Software
Houzz Logo Print
yeh_yeh

Getting quotes this week - Waterproofing for shower

7 years ago

Hello GWers,


I am getting prepare to get quotes from contractors for my 3 bathrooms remodel and would like to prepare myself on waterproofing so I can ask them for their method. I did a search in this forum on waterproofing and read through most of it if not all. I am confused on what's being called "mold sandwich" in one post and "recommended method" in another post.

One post has a comment that install tar paper of 6-mil poly sheeting between the Durock and the studs to prevent the studs from rotting away, another post has a comment this is what's called "mold sandwich" and should not be done. So which one comment is correct?


From what I read:

1. Need waterproofing over cement board (ie. Durock or HardieBacker). There are two kinds of waterproofing, sheet and liquid. Sheet is harder to applied when there's change of plane in close proximity but when installed with proper detailing, the thickness is uniform. Liquid is easier to applied but getting the specified thickness is the key. Also requires minimum of two coats applied perpendicularly. Some liquid waterproofing are RedGuard or Hydro Ban.

2. Shower walls and floor should use the same waterproofing system.

3. 48-72 hours flood test is a must and I need to be present to make sure all the water quickly drains out and in 10-15 mins there are no puddles of water.

4. Shower floor needs to sloped to the drain.

5. Shower curbs need to sloped toward the shower.

6. Silicone caulk should be used at a change of plane.

7. Sanded grout should be used on shower floor.

8. Mastic should not be used on both shower walls and floor.

9. I didn't find much on waterproofing the shower floor, what's the best practice? I am in Northern Cali.


Other than my confusion on the "mold sandwich", is there anything else i need to educate myself before the contractors come for quotes?


I plan to use quartz on shower walls as I don't want grout lines for easy cleaning, is there special preparations required for that? This will be my forever home and I want to make sure everything is done right. Thanks everyone in advance!

Comments (25)

  • 7 years ago

    I applaud you for being proactive rather than waiting until something goes wrong and you are back on this forum asking for help after a bathroom disaster.

    I'm just a homeowner, not a pro. There are a lot of pros on here who can help you if you will post the language of the bids.

    yeh_yeh thanked AJCN
  • 7 years ago

    I was in your position about 18 months ago, gathering bids and getting ready to remodel a master bathroom. I didn't know exactly what a "moisture sandwich" was, but I had heard of it and knew it was bad. So every contractor I met with I said "whatever you do, you need to properly waterproof my shower and not create a moisture sandwich." What I should have said is "put into the contract that all materials and work will adhere to the TCNA and industry standards, and manufacture's instructions." (or some such proper contractual language like that).

    What I ended up with was a contractor who "waterproofed-the-hell-out-of-it" meaning that they installed a double vapor barrier (poly behind and red guard on top). That's a moisture sandwich - 2 vapor barriers. They actually wrote the moisure sandwich into the contract and I didn't realize it.

    Long story short, they did a bunch of other stuff wrong (no pre-slope; holes in the pan; spot-setting the tile which is dangerous, etc.). When we asked questions, they quit the job rather than answer questions or finish the job, and we had to get another contractor to re-demo and re-build everything. I read the entire 2016 TCNA handbook. It's a good education just to read that manual.

    You are doing the right thing to reach out ahead of time, so that you don't end up like me. In the end we got everything worked out and we have a very nice, waterproofed bathroom, but I wish I had been more proactive like you are doing now.

    There are training/certificate organizations for tile pros. I think NTCA and others. Maybe a pro on here can weigh in on those so that you can find someone certified in your area.

    You are already more on top of it than I was. Good luck on your project!

    - SS

    yeh_yeh thanked AJCN
  • 7 years ago
    A mold sandwich is when you either have a exterior wall then cement board then redgaurd or kerdi and you don’t put slits or air holes between walls. Or putting up a vapor barrier behind cement board then redgaurd or kirdi on the walls.

