Software
Houzz Logo Print
juliebertoli

cooktop for island

7 years ago

Looking for a cooktop and down draft to use for our kitchen island

Comments (5)

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    I can’t help because I really dislike cooktops or ranges in islands and downdraft ventilation is mediocre at best. If at all possible do cooktops or ranges on outside walls

  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I have a cooktop in my island and love it. For the arrangement in our kitchen it works best and I hate to cook with my back toward people. We prefer to cook on the outdoor grill anytime that we can anyway.

    It is a Jenn-Air and works fine for me. No the downdraft does not work perfectly, but honestly it does as good a job as the puny <400 cfm units that everyone is putting in to bypass the make up air requirements. Clean around cooktop each time you cook and grease build-up is not an issue.

    We have installed the Jenn-Air telescopic vents with Wolf cooktops in several kitchens and clients have been satisfied with their choice. They are made taller than they used to be so it helps to capture steam and odors better than in the past. Best also makes a telescopic vent as well. Wolf makes one, but the price is too high to justify.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Downdrafts aren't much use...you're fighting the laws of physics. FOGSS (fumes, odors, grease, smoke, steam) all rise and downdrafts have to fight that. Add to that the fact that there are more and stronger air currents over an open space (island or peninsula), and you are fighting a losing battle.

    If you absolutely must have a cooktop in an island, then I very strongly recommend:

    • Be sure you have a minimum of 24" of counterspace on each side of the cooktop
    • Ideally, there should be at least 36" on one side, with 42" or more better
    • Install an overhead hood, not a downdraft
    • The hood should be at least 6" wider than the cooking surface (i.e., 30" cooktop/36" wide hood)
    • The hood should be at least 24" deep, with 27" deep much better
    • The hood should be installed no higher than the manufacturer's specifications
    • The hood should be 600 cfms or more (the higher the cfms, the lower the speed you can run the hood and the quieter it will be -- or get one with a remote blower so the blower isn't as loud)
    • If there's seating behind the cooktop, you should have 24" of counterspace b/w the back of the cooktop and the edge of the seating overhang
    • If there's no seating behind the cooktop, you should have at least 18" b/w the back of the cooktop and the edge of the counter overhang. (Yes, NKBA says 9", but that's really too shallow -- grease splatters much farther than that!)

    .

    If you must also have a downdraft, then be sure it's:

    • Telescoping
    • It rises from the center, b/w the burners -- assuming you want it to work for all burners and not just the back ones
    • Be aware that it will only work when cooking with pots/pans that are lower than the top of the fan by several inches and right up against the fan (that's why it should be in the middle -- so all burners can be used). It will not work when cooking with pans/pots the same height or taller b/c the FOGSS start out above the fan and keep going up, not down!
    • Don't have gas -- downdrafts can interfere with flames with a gas cooktop (or rangetop/range)

    .

    I'm not just talking via hearsay, I've had actual experiences!

    • I've used a supposedly top of the line downdraft (Dacor) and absolutely hated it! It was very noisy and ineffective!
    • In addition, I had to ban my children from sitting behind the cooktop while I was cooking b/c my son was burned with splattered grease (browning meat), despite the fact that it met the NKBA minimum requirements!

    .

    Are you sure you don't have any other options? If you post a floor plan, perhaps we can help you come up with a better plan that gets the cooktop off the island.

    If you're putting the cooktop in the island b/c you think that's where you spend most of your time, that's not true.

    • 70% or more of the time spent in the Kitchen is spent prepping (Prep Zone with counterspace and sink)
    • 20% is spent cleaning up (Cleanup Zone with a sink and DW and includes loading/unloading the DW, wiping down counters, etc.)
    • 10% is spent actually watching things cook or adding ingredients (Cooking Zone with cooktop/rangetop/range)

    So, what zone should be in the most pleasant/desirable space? The Prep Zone. If you enjoy working in the kitchen with company/spectators, then put the Prep Zone in the island -- an island with at least 12" of counter space + 18" to 24" for a prep sink + at least 36" (with 42" to 48" better) of workspace.

    .

    If you're willing to look at other options, post a fully measured layout of the space and we'll see what we can do!

    FAQ: How Do I Ask For Layout Help & What Information Should I Include?

    New to Kitchens? Read Me First!

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    If necessary I'd go with an induction cooktop for ease of cleaning, lower ventilation requirement and simple flat surface when not in use. Bosch or Miele are good units. Best Cattura has a downdraft with the highest lift and dual level inlets. Here's their ad.-

    .


    .

    .In my kitchen for many meals prep time is minimal and cooking is the 70+%. Everything depends on what you're trying to make. Those stats would be nice to examine but there has never been any source to back them up. I wouldn't consider designing to something like that. Do what'll work for how you work and are comfortable.

  • 7 years ago

    Have nothing to add of experience, but just had to say that was an impressive post, Buehl!!