Software
Houzz Logo Print
bpath

About Subway tile

7 years ago

I don't DARE post this in Kitchens lest I be excommunicated and declared a demon, but . . .

I've seen a lot of vintage kitchens in my day, and I just haven't seen a lot of subway tile. It does, and always will, remind me not only of, hello, subways, but also my brother's vintage bathroom in his vintage building. It does indeed have the original subway tile, but they are smallish. and, well, there. subway and bathroom. Not kitchen. For me, anyway.

I know it's considered classic, but more classic seems to be 4x4 tile laid in a grid.

And that's my second-glass-of-wine-because-it's-Friday soapbox of the week.

Next week will be stone around the bottom of a house. Trust me, I've been driving around a lot and am looking for it in old houses.

Comments (31)

  • 7 years ago

    What is it you're wanting to know or has the wine taken over? lol. Classic subway tile is 3" x 6" which is what we have for the kitchen back splash with small red diamonds every foot or so.

    Pick me up on your next trip, I love to look at old homes! :)

  • 7 years ago

    You have me laughing, bpath!! I do like the subway tile look. Not the inordinate amount of grout.

  • 7 years ago

    That's a good way of saying it cawaps - some things go in and out of style over the years and some things just go out.

  • 7 years ago

    I just think they are kind of innocuous - don't grab a lot of attention, do the job, etc. We don't have subways in the PNW so I don't have any notions about where they belong, whether in or out of style, etc. I don't know if I'd ever use them, but maybe - if I couldn't find something I liked better.

  • 7 years ago

    Well, a good brisk walk in the fresh air helped! But maybe it's just that everything I see from 1930s onward is 4x4. And every time I clean my late-90s 8x8 tile, I appreciate that it's a grid, just a long line of grout to clean in one fell swoop.

    I'm sure after my Colin Firth movie (he's sailing around the world!) I'll feel even better. No assurances on changing the subway tile stance, though.

  • 7 years ago

    I have subways in my guest bath and kitchen backsplash. I like them, whether this is their moment or not. My family and friends don’t care a whit.

  • 7 years ago

    I love it.


    It was original to my 1940 kitchen.



    And is original to my 2014 kitchen too. ;-)




  • 7 years ago

    And Jen, both kitchens look great :)

  • 7 years ago

    I like them but I'm also liking the 4 x 4s a lot these days...Look "fresher" now. Funny how that works, huh? :P Heed that urge to remind people of subway tile's dated period, cawaps. We need to be more mindful of decor trends. And by mindful, I mean understand how crazy it is to think we 'should' be on top of these expensive trends for our homes.

  • 7 years ago

    The customs and habits of mankind are perpetually changing and however we may affect to despise the innovation or fashion it is impossible long to resist its influence." (quote from the Humphry Repton thread)

    I'm sure I'll come around to the charms of subway tile just in time for 4x4 to come back. Hey, the 4x4 is already a real part of the MCM style, just don't see many people using it in MCM decor these days.

  • 7 years ago

    But .. but .. creamy subway tile goes with everything! (Unrolling my eyes now.)

    I'm glad 4x4s are coming back. We have them in our 1994 kitchen, so hopefully when we sell this year, we'll be right on trend. Heh, yeah.

  • 7 years ago

    I am enjoying reading this thread. Yes, they are classic, but yes nothing stays at the top of the desirability style list forever. Trends do come and go, and I agree that while subway tiles were never considered a poor choice, they were not the easy go to that they are now.

    The 4 by 4 grid style was dated for so long and now is trending back according to those in the know. (not me- I am just copying what I read).

    The one thing that I find different is that typically when something old becomes new and fresh again, it is usually tweaked a bit to differentiate it from the old old.

    KWIM?

  • 7 years ago

    I've never had a kitchen with subway tile, not my thing. It's fine in some kitchens, and seems like an easy choice in most. For those of you that do not like subway tile in the kitchen, what do you have and/or what would you use instead?

    Also, in what movie does Colin Firth sail around the world?

