Hi! Struggling on this...

I need a new dining table that will fit in with my colonial style and mix of antiques and very classic items. This big mouldings and details.

I really like this table: https://www.hookerfurniture.com/sorella-rectangle-dining-table-2-18-leaves/5107-75206-1744/iteminformation.aspx

But it only comes in the faux finish and I'm concerned that it will look fake with my real antiques.

Alternative is this one that is a bit more classic looking because of the finish:

https://www.hookerfurniture.com/archivist-trestle-table-2-18in-leaves/5447-75206-1744/iteminformation.aspx

I do like the latter just really love the dentil work but would hate it to look weird and I also don't love that the chairs for this one don't come with an un-upholstered/all wood version but can certainly live with it (will have to do some serious 3M coating given kiddos).

Help!