Software
Houzz Logo Print
webuser_704931868

Compost technique !?!?

6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago

Hi!

I don't have the space for a compost bin, but I've been doing some composting instinctively with an invented technique. I worry it might not be great, but other days I think it's brilliant! Someone told me it sucks the nitrogen out from my soil. I'd love an expert opinion.

I have about 30 gorgeous citrus and sub tropical trees in massive clay containers around my patio and hillside. All have a thick layer of wood mulch on top of the soil.

I keep vegetable scraps, banana peels, and egg shells in a closed container in my large freeze. When the container is full, I use a dedicated blender to blend the contents (usually go a few rounds) with a bit of water, essentially creating a thick smoothie with the waste. I then pour it over the thick mulch covering the soil of my pots, let it drain a bit, and mix it into the mulch layer using my hands and garden gloves. About two days later I mix the mulch around some more. I believe the "smoothie" stays mostly in the mulch layer.

My thinking is that this over time decomposes and nourishes the soil below, perhaps the same as leaves would do, or the same as the wood chips might over time. I also like to think it decompose fairly quickly since the particles are tiny (blended into this "smoothie". I also notice how the earthworms are so happy to come to the surface and feed in the mulch layers.

To my surprise there is no noticeable smell or pests attracted to this. I've been doing this for about 18 months, a couple trees at a time, and just keep the rotation going.

The "waste smoothie", once dried up between the mulch in a day or two, is basically unnoticeable.

Am I feeding my trees and giving my soil beneficial life and nutrients with this technique? Or can this be damaging to the soil and roots? Considering I water these roughly twice a week with deep waterings, a bit less in winter..

is there a name for such a thing?

Or am I instead depleting the top layers of soil of nutrients to get this "waste" turned into "compost" in the mulch on the surface of my pots?

I am so curious to get a solid answer on all this. Would love your thoughts.

FYI I'm in Los Angeles California. I assume our dry, warm climate might help the process above not becoming "pest central" and "stink central".

Is there a better category on Houzz to post this?

Thank you very much!

J.

Comments (2)

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Sounds good to me, You might want to put a few straws into the dirt as breathing tubes so that if your smoothy forms a surface dam to fresh air your plant has the breathing tubes in place. Straws come free with restaurant drinks. You may have to add nitrogen. I use grass feed 32-0-4

    Steve

  • 6 years ago

    I have some issues with this......... :-)

    First, just smooshing up your kitchen waste is not exactly creating compost. That is a process of decomposition that has not yet taken place and applying raw organic matter - which is essentially what your 'smoothies' are - to the soil can tie up nutrient availability until that process is complete.

    But of greater concern is that you cannot treat trees growing in containers in the same manner you treat trees planted in the ground. Soil media is a critical factor and the best container media is one that has a very small organic component to maintain durablity (ie. NO decomposition) and to insure fast drainage and good aeration. So there are by definition very small populations of any soil organisms in a quality container mix so really nothing to encourage your smoothies to break down and release nutrients. For that reason, compost (or any raw OM) or even organic ferts are not advised for container culture....nothing alive in the container media is present in sufficient quantity to effectively break down the organics into plant accessible nutrients.

    I'd suggest instead just using a synthetic full range liquid fertilizer like Dyna Gro's Foliage Pro diluted to half strength and applied with every other watering or every other week. Save your smoothies for any inground plantings :-)

    Mulching the container doesn't accomplish much either. It may help slow some surface evaporation but it really does not reduce watering needs significantly.

    Jay Ruso thanked gardengal48 (PNW Z8/9)