Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_329487632

Engineered hardwood decisions

7 years ago

We are trying to decide between several brands of engineered hardwood.


Option 1. Mullican Wexford

Option 2. Mullican mount castle


Option 3. Castle Combe



Based on reviews online, specs, etc, we were expecting the castle Combe to be the leader. US floors seem to get good reviews. Frankly a bit surprised when we received the sample to find there is only 1 solid middle core vs mutilple plys on the Mullican product.


Mullican Mount Castle is a little thicker than the Wexford product. Same Veneer.


we understand the castle Combe is oil finish, that doesn’t scare us.


Any suggestions or experience? We’re also considering the earthwerks plantatiom 8”. An oiled product.


Thanks.



Comments (5)

  • 7 years ago

    I'm not sure what your second photo is trying to show. I can see multiple plied layers under the wear surface for both samples. Did you load photos of the same sample? There are only 2 photos shown but you have 3 options listed.

  • 7 years ago

    SJ


    Second photo is actually the Mullican Mount Castle line. Looks VERY similar to Wexford.


    interesringly mount castle is more expensive, overall thicker, but has a thinner veneer, 2 mm.


    Ive basically rules out the mount castle because of the thin veneer.



  • 7 years ago

    A few things at play here:


    Thicker veneer only really matters if you think you'll actually be in the house long enough to need to refinish it....


    Also, are you experienced living with hardwood and how hard are you on them? My mom has hardwood floors that she refinished 30 years ago and they still look new because she doesn't move furniture without protectors, she makes sure to sweep up grit and sand and she doesn't wear her shoes in the house. She could buy 1mm thick wear layer and never know the difference, but some people absolutely trash their hardwood.


    Also....refinishing is EXPENSIVE, running between $5-8 sq. ft. It may be cheaper to just buy a thinner veneer layer and in 15-20 years if it is in rough shape just put in new floors instead of refinish.


    Plywood cores are much better than MDF no matter what anyone says. MDF WILL swell and be damaged if it gets wet and is allowed to sit. Plywood isn't waterproof or immune to water damage by any means but it isn't a life and death emergency every time someone spills something. MDF also does not have any structural strength when it comes to deflection resistance. If there are small depressions that are missed in the subfloor or a bit of deflection between joists, MDF will flex more and possibly de-laminate or crack the veneer over time.

  • 7 years ago

    Whoops. Didn’t realize the Castle combe didn’t post. You can see it here.





    And a side by side of all 3.




    We currently have hardwoods. And we are hard on our hard woods. 3 kids, dog etc.


    We take care of them. But are hard on them.


    You raise some some good practical points. Namely, would we rather just replace than refinish, even if we stay in the house for a long time.


    Resale isn’t a concern at this point, it’s a new build. We are looking to furnish with quality materials we like. We don’t have an unlimited budget.


    My my sense is we‘re overthinking all of this.


    the mulkican isn’t bottom tier, not top line, and should last a while provide the install is done correctly.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Look for a 4mm wear layer that will allow you to refinish the floors. Also find a product thats American or Canadian made. That will often mean a high quality and imports. Here is a helpful Engineered flooring diagram.

    Educational Plank Flooring Examples · More Info