Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_39177052745

10% up charge on Labor?

7 years ago

We purchased Laminate (wood looking) interlocking planks from Lowe's (yeh yeh I know), and opted to go through Lowe's for install as well.

The third party company they contract out did the measurements (five rooms total). Red flags were up when we looked at threshold measurements, and found that they allocated 52 Linear Ft. of threshold in lieu of the actual 15 (a 37 lf. difference to be exact). Foot note here that Lowe's charges us $ based on measured sq. ft. of the area.

Hubby (re-)measured the area: our numbers = 765 sq. ft., Lowe's = 860 sq. ft.

When we brought up the discrepancy to Lowe's/Contractor, we were told that 'Industry Standard' is to add 10% to ALL measurements, not just for material, but as well for LABOR!

My hubby has been a Construction Engineer for over 20 years, and this is news to him.

Just want to reach out to all pros and non-pros to see if anyone can confirm/deny this?

Thank you!


Comments (24)

  • 7 years ago

    I have never used a big box store for materials or labor. But, with my contractors, I have had 10% overage to all measurements, which makes sense to me. I have not had that apply to labor. Labor always seems to me to be an estimate of time and then adjusted at the end based on actual time for the job.

    Jora thanked Kendrah
  • 7 years ago

    Thanks Kendrah! Likewise it's our first time using a big box store.

    We are used to 10% added to material for waste, (not Lowe's), but the company that they contract out to is adding 10% overage for labor as well. They are trying to convince us that it's 'industry standard' and 'everyone does it'.

  • 7 years ago
    When you go through a box store the price given upfront is the price you pay for the entire job regardless of time spent.

    When you go through a normal contractor you get an estimate that changes through the job based on time and materials spent and used.

    That’s my guess on the labor upcharge, and materials upcharge seems reasonable only if any unused can be returned for credit (unopened boxes, etc).
    Jora thanked Donald
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    As applies to laminate - 10% overage on materials (refund on any unopened boxes) is normal. Labor is based on ACTUAL square footage. As a caution, some Big Box installers are excellent, some are hacks. I would avoid using ANY installer who can't provide references that you can see in person. Quality installers are proud to "show off" their work.

    Jora thanked chiflipper
  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    It is standard industry practice to add 10% so that one doesn't run short of material if several pieces are shipped damaged, or get broken during installation. Oh, and one other thing: product is sold in full boxes, not by the square foot. So it's possible that getting to 10% overage means you might have to buy an extra box of product because they won't split a box. Same with tile, FYI.


    Yes, you might have some material left over, but that's actually a good thing in the event of a water leak or some other minor disaster that would require floorboards to be replaced somewhere down the road. Can't speak to 10% on labor costs; have never seen that unless there's a change order.

    Jora thanked Sabrina Alfin Interiors
  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Hi Everyone,

    Thank you for the responses/info./suggestions. I do understand about the 10% overage for Material, and that's not an issue at all as worst thing is to be in the middle of the project and not have enough material (FYI we actually ordered more then 15% overage for material). The contractor who Lowe's is going through, however, is trying to convince us it's INDUSTRY STANDARD to upcharge 10% for the MEASUREMENT! Four different measurements say that the ACTUAL measurement is 765, and the contractors is charging us for 860 because of his insistence on 10% upcharge FOR LABOR.

    (sorry for the caps, I just want to emphasize those words...not yelling...).

  • 7 years ago

    We’ve done a lot of projects around our house with different companies and labor was always based on actual sqft.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    This topic is the reason amounts are never written into a contract. Include the areas to cover, products to be used, assorted details. Breakdown will consist of material, tax & labor. Price is for a completed project. You will not be asked for more $$ unless there is unforeseen structural damage. All appears normal to me. If 860 s/f is the amount of material estimated for the job it would also apply to labor. That material is picked up, driven to the jobsite, carried into the house and distributed to different locations. If there were extra you can reverse the process. For example - You want to carpet a 10'x10' room which is 100s/f. Carpet is produced 12' wide. So instead of 100s/f you will purchase 120s/f. You do not get 20s/f of credit for carpet, pad or labor.

    The bottom line is all that matters!!!


  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    If he touches the boxes to bring them to the job site, you get charged for it. It doesn't matter if you think that isn't "labor worthy". Everything anyone touches carries a charge to touch it. It isn't free. Thresholds don't get pieced out of leftovers. You can get 1, and maybe 2 out of each piece.

