Software
Houzz Logo Print
holly_stockley

Clad Wood Window Selection

7 years ago

I begin to think that window selection might be one of the most challenging aspects of a new build. I'm hoping for a bit of guidance, here.


Currently, my project has Pella specced - The 450 series for the most part, with a few from the Architectural line in order to get custom grilles for certain windows (which Pella only offers in that line).


However, there seems to be a general bias against Pella on the boards here, although it's hard to week through all the review posts and get a clear idea why.


OTOH, my builder has a clear bias against Anderson, based on the poor performance of the local sales rep. (It's hard to get issues resolved. And, as he pointed out, any brand can have issues). He also seems to have a little resistance to Marvin, I think for a similar reason.


Sooooo... The house contains mostly casements, with some awnings in the bedrooms, and a couple of double-hungs just to prevent smacking people on the screen porch with a swinging casement. We're looking for aluminum clad wood. Custom grilles are rather integral to the look of the house, at least in a few places. Availability in red exterior finish, with interiors primed to paint would be a big plus.


The project is in West Michigan. There is a local "elite" dealer for Jeld-Wen (meaning they carry the full line and have an authorized sales rep), a dealer for Windsor and one for Loewens. LePage doesn't seem to do the local dealer thing at all.


What would you all recommend as a good quality window, and how best to present it to my builder that won't cause him too much angst over using something that's an unknown quantity?

Comments (9)

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Builders don't typically have long term usage history with a given window and tend to base their opinions on rep interactions and service. Still a valuable evaluation criteria, but not one that the remodeler would usually value over product and service after the fact.


    I would skip the other brands you mention except for the Loewen. Might be good to just take a look at the other options and then lean on your builder if you seem to like one over the other.

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    Holly -

    Depending on your budget, I would encourage you to take a closer look at Windsor. Loewen is an excellent product but may price out higher than you want. Windsor products provide quality and value, due in part to our relationship with our parent company, Woodgrain Millwork -- one of the largest millwork operations in the world. If you are interested in learning more about Windsor products, please feel free to reach out to our Western Michigan sales manager: Mike Rollier, mrollier@windsorwindows.com.

  • 7 years ago

    As it turns out, Kolbe apparently also has a presence here. So I'll put that on the list, as well. Tuesday will probably turn into "run around and get quotes" day. Although, naturally the various dealerships are each about 30 minutes out - in more or less opposite directions. So - thoughts on Loewe vs. Kolbe while I wait for LePage to respond to an email?

    The project is a Swedish farmhouse, so "old house" detailing is a plus.

  • 7 years ago

    Loewen and Kolbe are solid choices, Lepage is very nice wood window and also a solid choice. A lot of the bias against Pella has to do with the design issues that remain to this day with no real regard for correcting them Clad wise from what I know is the main issue and the fact that they still to this day use roll form on their sash exterior. Add the fact of they way they have always gone to market and their mediocre at best performance numbers plus at the very least in my area the lack of customer service.

  • 7 years ago

    millworkman, I was hoping you might weigh in. Lepage doesn't appear to have any sort of "find a dealer" function on their website. And my Google-Fu is failing me. Any ideas of what to search for?

    While I'm at it, do any of them do a better job than others at things like good looking SDLs?

  • 7 years ago

    West Michigan, sort of Greater Grand Rapids.

  • 7 years ago

    Let me see what I can find out for you.

    Holly Stockley thanked millworkman
  • 7 years ago

    Thank you much, I appreciate it!