Software
Houzz Logo Print
mrbjones

Water heater started leaking. Advice on replacing?

6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago

Last night one of our two water heaters started leaking. It and the other are each 40 gallons, installed in series (no way to shut off the water to just one; we have no hot water anywhere!); although only one is leaking, we're guessing both wil need to be replaced due to their age. Four bedroom house, just my wife and I, but we do have guests from time to time. What do you think of this Rheem unit, at Home Depot?

XG40T09HE40U0 CLICK HERE


Any recommendations for other brands or models? Anything in particular to look for, or to stay away from?


Also, is 80 gallons total necessary or desireable? What about a single 50 gallon unit?

Finally, the heaters are in the attic of our one-story slab foundation house. Thoughts on relocating?

Comments (12)

  • 6 years ago

    I don't have an opinion on the advantages of one model over another, but I'd say that one 40 gallon WH should be more than adequate. I also would want to avoid having it in the attic due to the extra time, labor and expense for servicing and replacement, not to mention the cosmetic repairs that may be incurred.

    YMMV

  • 6 years ago

    Is the fuel source natural gas? How many people living in the house and are they all trying to take showers around the same time?

    I like the Rheem gas hot water heaters, but I don't care for the models sold in Home Depot. The control and drain valve are made of plastic. The better Rheem models are sold at plumbing supply houses for a little more money. They have a better control mechanism and the drain valve is made of brass.

    I can't image needing 80 gallons of hot water especially if they are fired by natural gas. My suggestion is to replace both with a 50 gallon size with a 50K BTU input. Bradford White is another brand to consider.

    Hot water heaters don't belong in attics in my opinion. I would move it out if it were feasible and not overly expensive.


  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Thanks for the replies. What about this one? A bit larger (55 gallon vs 50), with 50K BTU (vs 40K). Has a brass drain valve. Also 12 year parts warranty, 3 year labor. By the way, we're in Dallas...hot summers, relatively mild winters.

    CLICK HERE

  • 6 years ago

    Have you considered tankless? Talk to your trusted plumber about the feasibility of that. It’s what we did when we had a home w 2 furnaces.

  • 6 years ago

    I mean hot water heaters :)

  • 6 years ago

    The 55 Performance Platinum version is a little better built and has very good recovery performance. It probably can outperform your current twin 40 gallon tanks. The only negative it is a little pricey, but cheaper than installing a tankless system.

  • 6 years ago

    If it's just the two of you, a single 40 gal gas would work fine. You don't need two unless you have a big soaking tub that you use often.


    You should consider an electric hybrid (50 gal). It would work great in that location. They have an operating cost that's less than a gas tankless, without the install costs of a gas tankless. Utility Rebates are often significant - see what they are in your area.



  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    How about installing some additional piping and a valve to bypass the busted heater? Run the remaining heater alone for awhile to see whether it's capacity is sufficient. If so, discard the busted one and replace the good one, if necessary, with another of the same capacity. If insufficient, get the larger heater.

    Comparing the specs of the 6-, 9-, and 12-year warranty heaters, it appears the 9-year is the sweet spot as it is slightly more efficient than the 6-year heater but doesn't cost much more. Note that the warranties after the labor period expires are largely useless as you have to pay for everything, including transportation, except any broken parts.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Any thoughts on Rheem's Classic Plus series? A 50 gallon tank, 40,000 btu, would be $1,749 installed...includes the tank, lines etc, permit, and labor. Warranty is 8 years tank, 4 years labor. And it would be done tomorrow morning.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    I found this "Rheem Professional Classic Plus Atmospheric" (I don't know what Atmospheric means but there's no such thing as a simple "Professional Classic Plus" (or "Classic Plus") that doesn't have some kind of sub-type. However the 8-year warranty doesn't include any labor.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    @mrbjones

    That's fine - go for it.

    You need hot water. Just install one. You don't need two.


    Here's a tip though... just like we don't wait until our brakes go out to fix them--or our tires blow out to replace them - don't wait until your water heater goes out to replace it.

    It leaves you in a bad place that you have to make quick decisions because you don't have hot water - or you have a catastrophic failure.

    A water heater that's 12 - 15 years old is on target to replace.