Software
Houzz Logo Print
carla3127

Main floor renovation plan

7 years ago

Thoughts on this main floor reno plan?

Comments (39)

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    What are your goals for the Reno?

    It does jump out at me that it directs a lot of traffic right through the working part of the kitchen.

    Is it a split-level/tri-level house

  • 7 years ago

    Yes what are your goals and what does it currently look like? The mud room is in the wrong spot to be used much as it is not natural to walk into it and all the traffic is through the main part of the kitchen. What is the large closet with double doors By the entry? The office is very oddly shaped. What are the plans for the space between the kitchen and the living room?

  • 7 years ago

    Any way to make the new garage have a side entry rather than the way it is now? This house will end up looking like one big garage otherwise...

  • 7 years ago

    It is a reno on a side split! Here is the before and after...

  • 7 years ago

    I think the door from the garage has to be moved into the mudroom...I also worry about the traffic flow into the kitchen but not sure that can be changed...Not sure what to put between the kitchen and living space...

  • 7 years ago

    How big is your lot? Bri brings up a good point

  • 7 years ago

    And i absolutely would not want my kitchen to be a main thoroughfare

  • 7 years ago
    <?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><md>Can’t turn the garage around
  • 7 years ago

    What about the kitchen where it’s placed? It’s not good

  • 7 years ago

    It would be hard to move the kitchen since the nook is where the kitchen table sits and we don’t want to have to move that structure...Trying to make the best of things...

  • 7 years ago

    Move the kitchen into the nook and table where kitchen is. Better to walk through dining area than walk through a heavily used work zone.

  • 7 years ago

    I would take that area where you have the pantry and make it part of the kitchen- the workhorse part. Where you have the range I would make floor to ceiling shallow pantry cabinets instead ( it will be the thoroughfare still but you won’t be cooking in there so it will be less problematic).

  • 7 years ago

    I thought of switching the stove and fridge? Or turning the island around?

  • PRO
    7 years ago

    With the stairs located where they are, it's a very long trek from upstairs or downstairs to the kitchen, laundry and garage.


    Are you sure you want to make this journey many times a day and night?

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I miss my similar split!

    Can I hazard a guess that currently, the kitchen is straight ahead of the doors, the living room to the right, and the dining room behind the living room, next to the kitchen? Do you currently have a door from garage to house? Some did, some didn’t,

    Would you consider moving the kitchen to the left of the front doors, facing front?

    Do you need a four-car garage for cars (plus a bay for bikes, yard equipment)? Do you have a subbasement, below the main living space? Could you create a daily family entrance in one of the existing bays?

    Please let us know more about your needs that are not being met by the current house, and what your goals for the addition are. And what you told your designer.

  • 7 years ago

    Here is the original layout

  • 7 years ago

    I forgot to mention it is a waterfront property and we love eating in the kitchen nook since it faces the water!

  • 7 years ago

    My hubby really wants the extra garage to store the seadoo, canoe, bikes, etc

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I’m sorry but the new layout is a remuddle with poor flow. Most people come here to fix your updated layout.

    No one wants to walk past a stove as the main thoroughfare from garage to the rest of the house.

    No one will use the mud room. Instead lol the stuff will wind up on the kitchen counters.

    To to get to the powder room you go past the stove and then wind up following a maze to it.

    What the heck is the room with the angled wall?

    why do you need such a huge foyer closet?

    Why do you now have to walk through a second garage to get into the house?

    You’ve made the house harder to live in and less intuitive. A house should flow and one shouldn’t need to play a guessing game as to where certain rooms are

  • 7 years ago
    <?xml version="1.0" encoding="UTF-8"?><md>
  • 7 years ago

    Some 3D photos...

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    the extra garage to store the seadoo, canoe, bikes, etc

    Aha. So, which garage will that be? The new one, or the existing one? if the new one, wouldn’t it make sense for it to face the lake, or at least the side? How much space do you have on the side? Will things be overwintered there, used outside in summer? Or do you move things in an out regularly?

    How will the study be used? Tv watching? Home office? Household records? Reading? What about the living room? Tv? Play? Do you have a subbasement?