  • 7 years ago

    Foot note here that Lowe's charges us $ based on measured sq. ft. of the area.

    Well, there you have it! You’re being bamboozled.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Thanks everyone.

    We have already purchased ALL the material and as well have had it delivered and distributed to the individual rooms, individual of the contracted company.

    They will be removing the existing floor, installing new floor, and baseboards. We are charged different fees for each of these different items PER sq. ft. (i.e. x amount for removal of floor per sq. ft., x amount for putting down the planks per sq. ft., x amount for baseboards per lf., etc.)...

    Lowe's said the installers have told them that the 10% is the industry standard.

    This is NOT industry standard as they've chosen to label it, rather it's their chosen path of making additional money.

    Just a quick footnote, this company also doesn't do an actual, detailed measurement of each room, rather they do it as a FULL rectangular or square (i.e. in lieu of charging us for 3 sq. ft. of a small opening, they opted to charge for 30 sq. ft.).

    When I questioned him, he said, and I quote "these little bits here and there don't really make a difference" ????

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    For a contractor who hires subs to install, it makes sense to pay the sub for the exact amount ordered and charge the customer the same way. Otherwise it's likely to lead to squabbles between the store and subs they rely on.

    In the end we're probably talking about an amount that might be less than $100.00. Butting heads with a sub repeatedly over an amount <$100.00 could lose you a good sub.

    Jora thanked Johnson Flooring Co Inc
  • 7 years ago

    Or cause a good sub to feel beaten up and you end up with a mediocre install.

    Jora thanked millworkman
  • 7 years ago

    I just went through a situation last year where the flooring retailer (not a BB store, btw) sent a person out to measure, and then grossly oversold me on the square footage of the material as well as the installation (priced by the sq. ft based on the sq ft of material). Plus they then "lost" the excess carpet that I had paid for.

    For your installer to charge based on the actual square footage sold to you by Lowes, with the same 10% cushion already built in, makes sense. For them to be doing their own measurements and padding them, and then doing an additional 10% for labor when it is labor that you are hiring them separately for from the get-go makes no sense; and sounds like he is trying to squeeze you.

    You could ask Lowe's for a referral to someone else. How much extra $ are we talking about here?

    Jora thanked raee_gw zone 5b-6a Ohio
  • 7 years ago

    HI Everyone,

    Although the difference in price does matter, it's not really about the $$$ amount as much as it is about regulations and honesty.

    Not only he is charging an additional 10% overage on LABOR, but as well he was inflating the measurements: i.e. 53 lf. in lieu of the ACTUAL 15 lf. That is NOT a small difference...that is huge!

    We have already decided not to go with this contractor through Lowe's, but I still wanted to find out if the 10% uncharge on measurement/installation is industry standard.

    Thank you again Everyone.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    It's foolish to get hung up on how someone figures their price. What matters is THE PRICE. Get a couple prices, compare them and choose.

  • 7 years ago

    I did want to echo a previous poster about the problem with buying trim and threshold, though, because they are indeed sold in set lengths (ie 10 ft) and there tends to be a lot of waste from cutting sections to fit your specific space, leaving leftover lengths that can't be used elsewhere. So they may need to buy, say, 6 lengths when basic math might make you think you only need 3 or 4.

  • 7 years ago

    Not sure why Houzz keeps changing the word up-charge to uncharge???


  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Johnson's flooring...It's not foolish to get hung up on any pricing when the place you are ordering/installing from (in this case Lowe's) has a FIXED price based solely on actual measurement.

    Raree - Their info. wasn't about how much threshold we need to purchase rather how much the ACTUAL footage was.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    It is for me. If I don't like the way I feel someone is pricing something, I'll go elsewhere rather than arguing.

    Jora thanked Johnson Flooring Co Inc
  • 7 years ago

    Johnson Flooring - Exactly why I'm not going with them.

    I wasn't arguing with them, rather my OP was to find out if this indeed is 'Industry Standard'.

  • 7 years ago

    Good for you, Jora, for not falling for that crap. If someone’s willing to fudge the numbers on a document they’ll have no problem fudging the install, too.

  • 7 years ago

    I greatly appreciate the positive feedback Sammy. On the same page as you!