Software
Houzz Logo Print
eumie_choi

Help with Granite - Looks different!

6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago

My husband and I are currently getting a new home built and the granite was recently installed.

However, the granite looks nothing like the sample and the same granite in other people's homes (our friend has the same granite and I've searched other model homes thru this Builder website with the same granite). I know that granite can come in many variations but we were shocked that the granite turnt out SO DIFFERENT. The light portions appear more beige and there are a lot more blotchier black patterns. It doesn't go so well with our white cabinets and makes our kitchen and bathroom appear "messy".

The granite is supposed to be Ice Blue. Originally we were going to go with White Light but the Sales Rep for the Builder company recommended we not go White Light because another home buyer experienced a large discrepancy from what was expected.

We are very unhappy with our granite. We even wonder if it is truly Ice Blue and/or maybe it was ordered from a different supplier than in the past?

If anyone knows if this granite is indeed NOT Ice Blue and knows the name of it, we would really appreciate your help in figuring this out.

Thanks in advanced.














Comments (42)

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    When I google the granite it is all over the map for colorand I have ask did you choose the slabs? You should have done that then this would not be an issue.

    Eumie Weaver thanked Patricia Colwell Consulting
  • 6 years ago

    It’s fine. The builder holds all the cards here when you build a tract build.

    Eumie Weaver thanked User
  • 6 years ago

    There is so much variation in what is in your house I see how a sample couldn't begin to cover it! Is the color too unlike the sample? The color on computer looks good with your paint and cabinets.

    I think the patterns are great but I would at least ask about replacing the backsplash in the first bathroom you pictured. It's not a great match but the others are pretty good. I hope you like the fireplace. It's dramatic and very interesting.

    You probably don't have a lot of options with the builder (but ask!) and it probably doesn't help to have rando internet me say it's not bad at all, but it isn't!

    Eumie Weaver thanked Fori
  • 6 years ago

    Sorry live_wire I disagree. It is not fine.

    I am wondering if your friends also have the same bright white cabinets?

    A creamy white cabinet would have worked better.

    This is disappointing. It is why it is recommended to actually go and see the slabs.

    If you are planning on staying in this home for quite a while I would negotiate in some way. You will be bothered by this every single day.

    It’s disheartening because you actually “saw” this granite in other people’s homes and expected something similar.


    Eumie Weaver thanked eld6161
  • PRO
    6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Ugh, that is so disappointing and I'm sorry.

    If you chose the slabs based off a small sample, and signed off I can't imagine there being any room for negotiations.

    Unfortunately in your case, granite is a natural product which means every single slab is different. Without seeing the actual slab there is no definitive way to know what your are getting. Many times, when seeing the slab you are able to approve the template layout on the slab. That way you can dictate where the markings will fall in relationship to your counter.

    Eumie Weaver thanked User
  • 6 years ago

    Builder/Developer house all he owes you is a similar product and your contract will say he can swap out products. Granite being a natural product will have huge swings from slab to slab, lot to lot.

    Eumie Weaver thanked millworkman
  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    it 'kind of' looks like this which is labeled 'ice blue'



    but it seems more like

    a delicatus like this one




    so sorry that you are disappointed.

    Eumie Weaver thanked Trish Walter
  • 6 years ago

    Do you have the sample?

    Eumie Weaver thanked Louise Smith
  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Tract builders who build tract builds give tract builder results. The buyer doesn’t even own the house until closing. There simply isn’t a recourse when you don’t own the house. They might be willing to change out a splash, or other tiny concession. But that’s going to be it. Because it’s the builder that owns the house.

    Eumie Weaver thanked User
  • 6 years ago

    You *MIGHT have leverage *IF you have:

    1. A Photo of the SLABs YOU purchased in the stone yard

    2. A PHOTO of your SIGNATURE on the slabs (back of slab)

    3. A PHOTO of your signature ON THE SLABS as to the lay-out of the cuts


    You will need ALL THREE photos to PROVE your slabs (you picked out, purchased and agreed to layout) were NOT USED in your home.


