Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_327566990

Kitchen Carpentry Issues - Am I Being Unreasonable?

7 years ago
last modified: 7 years ago

Hi


I recently engaged an ID to renovate my house. While most of it has gone well, my biggest issue lies with the carpentry and it is not something I am pleased with. Notably, the ABS trimming used is much different from my laminate and it's one that I find rather ugly. I am unhappy with this because:


1) I paid a fair bit for 3D renderings that showed the same design for the laminate and ABS trimming.


2) Not once during the whole process was I informed that the ABS trimming would be different. If I were notified, I 100% would have chosen a different one. For reference, I have since found one that better matches my current laminate.


3) While I now understand that not every laminate design will have a matching ABS trim, surely it would be better design sense to choose one that doesn't highlight the difference?


As an aside, the carpenter accidentally drilled a hole into my drawer. When I brought this up, he tried to patch it up yet somehow made things worse.


Regardless, I intend to ask my ID to rectify these issues while bearing the costs in a 33% (me) - 33% (ID) - 33% (carpenter) split. My question is - are these issues actually minor and/or am I the one who's being too particular? I'm worried that I'd be unreasonable in asking my ID to rectify this issue and to bear some of the costs. Can anyone kindly give some advice?


Thank you!









Comments (2)

  • 7 years ago

    I think you are reasonable in requesting it be replaced. The pictures are worth a million words, very different

  • PRO
    7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    You’re trying to be reasonable, which is a very good thing and should be commended. However, you aren’t working with all the facts that you need here. You need more information first.

    Design software is never a 100% accurate rendering, and should never be relied on for details like that. Those details should be documented in the other paperwork that you signed and that the cabinet maker used to create the cabinets.


    PVC edge banding for laminate doors comes in certain specific colors only. It’s not available in every single finish. You could have a gray, or a stainless look, or white, or the marbled look that you have currently. Edge banding is industry wide used instead of a self edge on laminate doors because it’s more durable, to impacts specifically, and is seen as a decorative accent in many cases. This is a case that the stainless look would have been a much better design choice.

    Custom creating a self edge for the doors can be always done on an order, if specified. It is an upgrade in price, and a downgrade in durability. It’s very labor intensive, and would just about double your door costs. It’s also not very easily retrofittable once the edge banding has been applied. Especially if they used an industrial edge bander.

    This is a detail that should have been discussed and documented. Pull out your paperwork and see what kind was specified, if any. I don’t know what led the cabinet maker to choose that banding, or if the designer chose it. It’s possible that he or she thought it was the best possible match. The designer may not have been aware of the methodology of cabinet construction and that that was a detail that had to be specified.


    If you want self edged doors, they may need to be remade. Check your paperwork for specifications before you go down that road. The fair cost difference for you is the difference that you would have paid for the edge banding vs self edged originally. The cabinet maker will already have to eat the cost of new doors, so no, I don’t think it’s fair to ask for any more from him. Whether or not the designer chips in depends on the paperwork and specifications given to you and the cabinet maker. If she gave the correct specs to the cabinet maker, it’s on him, and she should help out a bit for her fsilure to confirm his understanding. And for her failure to inspect at delivery. If she failed to specify the edge banding, then yes. she should chip in a lot more.