    A good stiff subfloor is what you want 1st. Example 5/8” minimum plywood for tile over 2x10 joists 16oc.
    1/4” cement board only for floors, walls get 1/2”.
    Cement board gets put down in modified thinset the. Screwed and mesh taped.
    I would put schluter ditra for the flooring then tile same method as cement board. Redgaurd over cement board requires 2-3 coats.
  • 7 years ago

    Thanks ssdarb and Mr. Memes! For both showers, one of the shower walls is an exterior wall, so what should be use between studs and cement board? And for the interior shower walls, is cement board over stud and RG over cement board acceptable?

  • 7 years ago
    Im pasting this from a reputable site cuz its clearer put then me explaining it lol

    If you are using a topical waterproofing membrane such as a liquid like redgard or hydroban, or a sheet like kerdi, do not use a moisture or vapor barrier behind your substrate. If you have a vapor or moisture barrier behind your substrate do not use a topical membrane on the front of it. This combination creates two waterproof barriers with your substrate sandwiched between them. any vapor or moisture trapped between them has absolutely no way to dissipate. This is lovingly referred to as a ‘mold sandwich’. It is not tasty. Use either a moisture or vapor barrier behind your substrate or a topical membrane on the face of it. One or the other – never both.

    With that said, if you want to use a topical liquid such as redgard on the seams of your backerboard, after you tape and mud them, you can do so without problems. If your moisture barrier and backerboards are properly installed there is no real reason to do so – but if it will help you sleep at night go ahead and do it.

    If you are using a topical membrane and you have an exterior wall with either plastic facing or kraft paper facing you need to cut slits into that facing before installing your substrate. If you do not it will create the aforementioned mold sandwich. Give moisture or vapor somewhere to dissipate.
    yeh_yeh thanked Mr. Memes
  • 7 years ago

    Would a real pro weigh in here please? This homeowner is doing the right thing by asking ahead of time. Most OP's post after a disaster.

    The homeowner should educate themselves so they know what questions to ask and what to look out for (which OP is doing), but a homwowner should not tell the contractor what products or methods to use. That's just asking for trouble.

    yeh_yeh thanked AJCN
  • 7 years ago

    If you’re considering solid surface shower walls rather than tile, read the installation instructions. You’ll probably find that waterproofing is not needed. I’m planning to use Kohler Choreograph walls and they get installed directly on cement board. I also plan to use a cast iron or acrylic shower base and neither require separate waterproofing.

    yeh_yeh thanked beaniebakes
  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    This will provide you with the questions to ask. https://www.ceramictilefoundation.org/homeowners-guide-to-hiring-qualified-tile-installer

    You want your contract to state all tile work to be in accordance with TCNA, ANSI standards and manufacturers instructions.

    yeh_yeh thanked Creative Tile Eastern CT
  • 7 years ago

    Thank you everyone for all the good comments. I don't know what material facing I have for the exterior wall, I guess I will know when they gut the bathrooms! But don't do moisture barriers on both sides, got that! I will also wait for the contractors to tell me their methods but at least I know when I should be concerned about if I hear certain things from them!

    @beaniebakes The shower walls will be solid surface, but the shower floor will be tiled, with big tiles to minimize grout lines.

    @Creative Tile Eastern CT Thanks for the link, I will study that! The first contractor will be coming this Saturday, trying to schedule another one. And I want to get at least 3 quotes, if not more, to compare.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    This is great - I'm following because I will soon be in the same position. @yeh_yeh, have you selected the quartz slab maker/color for your shower walls? I have been looking at porcelain slab and quartz slab for this.


    Also - I have learned here that sometimes "solid surface"is a specific term that refers to a specific material (Corian maybe?), so sometimes when people say it they don't just mean "one big slab instead of tiles all over the wall."

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    don't any tile setters do 'old school' mud anymore? My guys did it in my shower. (that back wall is exterior)


    this is all they used to do in the old days and those tiled showers held up for 70+ years. A good mud guy can do those walls in the same amount of time it takes to hang CBU and waterproof it. Plus, w/the mud, they can screed it so that it's perfectly plumb/level, unlike your CBU on your studs.

    You'll find that in Calif most of the guys use hot tar for the shower floor. (at least down here in So Cal they do)

  • 7 years ago

    When things go wrong, people always ask to see in-progress photos so be sure to take photos of every step.

