Software
Houzz Logo Print
futura4

Replace cabinet doors now or later?!

7 years ago

We are doing a kitchen refacing (new counters, backsplash, appliances etc) and because our kitchen was put in back in 1995, we have to cut the fridge insert to accommodate for a fridge bigger than 68 inches. By doing this we have to adjust the cabinet above the fridge. Our contractor said he could put in a new, smaller one no problem. The dilemma is this:

Do we pay him to make 2 custom doors to match what we have now (old, dated arched doors, but painted white) OR do we order the shaker style cabinet doors we eventually want to put in? I realize these will not match the other cabinets but I'm torn on whether or not I want to pay to have custom doors made to match something we eventually plan to change.

Comments (13)

  • 7 years ago

    My designer cautioned me that refacing quotes would be almost as much as new cabinets. She was right. I replaced mine.

  • 7 years ago

    Replacing our cabinets is not an option. At this point it's doors now or later. I did a quick quote on Barker doors; it was about $3400 for all of them.

  • 7 years ago
    last modified: 7 years ago

    Finishing raw doors properly costs as much as the doors do. You need a conversion varnish, sprayed by a pro. Refacing doesn’t address the most critical insufficiencies of the kitchen. It’s just new pretty makeup. You end up spending more doing things piecemeal and while you’re at it than you would ripping off the band aid and doing the gut and start over. You get a much better end product starting over too.

  • 7 years ago

    I wouldn't do the counters and backsplash before you do anything about cabinets, because there's no way that cabinet possibilities haven't improved in that time (read: big drawers!) and you'll be locked into your old stuff by the new stuff you put on top, even if it costs a fortune for new doors.

  • 7 years ago

    My parents were just dealing with this. My dad - pretty handy though not a perfectionist - somehow took out the existing cabinet box and shortened the vertical pieces, and then he took the existing doors and sawed off the top of them and left them unfinished - because no one looks at the top of cabinet doors when they are abutting the ceiling :). The doors are raised panel, but no one notices that those doors are slightly off now. He did it all diy....

  • 7 years ago

    Can you just buy an Ikea over-fridge box? They're available in 30" and 36" widths, and assorted heights, then get a pair of doors - either hinged on the sides or flip-up - in a coordinating pattern, or just black, or just white, which tend to go with everything?


  • PRO
    7 years ago

    IMO you need to really love your kitchen as is before spending all the money on what you plan. I agree just do the box and leave the doors off for now.

  • 6 years ago

    We don't love our kitchen as is but we can't afford the full gut. Our kitchen is in the middle of our house and in order to expand or change the footprint, we need to remove a load-bearing wall and put in a 12K beam. So we are doing a facelift, for now, until we can afford to do the full gut in a few years. I'm also aware that it may never happen so we are taking the steps to make the kitchen better than it is now. I think I'll just go with the custom-made doors so they match on the off-chance we never get new doors.

  • 6 years ago

    IF you can find the cabinet maker's name on an inside drawer, you can see if they still make the arch door style. The arch style is still sold in my area's kitchen showrooms. If not, two custom doors will not cost much. Check the new fridge's installation sheet to see how much ventilation clearance you need at the top of the fridge.

  • 6 years ago

    Consider adding a single deep open box shelf between cabinets on left of the fridge and the cabinets on the right side of the fridge, perhaps with a single top hinge door. You could add additional shelves within it or a single center divider or multiple dividers such as for trays and elongated metal baking pans -- dozen cupcakes, etc.


    Even without more shelves or vertical dividers, you could use that space for plastic containers, including tall cake covers -- items you could place and remove with the right kind of "tongs" without climbing on a step stool , especially if you choose a hinge that requires pressure to either open or close -- one that will stay open -- and/or choose a handle for the door that would enable you to hold up the door with one hand/tool and fetch your sought item with the other hand/tool.


    Do make sure there is vent room beneath the box shelf (above the top of the fridge) as needed.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Having been involved in a both a new build and in a remodel of a kitchen, if I ever am contemplating another "remodel", then ( space permitting of course), I'd rather build a new kitchen -- either in the dining room and then gut the kitchen to use as the new dining room or just add a room to the house for the new kitchen rather than gut and rebuild one in place.


  • 6 years ago

    If you build a box shelf with a hidden door -- no visible handle/knob ... a door that looks like a paneled wall above the fridge -- you'd not even need to match cabinet doors -- just finish/paint it the color of your cabinets as if it were a side wall of your cabinets.