Software
Houzz Logo Print
rjinga

Electric fireplace vs real one?

6 years ago

I searched around the site for other posts and most talked about gas vs wood burning, I'm considering not putting in a fp at all. I just don't see us using it at all or very rarely. We live in GA and even when it's (infrequently) colder outside, we have a fireplace now that I think is electric where you put the fake logs in..have not used it once in 15 years. so with our new build, I'd rather use that money towards windows. this is along the lines of what I'm looking at (not the exact one but just to give an idea of exactly what I'm talking about) Does anyone have one of these that they like? pros/cons? (what about resale considerations?)




Comments (19)

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Regarding resale: Once a home build reaches a certain price point, a fireplace becomes mandatory — even in Georgia! This is where the expertise of your real estate agent or Realtor comes in. The style of fireplace — traditional vs modern (e.g., linear) — depends on the style of house. This is where the expertise of your architect (or interior designer) comes in. When it comes to choosing the fuel type (gas vs wood-burning vs electric) and construction (masonry vs factory-built) of the fireplace, that’s where things can get a bit more complex. FYI: If you’re building a mid-to-upper-end and/or traditional home, a fireplace like the one in your photo would be completely inappropriate. ;)

    rjinga thanked Sammy
  • 6 years ago

    I also live in the SE...fireplaces, either gas or wood burning, are pretty darn popular. I’m not a realtor, but I would imagine a majority of buyers would want a fireplace, for decorating if nothing else. We have both an indoor (gas) and outdoor (wood burning w/gas starter) fireplaces, and also a gas fire pit on our patio. We use all three, often. I’d consult with a realtor if you think you might ever need to sell, particularly if you are in a production home neighborhood where most homes have a fp.

    rjinga thanked nini804
  • 6 years ago

    this home will be in a small exclusive community, but it's more casual in general, lake homes, BUT they are 3000 sq ft and up (HOA covenants).

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    "Once a home build reaches a certain price point" ... you can do whatever you want!

    I decided to skip the fireplace in the new build and we will be priced at the higher end for the area. I have no use for a fireplace and if a hypothetical future buyer has a problem, then they aren't the right buyer. Many of the local housing stock have major floor plan issues, so I'm not worried about not having a fireplace. The house has other positives, which will rank much higher than a fireplace, to most people.

    I am going from a hot climate with 4 fireplaces (that have been used a combined total of 6 times in 10 years) to a hotter climate, so a fireplace made no sense at all.

    rjinga thanked chispa
  • 6 years ago

    The only reason I put in a fireplace in my new home in SW Florida was because I was building a craftsman inspired house and those had fireplaces and I was trying to replicate the look and feel of the style of house. I consider it more of a focal point than something we use much and it, along with the built in bookcases on either side is like a piece of art to us.

    If I was building another style of house, I most likely would never have put in a fireplace. And yes, our house is on the upper end of the price scale for the neighborhood.

  • 6 years ago

    But from a decorating standpoint, wouldn't electric suit most people?

    The argument for gas around here is ice storms and power outages. We used ours for a prechristmas family gathering when it was 28 degrees last Sun morning. House got a little toasty after 1.5 hours but was nice for the gathering.

    RTP area here so colder than much of GA by a degree or two.

    rjinga thanked David Cary
  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    I have seen the electric insert ones with mantles above them and tvs mounted above them..I suppose that you could do just about anything. I happen to have a few gorgeous antique mantles in my antique mall booth, that I could use..and the designs i've seen for the electric are basically bump outs like a normal fireplace that can be tiled or brick or whatever you want. I think that I've read the real FP's can cost up to 20k to build? I can think of a lot of things I could buy to decorate /furnish the house with that money. how cool is this one!

    <div><a href='https://www.houzz.com/photos/wheelers-hill-project-contemporary-living-room-melbourne-phvw-vp~15173298' target='_blank'><img

  • 6 years ago

    A fireplace is not going to make or break resale when the time comes. What will is a poorly laid out floor plan and little natural light. Those two things are more important.

    rjinga thanked cpartist
  • 6 years ago

    Just run a picture of a fire on your TV (I think it's on Netflix) It will be more energy efficient, cheaper, and not cause you to consider one of those awkward TV over fireplace configurations. You can also change it with the seasons-- in the summer run a picture of a pool and save the expense and difficulty of maintaining a real one of those too!

    Seriously, a fake fireplace is just silly. Save the space and money for something much more useful to you.

  • 6 years ago

    Likely this is regional. Fireplaces are expected here in Vancouver so we have one. Although we barely use it I’m glad we have it. It’s gas

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Likely this is regional.

    Yep.

    And the number and style dependent on the price point.

    In Toronto, for mid range, I've gotten away with two.

    On near luxury--less than C$5m.--three or four are the minimum number. But rarely wood-burning. One thing I've noticed is that the once mandatory fake chimneys aren't necessary anymore.

    Electric is common now--but only in entry level homes less than C$1 m.

  • 6 years ago

    Most people in FL, if they have a "fireplace" even in multi million dollar homes, have an electric one, which once again shows it's all regional.

  • 6 years ago

    I'm having a similar dilemma for our upcoming remodel. The money I'd save on the fireplace could be spent on a lot of other things that I'd use more than the fireplace. To be honest, the only real reason I want one is for holiday decorating :/ The bad thing is that I need to decide by next Monday for sure :(

  • 6 years ago

    shead, you can have a mantle in a room even without a fireplace or even a fake fp. if I had the one below, I'd add chicken wire painted white into the insert and put twinkle lights all over that area :)



  • 6 years ago

    @rjinga, DH just dropped the bomb last night after spending months trying to convince NOT to have a fireplace that he has decided now that he REALLY wants one - a wood-burning one at that....lol. We break ground and pour footers next weeks so we have to come to a consensus pronto. Decisions, decisions....

    rjinga thanked shead
  • 6 years ago

    Check out 'European Home' brand electric fireplaces. I bought one and it's awaiting to be installed.

    https://www.europeanhome.com/modern-electric-fireplace/

    Anything less seems meh now, and paying to pipe and vent a natural gas FP thats rarely used, or a chimney for a wood burning fireplace that's never used - no brainer for me.

    rjinga thanked Matt McLagan
  • 6 years ago

    Matt M, I really love that..and that's what we will probably do for the same reasons. so many of the homes I've seen have 2 and 3 fireplaces...I saw one recently that was a stack sitting out by itself in the middle of their back yard, it looked plain stupid to me..and the ones that are outside for outdoor kitchens usually in a covered patio of some sort, again...cool enough, but impractical for me..well even though that one may get used more than the one inside...it's use again, would be minimal..I can absolutely choose other things to spend our money on :)

  • 6 years ago

    If you want realism with an electric fireplace you need to look at a Dimplex. It fooled me at first when I saw it in the store. In fact at the time they only had a linear version but now have a rectangular version. If they had the rectangular version when we were ready to buy, I would have never gone with gas.

    rjinga thanked cpartist