  • 7 years ago

    One contractor came and he said he do the following for waterproofing:

    1. Vapor barrier

    2. Hardie Backer

    3. Kefir Schluther cloth

    4. "Dragon skin"? (I think that's what he said"

    Do these add up as "mold sandwich"? It just sound like a lot of layers.


    Another one said he does:

    1. membrane

    2. concrete board


    I am trying to call a couple more contractors but that's what I got today. Do they sound right?

    Thanks!

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Siena/Omega Products

    Siena Dragon Skin is a liquid-applied, fast-drying, high-performance, easy-to-use water-proofing and crack-isolation membrane, formulated to produce a high-quality elastomeric barrier. It is easily applied using a trowel, roller, paintbrush or sprayer. It changes color from light purple when wet, to a dark purple when dry. Dragon Skin is IAPMO Certified and complies with the requirements of ANSI A118.10 and ANSI A118.12. www.siena.omega-products.com



    the first guy w/all the layers is way too much. Click on the Sienna link and read what it says about using it's product. it will prob tell you no barrier behind the cement board.

    here's the Schluter Kerdi system. you don't need any of those other things if using this.



    If using Hardie or Durock cement board, it's either a vapor barrier between it and the studs, OR a waterproof membrane (like Redgard) on top of the cement board. You don't do both or else you will make a mold sandwich.

    I've done many with vapor barrier behind the CBU, proper taping and mortar and no membrane painted on the board. It's perfectly fine.

    * one or the other, not both.

    yeh_yeh thanked Beth H. :
  • PRO
    7 years ago

    And don't use large tiles for the shower floor. 2" is preferable. Remember, you're tiling a "bowl" and can't do that with big tiles. 4" is absolute maximum unless you are using a linear drain with one slope...

    yeh_yeh thanked Avanti Tile & Stone / Stonetech
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    " Remember, you're tiling a "bowl" and can't do that with big tiles. 4" is absolute maximum unless you are using a linear drain with one slope..."

    Correction:

    Outdated innacurate advice. very common to use large tiles and envelope cuts today. round, square and linear drains too.


  • PRO
    7 years ago

    OK....you CAN use larger tiles, but it frequently requires that you cut them up into triangles and such....not something the average homeowner/DIY'ers are comfortable doing. A pro can certainly do this, but my advice remains.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I'm just a homeowner, not a pro. But my tile pro is here right now building one new shower and re-tiling floors and shower/tub combos in 2 others. He doesn't use the cement boards. If you look up the Laticrete Hydroban Board instructions he does that, 100%. You can look at their videos and read the manufacturer's instructions online. There are area reps that you can contact if you have questions. You can also buy a download of the TCNA handbook for about $40 and read the shower sections of that. Very helpful to prepare you to know what questions to ask and what to look out for. There are other companies such as Schluter, Wedi, etc. Laticrete is just what my pro chooses to use. Contractors have their own preferred products and methods based on their experience, availablility, etc. It's good if they go to training sessions, seminars. conferences, etc as my pro does. That's always a good sign.

    yeh_yeh thanked AJCN
  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    NOT stating that it's "bad advice." Just that it may not be a technique that many HO's are able to do....and I've been doing this for over 40 years....

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I'm not a pro or anything approaching one (just someone about to have two bathrooms remodeled), but I thought smaller tiles were preferable because it will provide a less slippery shower floor.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    You are correct, Patti.

  • 7 years ago

    Thanks all for the advise! It never cross my mind to do any of these by ourselves, we are hiring a pro. I might be a pro at something else (maybe at spending money =p) but definitely not DIY Remodeling!!

  • 7 years ago

    If I was getting a tiled shower done today I’d use one of the waterproof foam backer board wall and floor systems from Schluter, Laticrete etc. or I’d use solid surfacing for the walls and a pre formed shower receptor.. Make sure you follow local code and the manufacturers instructions and that your contractor is experience with the shower system. Don’t mix and match products or systems.

  • 7 years ago
    Check out this link from The Floor Elf. Lots of very useful information. https://floorelf.com/waterproof-shower/