I don't have it, but I DO remember reading someone's post that they had the Create Good Sink with a seamless drain, and said it wasn't easier to keep clean. Sorry, I cannot find the thread.

Edited to add: found the thread! It was Nidnay's comment:

[https://www.houzz.com/discussions/sinks-drain-location-julien-vs-creategoodsinks-and-prep-sink-question-dsvw-vd~5136025[(https://www.houzz.com/discussions/sinks-drain-location-julien-vs-creategoodsinks-and-prep-sink-question-dsvw-vd~5136025)

Thank you SO much Shannon_WI. It had not occurred to me to check for feedback on the basically identical Create Goods sink.

I'm still a little torn. The commenter says the rubber part still gets filthy, but that is the case with my regular drain as well - the rubber gasket leading to the garbage disposal is gross. But that edge around the drain - sometimes with a logo imprinted on it! - is still a gunk collector as well. So is she describing edges that STILL exist within the drain, or new edges that are created further down???

I don't expect this drain assembly to solve all my gunk problems. I just want therm reduced. So I would cry foul if it just MOVES the problems to a different spot.

I have the create good sink seamless drain, I love it, it’s one of the reasons I chose the sink. The rubber gasket is easily removable for cleaning, I put mine in the dishwasher once in awhile

Thank you, Sue! That's exactly what I wanted to hear. I was feeling silly about letting the Perfect Drain weight my choice towards one sink, if it was a totally worthless feature. I'm thrilled to hear you think it makes cleaning easier.

Thanks, shadowpiper! The lack of gunk is exactly what I am after!

@southeasthouse which sink did you end up going with and do you love it? Or anyone else reading this thread. Do you have one of these drains and do you think it's helpful or not? I'm starting a remodel in a couple weeks and I'm having the same dilemma. Thanks!

We also have an Elkay sink with perfect drain and really like it—no issues whatsoever and we cook a ton. Both sides are so much easier to clean than the old style models.

I love the drain in this Franke Peak:

I ended up deciding on this little beauty 33" Elkay Fireclay 40/60 Double Bowl Farmhouse Sink with Aqua Divide (small bowl to the left with the disposal)