  • 7 years ago

    Thankfully, when my kitchen was "upgraded" in the early 80s they put 4 inch WHITE tile as a backsplash! I don't think it's the size (4 inch, 8 inch, subway) as much as it is WHITE that's classic. White IMO NEVER goes out of style. It's just there and it looks good and it doesn't matter whether you have wood, white or blue or green cabinets. It goes with all and it's not "trendy" like some of the other backsplash tile. Not that it won't look "dated" in some people's eyes eventually but it's just there and doesn't compete with countertops or cabinets. How many posts have we seen where someone is looking for a new backsplash because the green glass tile doesn't look good with the new granite countertop they've installed. White would have looked good!

  • 7 years ago

    Well white doesn't always look good, if you have your heart set on a brownish granite with gold. But I do love a white or cream kitchen. I love other kitchens, too, even oak (that does it, Kitchens will have my head for sure). As long as I can find the coffee! My 1955 townhouse had the original white cabinets, but they were metal so a bit clangy, but I always had a place to stick a magnet with a note or a recipe :)

    Maybe it's just that I have trouble with the word "timeless", especially for subway tile. There was a long time, 50+ years, when it wasn't used. So maybe "retro"or "classic" are the better words for it. And of course, "retro" is "trendy", so who even knows anymore lol!

  • 7 years ago

    White was seriously out of style for quite a while back in the late 20s and 30s. White was the ultra-budget choice, just like a clawfoot tub in the bath, during that period. So a lot was put in, because just buying a house was always a stretch, but it didn't pretend to be stylish. Having a bathroom was the trendy part. (You could buy house plans and kit houses without bathrooms at least up until WWI, and I don't mean summer cottages.) But especially once colored fixtures came out in 1927, color was the thing if you could afford it.


    Yes, bpath, subway mania drives me crazy, too. It appears that all you need to do a "historic renovation" for any time during the 20th century is white subway tile and a hex floor. I'm befuddled by all the people in the bathrooms forum who have splendid old mud-job tile from the 40s through 60s who are ripping it all out to make their bathroom "mid-century". What particularly bugs me is trying to find colored tile in the right shape. You mostly can only get it by having it custom-made, but there's plenty of tile in lovely colors in modern subway shapes. Grr.


    Anytime someone uses the word "timeless" I know I'm going to be looking at the most datable momentary trend there is, when I look at their pics.

  • 7 years ago

    This bathroom. I was online-snooping all the houses in a neighborhood, and this is the one with the un-updated bath. Sigh, even the wonderful Stanley Andersen house had been "updated".

  • 7 years ago

    Subway tile is not for me either, but that's not to say I don't like it in alot of other kitchens I see.


  • 7 years ago

    That's a nice looking bathroom, bpath! I hope the new owners will be inspired to keep it.

  • 7 years ago

    all you need to do a "historic renovation" for any time during the 20th century is white subway tile and a hex floor.

    This describes the bathroom in the 1920s prewar apartment I grew up in, where my parents lived for almost 50 years. The kitchen had no tiles, no backsplash at all.

    I had white 4x4 tiles in our kitchen in the old house for 25 years. New tiles in new kitchen will be 4x4, blue and white, either Tabarka or talavera. I tend to be a creature of habit : ) .

    I grew up in NYC in the seventies so subway tiles for me also evoke a particular... aroma. Which definitely should not be associated with any room in a house, especially the kitchen. I have to try to forget that when thinking about backsplash recommendations lol.

  • 7 years ago

    Subway tile is just fine. My issue with it is that Everyone Has It. Like. everyone who has redone a kitchen in the last 10 years...probably 85% of them have used subway tile. At least it seems that way.

    In my last kitchen, I had slate tile similar to this. I still liked it 12 years later when we moved.


    In our beach cottage, we have herringbone marble tile, which I still love. Similar to this.


    We are redoing the kitchen in our new/old house this fall, and I may do something like one of these. Haven't even looked at any tile yet, just poked around on Pinterest.



    I think many people get scared when confronted with all the tile options out there, and choose subway tile because they've seen it everywhere and therefore can envision it more easily than other options. That's my assumption, anyway.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I spent some time with a dear friend today. When we walk by/in shops, we have decidedly different focuses. She's about jewelry and textiles, I'm about house goods. We walked by a tile shop and I pulled up short. She sighed "bpath, you're the only person I know who can have an org@$m over tile." In the next block she laughed when I stopped to take these pictures (right after she tried on an opal ring). We have a lot of fun.

