I'm confused. All three pictures are different, but there are only two to vote on?

Yes, confusing but dark leather couches do not say Caribbean to me. Maybe something lighter????

You have a LOT of gray and a LOT of accessories. That feels cold and fussy not comfortable and elegant.

There is a good bit going on in the rooms. Would suggest your pare down it you can. I agree with barebay57 - the black leather furniture seems out of place in a Caribbean setting. I do like the mirrored window but thing it might be better if the frame were a beautiful Caribbean inspired color. Good luck!

Please see calastra's other post on this room to clarify what she wants to do and see all the ideas that were suggested.

Neither choice appeals to me. I'd go for light, airy, clean lined. You can have these attributes and still attain elegance. Elegant living, to me, is much more than my decor, especially fussy decor.