    What is the purpose of the space to the left of the main entry? It leads me to think you do not have a basement, but it won’t make a good front hall closet.

    Do you have kids? How many, ages?

    What doesn’t work now?

    How do you want your home to work for you?

  • 7 years ago

    Without further information, I would say that this does not improve the floor plan. There is still no circulation, there is only one way to move through the house. I don’t know if it improves privacy for the upstairs bedrooms and baths.

    Too much traffic funnels through the kitchen.

    If one garage is for storing recreational stuff, it should be oriented to where those things will be used.

  • 7 years ago

    The 3D photos are pretty but don’t answer any of cpartist or bpath’s questions...

  • 7 years ago

    All great comments! Thanks! We cannot turn the garage since there is not enough room! We are a family of 5! The area that bothers us the most right now is that there is no mudroom and when 5 of us come in from the garage it is frustrating! I will move the entry from the garage into the mudroom so things works better. I work from home sometimes so the office will be used for that - the kids could use it to do homework too. We do have a small basement and there are 2 bedrooms, a bathroom and a TV room there.

  • 7 years ago

    What could we do to improve things?

  • 7 years ago

    So your wish list is something like the following?


    Dining and living room with view of water - how many people does the dining need to fit?

    Mudroom where you come in from the garage to hold 5 people.

    A Home Office ( Any particular size you need or can it be small ie similar to a cube in an office?)

    Storage for bikes and water toys (canoes - personal watercraft) - can this be accessed from the back or do you need it in the front?)


    Did I miss anything?


    I think if I had a choice I'd add the following too - access to the powder room from the outside without having to walk through too much. This way when people come from the water they can use the bath without walking all through the house.


  • 7 years ago

    Oh and in the back the view is it just straight out or to the sides as well?

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    I'd consider adding on a garage side which is a tandem garage that can go all the way through with access to the rear so it looks like a 2 car garage from the front. Then convert the existing garage to laundry, mudroom, pantry etc. Just one idea. I haven't sketched it out, but it would allow you to enter more into the middle of the house and laundry would be closer to the bedrooms. Removes people walking through the kitchen.


    Just a potential concept. Would still need to figure out placements etc.





  • 7 years ago

    What could we do to improve things

    You could hire an architect to create something that will be wonderful and work well In the long run it will save you money because there will be no wasted space, no poorly laid out space like this one and if you ever sell, it will yield you the highest rate of return.

    You wouldn’t diagnose what’s wrong if you’re spitting up blood. You’d hire a doctor. Same here in that you need the professional.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    The house is already somewhat long. Are you changing the driveway? The elevation shows a sweeping curve, but the existing shows straight I think. Anyway, adding another two-car garage means not only that the front of the house will be dominated by garage doors, but the lawn will, too, by all that asphalt.

    Lyfia has a creative concept, turning the existing garage into house space that can balance the right side of the house, with tandem garage alongside. Or, you could keep the existing garage, and add a single-wide tandem. The garage door in the back can be a traditional roll-up door, or hinged carriage-type doors. That kind of the thing is much further along the design, though.

    Did Lyfia miss anything when she reiterated your wish list? What else did you talk to your designer about?

  • 7 years ago

    These are all great suggestions! If we did a tandem garage and converted the current garage into living space the whole front of the house would have to be redesigned? We do t have to add any drive way

  • 7 years ago

    Oops! Posted too soon! We don’t have to add any more asphalt since there is extra asphalt - see photo...

  • 7 years ago

    Since you are doing so many changes on the main floor, you even have an opportunity to move the entry door to the middle of the porch. That could open up other opportunities for you.

  • 7 years ago

    We did consider that at one time but I love the roof extension since it makes it look less like a side split...

  • 7 years ago

    I like that. If the existing garage were incorporated into the house, windowed and sided like the rest, and the new garage a tandem, I think it would look like a Minnesota rambler, not a split. And fwiw, I like a rambler!

  • 7 years ago

    I just googled “rambler house” and they are really nice! If we kept house as is with the 2 garages what kind of siding would you do? Lap? Board and baton? Shingle?

  • 7 years ago

    I have no idea! I’m a layout gal lol.