Software
Houzz Logo Print
storybookhome

Is the acceptable? Damaged granite installed.

7 years ago
Today we got the granite countertops installed in our tract new build (see, see, I used the correct spelling like y’all so subtly suggested ;)

[[Backstory: This is the “free” builder grade granite. You had to sign a waiver that you could not select your slab of material even if you upgraded so we decided to go with the included option since it matched our floors and cabinets perfectly, we could upgrade with a slab we chose later on our own, and we were concerned about the appraisal going over since we did several other upgrades.]]

We selected an eased edge which I know is more prone to chip than a bullnose. However. This is NEW. We have not used it yet. We haven’t even moved in yet! You can clearly see where the stone was damaged and repaired in several places. One area is pitted and not filled in well. Most chips are small. One is quite large. More photos will be attached in comments. I know this is the freebie option but still.

Our builder has been great about fixing flagged issues so far. What do you think is reasonable? Can we ask for a monetary kick back? I don’t really want them to pull it out even if that is reasonable. The color is perfect and there is no guarantee we’ll get so lucky with another batch. It doesn’t visually bother me too much. The granite is so busy you don’t really see it. I inspected it meticulously. It’s more the PRINCIPLE. I feel it should not be a repaired product in a new home. Or is this par for the course where tract homes are concerned and to be expected?

Thank you.

Comments (22)

  • 7 years ago
    Here is the large area.
  • 7 years ago
    Here is the damaged corner.
  • 7 years ago
    The pit.
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    It is natural stone. Pits, fissures, mineral streaks, inclusions, and color shifts are all normal. Live your life and enjoy Mother Nature made.

  • 7 years ago
    @oak I love the imperfections and uniqueness of natural stone and have always had granite countertops in the kitchen. I’ve never had damaged ones before. The pitting alone would not bother me as my last granite had many small imperfections. But this granite seems actually damaged, not just naturally imperfect. The pit is quit deep and looks like a chunk came out. The side chunk that is missing is about quarter sized in diameter. Honestly it seems like since this was ‘free’ granite not much care was taken with the cutting and polishing and when chunks fell out they just patched it. ‘Free’ or upgraded I think everyone should be given the same care and respect in how their materials are handled. I somehow doubt a Quartzite or Quartz countertop would have been installed with a quarter size chunk missing and replaced with clear filler.
  • PRO
    7 years ago

    I am a fabricator. Fabricators fix chips in the shop quite regularly. The chip repairs you show in the pics are simply poorly done. Stone with black inclusions is one of the easiest to repair because the filler can just be another black spot on the stone. Good news is the fabricator can probably do a better job given the opportunity and willingness to do so The gray one on the corner is not bad IMHO.

  • 7 years ago

    I'd at least request a redo on the fixes. And I'd request the pit be filled as well.

  • 7 years ago
    Thank you for the information @oldryder! The smaller fixes don’t bother me at all because, as you said, they blend. The big chunk freaked me out so then I went over the whole thing with a fine tooth comb to record all the others. I agree as to why it bugs me, it’s a big clear nothing that stands out without any dark speckles mixed in. Can this be repaired on site? Seems like a lot of work to yank it off for something so small and I don’t want to delay our move in. It doesn’t even REALLY bother me visually so much as I want to hold them accountable to what is considered the industry standard. (Just not sure what that standard is). I’m very frugal and believe in quality workmanship and people delivering what is sold to you. Is this something that I should insist be repaired? Is it deserving of a small kickback instead of repair (which I don’t want if it means they have to take off the stone or might damage my cabinets)? Or do I just let it go? The process has been remarkably smooth and I’m very pleased with the GC, builder, design center, etc. Every issue has been addressed promptly and professionally. Before asking our GC, I just what to know what is reasonable. I’m a single woman and this is my first ever house. I want to make sure I don’t get taken advantage of during the process and I have to be my own advocate.
  • 7 years ago
    Please have them repair to make you happy - years down the road you might regret it or ask for $$$$ back so you can replace it yourself
  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Yes, have them repaired properly. And they are NOT "freebies" - they are standard equipment that comes with the house. You ARE paying for them.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    The repairs can easily be redone on site. If needed ask the builder to lean on his granite guy. One of the advantages of going thru a cabinet shop, general contractor, K&B, or whatever, is that as a repeat customer that entity typically has more influence over the granite supplier than a one purchase retail customer. Your attitude is very reasonable IMHO.

