Software
Houzz Logo Print
dominick_orlando67

new branch off trunk line

6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago

Hello, I understand it is best to run a new branch off the plenum but that is very challenging due to the design of our attic. I need to run either a 6 or 8" duct run into a new room. The nearest trunk line is about 15 feet away. The rooms on that line are getting very good air flow. I understand I risk losing some air in those rooms if I connect to that trunk line but I am wondering if I can make up for that with the below suggestion.

My plenum and the initial 10 feet of the initial trunk line actually run parallel to the trunk that I want to tie into. It kind of makes a little bit of a U shape. If I ran a short 6 foot pipe from the main trunk line into this other trunk would it add more air into that trunk, therefore offsetting the air i would use for the new line? The new branch will be 25 feet away from where this is happening. There are also 2 vents between where I would make the connection from the main trunk and where the new branch would be.

Thank you

Comments (6)

  • PRO
    6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    The best way is to redesign the entire duct system... because each room needs 'xxx' amount of air.

    I don't know if what you are doing makes the duct system over sized, right sized, under sized. Proper means 'right sized' and guessing gets no where close.

    Because you're adding to an existing system likely with the intent of trying to fix a 'problem' --- that 'problem' you think you are fixing isn't going to be fixed it will merely be shifted somewhere else and often times makes matters worse, not better.

    While what you propose here may work in mild weather, it almost certainly won't work during the rest of the year.

    If you're in an all year long moderate climate -- like Los Angeles for example it might work ok.

    In a hot climate like me (Katy, Texas) --- nope, it won't work for long.

  • 6 years ago

    It is difficult to follow how your current duct system has been put together.. Is it possible to post some photos and/or draw a simple diagram of what you are proposing to do?

  • 6 years ago

    Hi, I have decided not to try what I described above. However, I do want to try and run a line to the new room. Our unit should be pushing out 1400 CFM per the tech specs. We have 10 ducts and most appear to be 6 CFM, a couple smaller and I think one 7 or 8. I don't think we are getting more than 1100 cfm. It seems like there is some air that I can push out to that room. The house does get very good air flow.


    My thought is to attach near the plenum as i am not sure I can get directly to the plenum. I was going to cut in within 8 feet of the plenum before it branches or splits off. I can make the cut and if the rest of the house is then unbalanced or loses much air I can patch the hole.


    Any thoughts on that? My understanding is that it is not abnormal to cut into or near the plenum to add a line if there are enough CFM's.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    The new branch will be 25 feet away from where this is happening.

    That is a long run. This run is in addition to what is there now.

    Everything I said above still stands. You can do what you want, but I don't see this working under heavy load conditions (hot or cold).

    You can't rob Peter to pay Paul... that's about as clear as I can make it.

    (well you could rob Peter, but you'll probably go to jail) -- I know that's kind of 'snickerish' --- snarky --- but it is what it is.

    Design is the often thing not considered in the 'cost' of doing something. It's a box, if we don't like the price we'll pick a different box.

    There's a big market for homes with problems in HVAC. Design problems are the worst if you can imagine.... why you have the problem to begin with.

  • 6 years ago

    I understand what you are saying. I guess my confusion is if my unit is pushing out 1400 cfm and the main trunk line is sized for 1100 then if I tie directly into the plenum an 8” line that is now a total of 1300 cfm. Won’t the unit still push 1100 through main trunk? If I do anything it will be directly in the plenum

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    if my unit is pushing out 1400 cfm and the main trunk line is sized for 1100 then if I tie directly into the plenum an 8” line that is now a total of 1300 cfm. Won’t the unit still push 1100 through main trunk?


    So everything or a good amount of it is based on 'If' -- do you really know what your unit is pushing?

    Trunk line systems start out larger and go smaller primarily for 'throw' or velocity out of the vent. Air takes the path of least resistance. If the trunk was sized for total allowable air flow of the system it wouldn't build enough pressure to 'throw' out of the vent. This would likely lead to very little air coming out certain vents at the start of the trunk. Because air takes the path of least resistance which is farther down the trunk because there is more room now for it to go there.

    So if you now open up and add another air way for air to go that is going to change the entire equation in things that I can't explain in not even knowing 'exactly' what I am looking at.

    Trunk based duct designs can work in a residential setting, but preferably I don't care for them in a residential setting (most of the time). The reason for this is primarily control of the air. Trunk based duct designs are the better option for commercial type installations. Residential foot prints are usually smaller, unless you are living in a mansion or something not so typical.

    A new duct design looks at the whole house --- not just the room with the problem. Without doing that I doubt it is successful under all conditions a home HVAC system is put under.