Software
Houzz Logo Print
rddee

fireplace dilemma-keep or redo?

7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago

Back to the drawing board on this fireplace. Any ideas on what to do? Keep it? or redo it? If we redid it, we would be keeping it in line with the rest of the style of our home-so probably white brick with a mantel like the photos.

Either way I am getting matching new cabinets on either side and adding floating shelves on both sides as well. I am open to other suggestions as well. Thank you









Comments (28)

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Is the mantel scalloped on the bottom? I'd replace and raise it.


  • 7 years ago
    No the black scalloped piece is “decorative.” Unfortunately there’s no other place I can really put my tv except that wall because I have a large slider on one wall and sofa on the other
  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Draw the room, Add all dimension. Mark the slider in, and the dimensions. Show all openings, entries etc, Post it

  • 7 years ago
    Redo. Redo. Redo. A thousand times redo. All your ideas sound great and will transform your room. When I first saw photo of your fireplace it took my breath away. But in a really bad way. Good luck!
  • 7 years ago
    Here is a very rough drawing of the space. Maybe this will help a little ?
  • 7 years ago
    Put the tv on a console to the left of the fireplace rather than adjacent to the drapes. Get rid of the “decorative” scalloped mantel. Keep any built-ins low to avoid accentuating the shape of the fireplace and chimney.
    Is there a chance you could build (or have built) a straight vertical stone fireplace and chimney facade? If that is possible, it would make decorating the space so much easier.
  • 7 years ago

    Yes, I would build a straight vertical fireplace, then I could have a mantel and something over the mantel. Not sure if I could put the tv on the other side, only because it would be hard to configure the seating to watch it


  • 7 years ago
    Any ideas @janmoyer ? I posted a pic of the layout
  • 7 years ago

    Well here I am again and it looks like we don’t have the budget to replace the fireplace right now. So I am thinking of putting matching cabinets on either side with floating shelves as a start. I created a mock pic with these Cremona latch cabinets. What do you think?
    Yay or nay?
    Or should I stick to plain white cabinets such as this other one pictured.
    Any other ideas? Thanks

  • 7 years ago

    The reason you like the traditional fireplace photo is that the fireplace blends into the wall rather than contrasting with the wall color. The dark mantel, dark firebox opening and black rectangle of the tv overpower the rest of the wall. If you paint the fireplace a couple of shades darker than the walls it will still be the focus but will not contrast so much with the dark elements. I would not go very dark with the new pair of cabinets. And the final touch could be a nice vertical painting above the mantel.

  • 7 years ago

    Like the low cabinets on either side (would consider solid doors for a less busy look) and the shelves. Think you need one over the tv for balance. Would not totally ignore the fireplace/brick. A mantle and a large framed piece will take the eye off the fireplace form....see my very rough sketch attached.

  • 7 years ago

    Forgot to mention...if you can swing it, place sconces to “square off” the slope of the brick. Good luck!

  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Don't buy any cabinet. Every dime in your purse bottom should go in the piggy bank to get rid of it.

    Drywall, a fireproof surround and a mantel. Stone to the ceiling belongs in your mountain lake home : )

    How much of the slider do you need for exit? Which side? I'd flip the sofa and see if you can use the long sofa wall for cabinetry and tv. I really hate a tv to one side of a fire. Hate it . jmho. Especially as they grow ever larger.

  • 7 years ago

    First thing I would do if I " could redo " is to square off the bricks on the fireplace . Then look again !

  • 7 years ago

    Good that you were able to remove the scalloped piece! If I had to live with this for a while, I'd be tempted to address the hanging aspect of the "hood" on this fireplace. Subconsciously it seems incomplete so begs for something under it to "support" that mass, even if it is symbolic and not functionally supporting.


    To be economical, one thought I had was a simple DIY solution: build a U-shaped fake firescreen out of black metal mesh, placed in front of the fireplace opening and sized to fit exactly and directly under the overhang, using a material such as this:


    https://www.homedepot.com/p/Fencer-Wire-4-ft-x-50-ft-16-Gauge-Black-PVC-Coated-Welded-Wire-Fence-with-Mesh-Size-1-2-in-x-1-2-in-WV16-B4X50MHH/308148093





    I'd probably bend the side pieces so the corners were squared like the contour of the overhang. You would need a small piece, so it shouldn't cost much if you could find the product for sale by the foot at a local hardware store; often this stuff is galvanized but you could paint it black. You could even add (drawer hardware) handles if you wanted to make it easier to move and look more intentional.


    Metal mesh fire screens are included in the ideal photos posted above by the OP, so this gets closer to where you want to be without costing much! And helps you to experience what part of the ultimate solution might be when you have the money to drywall in the bricky stuff, etc. A proper firescreen can be a sculptural statement on its own, but that might call more attention than you'd want to the fireplace :

    Cyan Design 02447 Black Finley Fireplace Screen · More Info



    https://www.houzz.com/products/cyan-design-finley-50-fire-screen-in-silver-black-prvw-vr~132888834



  • 7 years ago

    @janmoyer Unfortunately I so need the slider and it is a major focal point of my home, I have tried this and when I place the sofa against the slider it will seem very closed off and awkward-which is why I have the sofa placed against the wall and the tv where it is. My husband does not like TVs above fireplaces which is why we have in Im the corner.

    I would like to replace the fireplace but thinking of having the cabinets and floating shelves even after I replace the fireplace which is why I wasn’t worried about investing in them anyway. What do you think about that?

  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I'm always for putting the money to the BIG PROBLEM first. It will change the way you think about the entire wall. That's what I think : ) The fire and surrounding area need a cohesive consideration, no matter what and on what side. The wall is a WHOLE . I wouldn't peck at it in piecemeal fashion.

    Search Houzz for visuals that really appeal to you and make an idea book.

  • 7 years ago

    Thank you for your input. Makes sense. I’m sure after we redo it I’ll have a different view on the whole wall itself. I’m just itching to change it somehow any way possible lol. But patience I suppose is best

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Replacing the fireplace/chimney is a big, dirty job. Try painting it and the abutting walls the same color. I happen to like black because your t v is going on one side.


  • 7 years ago

    Wow!! Love Jan’s black wall/fireplace!! Not only would that make the hulk recede, it would absorb TV, plus you could put wall shelves on either side. Fabulous!! Go for it

  • 7 years ago

    Wow black would be a stark contrast to the rest of my home. What about all white?

  • 7 years ago

    How about a really dark, blackish green for the wall?

  • 7 years ago

    Love the black idea!

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Laurie…it is Judy, not Jan.

  • 7 years ago

    Super dark green is brilliant! It looks like there are many shades of green in the rug that the OP has in this room, plus other green touches.

  • 7 years ago

    As others have said the scallop is off along with the placement of the shelf. But what look are you trying to go for? I’m posting several. You need balance/symmetry to pull this off and your width should be similar. So if you have the television on one side, then have a similar sized piece of art above the matching chest. They also have televisions which display art when the television is not in use which may give you additional possibilities.

  • 6 years ago

    I am having a similar problem. What did you decide to do with your fireplace rddee?


Sponsored
Wannemacher Interiors
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars26 Reviews
Customized Award-Winning Interior Design Solutions in Franklin Cnty OH