    Edit to add that this is glazed tile, needs some work. Our winters can be brutal.


    This building has some empty storefronts, and the antique-y shop we'd been in is being effectively kicked out (hiked-up rent), which will leave it nearly empty, so I suppose the building owner is going to do something -- like remove the timeless subway tile?

  • 7 years ago

    Our first house was built in 1942. I had Lots of 4x4 tile in the kitchen and bathrooms. Funny, I seem to remember the kitchen counter being 1x2 tiles. I'll have to try to find pics. Function was a disaster in there. I had one counter, divided in two by the original sink. A freestanding stove next to the fridge. No countertops on that wall, with hardly any prep space. Still, I miss that house. It was so dang cute!

    In my kitchen reno I chose Glacier White Corian countertops and 18" backsplash. It has a very quiet look that I like, at this point in my life.

  • 7 years ago

    We had paneling on our BS, and I put in glass mosaic after we put in the blue pearl counters. I really still like it.





    We need to renovate our hall bath. The work we did some years back was not meant to be a long-lasting fix. The walls are at least 6 layers deep in paint and wallpaper and need to be taken down to the studs. We have 4 x 4 tile in there now, but it was tiled over other tile. I would like to bring back the retro color. The 4 x 4's are still available though the big box stores and other retailers as I've seen on RetroRenovation. The guy at Lowe's looked at me like I was insane when I asked about color tile, saying no one has asked about that "in decades." Of course, DH says we are not moving if we put in color tile because the first thing someone would do is rip it out. We had to re-do the floor tile a couple of years ago, so that will stay. It is another retro pattern in pinwheel B&W. I would like to take the tub out and put in a shower pan, but I can't win that battle.


    Of course, if we went with B&W wall tile, we could look at subway.






  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Ooh, that pinwheel pattern, nice. And the color tiles now are great if you are not trying to match existing tile. The colors are, of course, slightly different but also the thickness of the tile and the curve at the edge. We discovered this when trying to extend the tub tile higher up the wall, above the shower head. We ended up doing a different color for one row, then the closest we could find to the existing grey. But we could always see the difference in the shape. If we were doing it nowadays, 25 years later, I'm sure I'd be here at GW getting resources for authentic tile!

    Your mosaic tile is lovely, and with the mixer, perfect! (Cool seat in the bath, too.)

  • 7 years ago

    My in-laws summer cottage has a stone foundation. I think it was built in the 1940's.

    Subway tile neither rubs me the wrong way nor does it excite me. I have standard subway tile in the kitchen - matte and sort of a beigy colour that seems to recede. Behind the stove is a beautiful mosaic copper tile and that's what I see.

  • 7 years ago

    I just like the simple, clean lines of white subway. While the more elaborate tile shown upthread is pretty, I can see myself tiring of it. I prefer my art to take center stage in most rooms, and with an open kitchen, dining and living area, subway provides the unobtrusive backdrop I desire. I don't think it's necessarily true that people choose it because they lack a vision for anything else. Probably many choose it because it's exactly what they like and want.

  • 7 years ago

    Probably many choose it because it's exactly what they like and want.

    Bingo!

  • 7 years ago

    AT LEAST it doesn't clash with the countertop! I have lost count of all the backsplashes that look awful with the patterned countertop. It doesn't matter if it is granite, marble, quartz, or laminate. Top of the line, can't spend any more money on either or bargain basement price. They put patterned backsplash with a patterened countertop and it ruins both of them!

  • 7 years ago

    I'm really, really not afraid of colors and patterns and shapes. If I fall in love with a tile-I won't tire of it. And the current house really supports tiles that I love, My problem is I fall in love with very expensive tiles.

    So wherever I have subway tiles -they're handmade and also not very cheap(and it was a battle with my DH to go with them too, handmade character softened the look somehow-see, we don't associate them with subway 'cause our subways were all clad with marble and granite and elaborate mosaics etc-but public restrooms, these had subway tile), and they're there because they were what I liked best and could afford under the circumstances.

    (except for the abomination of our fireplace where they put in the whatever they has at their diposal the last moment to pass the final inspection. I hope to redo it all.)