Pictures of the house?

Thank you in advance for your professional opinion.

Which do you like?

I believe that in looking up close and personal at current shingles and the above samples (I have actual sample), that Country gray is similar in general to what it there, if we want to duplicate and be safe. I also like Autumn blend and even charcoal black, but fear that may be too stark if there is no variation of shading. So, I haven't really narrowed it down a lot. The house was just recently repainted, so that will not be changing for a very long time.

Autumn Blend -- darker but not too dark.

I very much appreciate that-a lot actually! I was leaning toward that choice, and for interior projects, rarely make a mistake, but this decision was massive and I so needed the second (and professional) opinion! Thank you.