  • 7 years ago

    That like saying hey, you chose the lowest grade carpet. Yep it's new. Sorry about the giant grease stain in the middle. But hey, it was "free" (not). You are paying for it no matter which way they try to explain it.

  • 7 years ago

    You're using a 'tract' builder. They found a granite company that will sell them 'junk' granite very cheap. The 'tract builder' can increase their price of their houses because they are offering 'so called free granite' which they are getting for almost nothing!!!! Tract builders will do 'anything' to increase their profits!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

  • 7 years ago

    We have what looks like that same granite. We had a chip on the edge when it was 1st installed and they came and fixed it - I'm sure if I really hunted for it, I'd find it but it is very well hidden - your guys can do better. Also, after that initial chip, it didn't chip again anywhere else. It is a low grade granite, but often they are the hardest wearing. I find it pretty neutral and actually don't mind the look of it considering how cheap it was - we have black and white cabs and it works well with both.

  • 7 years ago

    At least robin spelled "tract" correctly, now we just need another post on punctuation...................

  • 7 years ago

    Excellent response Storybrook Home. I completely agree.

    I currently own a primary home and a beach home. The beach home is a tract build, my primary home was semi-custom.

    Just like you said, each have their pros and cons, and neither of them are guaranteed trouble-free.

    Part of learning to get along in life is dealing with problems as they present themselves, researching solutions, moving forward and hopefully learning something along the way.

    I know the house is new and you want everything to be perfect. But nothing in life is ever perfect (at least once you start living there), and even the large blotch isn't all that horrifying (again, in my opinion).

    I would follow Oldryder's advice. He knows his granite. I wouldn't go
    through the hassle of pushing to have the tops replaced - you take some
    risk of damaging cabinets and then it just snowballs from there. Push them to make the blotch look better cosmetically and there you go. :)

  • 7 years ago

    They should have used a different color filler, but it looks ok. The pit needs to be filled, but the others look alright. Don't let anyone shame you for having a "tract" home. I'm sure it's going to be lovely. I have an upper level granite & it has filler in it. Most people wouldn't be able to find it, but I can. Just because you have filler in your granite doesn't mean that it's crap. Most slab do have it.

  • 7 years ago

    FYI. I thought that large area was a chip, not a repair or flaw, hard to enlarge on my phone. If it's a repair, could have been done better but if its a flaw it is what it is. The color is nice. Can you live with the flaws or not so good looking repair, you may not even notice after a while. I would imagine someone who did repairs on such product would have filler that could be match better with granules of different color granite to mix in on larger "holes". I agree with previous poster, having it replaced could just cause more problems. Maybe leave well enough alone.

  • 7 years ago

    Principle? There is no principle. You are worried about something that you say doesn't bother you but want to complain anyway. Let it go!

  • 7 years ago

    1. i think it is unfair that some posters think that because people live in what is called a tract home they are somehow beneath the semi custom.. 2. all home builders inflate their prices just as all contractors inflate prices.. if people are willing to pay they wouldn't be able to. 3. if you are not happy do not let it go - demand it to be either replaced, a credit given to you for a new counter or have them repair it to your satisfaction. 4. no house is perfect - there are some things we can let go and some we can't.. good luck in your house adventure!!!

  • 7 years ago
    Thanks for all the responses! The principle does matter to me, more so than the visual. If no one calls out manufacturers/builders on subpar work/products, that becomes the norm. Just because I don’t really mind the blemish TOO much doesn’t mean it shouldn’t be done correctly or that I wouldn’t prefer it to look nicer. I spoke to my GC about it and he saw it and agreed it could be better. I reiterated I don’t want a new counter put in (delays to move in, risk to cabinets, gamble of not as great of a color match). He said he would address it and let me know of the resolution. He’s addressed every other complaint (all pretty minor) promptly and satisfactorily so I have no reason to doubt he will present me with a fair solution. IF not I’ll response accordingly, but I’m not expecting a problem. Again, I posted to know what was considered REASONABLE and STANDARD for this kind of thing. I try to be fair to the vendor and to myself. Not trying to get something for free over here, lol. I appreciate the time people took to respond and inform me of solutions. I will update when I find out what the fix is! I agree everything is never perfect in a home build and some of the faults become charm later on! We’ve been remarkably lucky to have a very smooth build so far. My only REAL regret is not adding can lighting to my craft room!! WHAT was I thinking? At least I put in a ceiling light but, ugh. Dumb dumb dumb.