression of slate.

  • 7 years ago

    While cedar shakes are beautiful, they are not an appropriate roofing material in fire-prone areas. In fact I believe they are disallowed by code in some Western jurisdictions. Metal and tile roofs are popular with people who can afford them. Why not add them to your list?

  • 7 years ago

    Cost of shakes + cost of installation labor + cost of insurance = NO.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    The last cedar roof I had installed on a new home was around 2001-2. Since then our Sacramento region has been dominated by concrete tile. The reroof market is dominated by asphalt comp.


    The only cedar roof to consider at this point is jumbo and/or high grade with fire treatments. Mediums we installed have all been replaced and did not last 20-25 years, even on skip sheeting, and they look older than they should after a few years, hurting resale value. Today all homes are built with solid sheathing on the roofs for engineering value, not optimal for shakes.

  • 7 years ago

    I have had 3 homes with cedar shakes, loved those roofs. Cedar is not the same anymore, I had medium shakes on this home and they lasted 20 years, replaced with asphalt shingles apparently good for 50, it will outlive me easy.

  • 7 years ago

    It helps to remember that some materials which were used in the past have been supplanted by newer, and better ones. When building a structure in the early 1900's, locally available materials and workmen familiar with them were the norm. You don't see slate roofs on old homes in the Northwest, while in NE they were popular if you could afford them. Personally, I love the look of a thatched roof....and you can have one IF you can afford to import the reeds and the thatchers.

  • 7 years ago
    fire hazard.
  • 7 years ago

    Not a good idea in SoCal. Our house had cedar as was required by the HOA architectural rules. It burned to the ground along with 90 other homes during wildfires. The house next door was being re-roofed at the time of the wildfires and had only felt installed. It didn't burn at all. When they rebuilt they allowed other roofing options. There are eco-shingles that look like cedar shake but made out of something else.

  • 7 years ago
    Never in a fire area.
  • 7 years ago

    Virgil......you've NEVER heard of metal roofing??

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Did I say that?