    What evidence do you have to dispute the stone in your home is NOT the stone you purchased?

    Eumie Weaver thanked SJ McCarthy
  • 6 years ago

    A local slab yard in Seattle looks like they have something similar called Delicatus White Polished Sierra Heights Yellow: http://inventory.pentalonline.com/lines/naturalStone/slabs/granite/delicatus-white-polished-sierra-heights-yellow



    Eumie Weaver thanked Rebekah Gibbs
  • 6 years ago

    The builder holds all the cards here when you build a tract build.

    Yeah, this.

    This board is pretty down on tract houses, but -- honestly -- they're a decent, moderately priced choice. I really like my daughter's tract house! However, I fear you were expecting custom quality (small details like exact coloring in granite) at tract prices. That's not realistic.

    Do consider that this coloring difference may become less noticeable once you've moved in all your stuff. It can't hurt to talk to the builder about it, but I think it'll be fine in the long run.


    Eumie Weaver thanked Mrs Pete
  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Swap out the island top in a few yrs? or sooner, and get a single bowl sink at the same time. you have a new home to enjoy for now. In reality , these kitchens get entirely redone later down the road . Not to be advocating that, but it is typical , before they wear out....so don’t worry about it. I think the island is where a swap might be worth it : but that would be it, for now. Fireplace and perimeter and bath are fine

    Eumie Weaver thanked herbflavor
  • 6 years ago

    Not a fan of those counters, either intended or actual. I find them messy and uninspiring. That's off-topic, I know.

    I doubt you will get anywhere with the builder as you did not pick the slabs.

    Eumie Weaver thanked strategery
  • 6 years ago

    I am sorry it is not what you were expecting. It is very beautiful!! My friend had a similar situation where she picked from a small sample and was surprised by the final result. Your counters are prettier than many. Again, I am sorry for your distress. They are beautiful to me. If you can not get them changed, keep in mind that if you bought an existing house, it would just be whatever the prior owner had.

    Eumie Weaver thanked lafdr
  • 6 years ago

    The problem with choosing stone/granite from a random sample is that in most cases the samples are years old and not representative of the current material that is being quarried/cut or the builder is now getting it from a different wholesaler/quarry.


    The same thing applies to samples of man made quartz, which can also be years old and from different dye lots. Always ask for a current sample from the manufacturer or pick out your slabs in person.

    Eumie Weaver thanked chispa
  • 6 years ago

    BTW, are you doing a backsplash tile in the kitchen? if so, remove that 4" piece. don't tile on top of it

    Eumie Weaver thanked Beth H. :
  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Beth, good catch on those seams and mix/match of slabs! Builder's installers are just minimizing product used and maximizing profit ...

    Eumie Weaver thanked chispa
  • 6 years ago

    Thank you all so so much for the comments. First time using Houzz forum and I had no idea there were so many comments. I’m so grateful for everyone giving us input to help us out!

    It’s come to the conclusion that we have to accept the granite because the company says they can’t change the counters. They did say they will change the granite on the fireplace because of the inconsistency from the countertops. They told my husband that the island itself costs them $1500 and therefore cannot change all of the granite. But I think the island costing $1500 is not true haha..

    Despite disliking our granite at first, we are now getting used to the look of our granite and I figured once we decorate, it will look better. What may be throwing it off is our cabinets are white and the lighting that’s put inside the home are of the yellow bulbs, so we will change them out to daylight bulbs, as someone mentioned above, once having moved in. I wasn’t able to see the granite in person yet because I live couple hours away from the location but my husband finally went in to see it in person over the weekend. (Our realtor had taken the photos that I posted with). It appears that the granite looks more yellow/beige when the lights are turned on. Thus, there’s a less yellow appearance when no light is turned on.

    I did see some photos of supreme delicatus, as a few of you mentioned it looks like delicatus. And I was thinking ours looks very similar to it. So I was thinking it’s possible it could be a mistake on the manufacturer or supplier?

    Here is a photo of the sample, followed by three photos of our friend’s Ice Blue granite (their home built by the same builder company). Our original choice was going to be White Light but the sales manager recommended us not to get it because another home buyer’s White Light granite came out blotchy and very dark in some areas. Thus, we went with Ice Blue after we saw these photos of our friend’s granite. We are definitely learning a lot from this experience. If we replace the granite in the future, we will definitely pick out our own slabs. Our builder company doesn’t allow home buyers to look at slabs before they are installed into the homes.

  • 6 years ago

    @Beth H I totally agree with you. The dark marks being so thick and dramatic on our granite was what was getting to me! And I even mentioned to the sales rep that I wanted a more cleaner look to go with white cabinets. My husband wanted a darker kitchen because he’s a bourbon type of guy (haha) but I wanted a more open feel to our home since our home.

    Most of the options of granite the Builder offered looked a bit messy for my liking or just not unique so we went with the Ice Blue. Our granite was an upgrade from their standard granites too. We had the option to upgrade even further by choosing quartz and I think marble(?), but our friend/realtor told us to stick with granite as quartz can burn easier and marble is actually more porous and gets ruined quicker. However, I do really love the look of marble!!

  • 6 years ago

    @chispa yes, I also believe the Builder is trying to maximize profits. For instance, after we signed our contract, they made the standard flooring to all “luxury vinyl” flooring with exception to bedrooms being carpet. What we signed for was wood flooring for our living room and tile for kitchen, foyer and laundry room areas. When they told us that we have to get the luxury vinyl instead and have to pay extra for what we originally signed for, I was pretty upset!! But we addressed our concerns and they let us stick to the wood and tile. Oh and not that incentives are that important, but they told us that we can get free blinds, fridge or washer/dryer if we buy a home thru them by the new year. We went to look at homes few days before Christmas and I think on dec 26th and 27th. However, the sales rep was on vacation from around dec the 28th to january 3rd or something..(I was only able to be in town to look at homes during the Holidays as my husband and I are still long distance). They told us as long as we sign to buy a home soon after the new year, we can get an incentive. When that time came to us signing the contract, they told us we can’t get incentives by purchasing a non-Spec home. This was never specified to us lol.. Having gone thru even with these situations, I felt like they were tricking us again after we saw our granite.. as if they choose cheaper slabs for the Ice Blue granite for their homes now.. I did some research on some of the company’s more recent homes in other states and it looks like a good number of them do have the “messier appearing Ice Blue” installed as well. I still think our granite is not true Ice Blue!

  • 6 years ago

    J Choi, it can always be a bit of a shock when you install something new. Our minds make up their own picture and it usually doesn't quite match up to reality! I'm sure your house will be lovely when it is finished and you can't beat having everything brand new and never used by anyone else! I've done a lot of major remodeling, but have never had a whole brand new house. Enjoy!

    Eumie Weaver thanked chispa
  • 6 years ago

    I think your kitchen will look beautiful once you install your backsplash.

    Eumie Weaver thanked Ac Lb
  • 6 years ago

    The worst look is around the fireplace. Awful. I would at least replace that since a fireplace is a “focal point” and just live with the rest for now.

    Eumie Weaver thanked zorroslw1
  • 6 years ago

    @zorroslw1 Yes, thankfully they said they can replace the fireplace. Hoping that the replaced granite will turn out better *fingers crossed*

  • 6 years ago

    J Choi, I'm not sure your builder's installer has the ability, or can be bothered, to do a good design and installation on the fireplace. I looked again and saw that he used 4 pieces for the face of the fireplace. A good installer would do that with only one piece and cut the opening to fit the firebox, similar to cutting the hole for a sink in a kitchen island countertop. Your installer is just using leftover bits for the fireplace. You might as well use tile and have a better looking design.

    Sorry, you have to deal with this.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    chispa has a very good point. no way the builder is going to cut a brand new full slab for your fireplace.

    the circles parts are leftovers that were joined together.

    How it should be made is a large piece that fits the fireplace, and a hole cut out of it. the entire whole piece is placed on the surround. see the diff?


    I'd pick a nice tile and have them do that .

  • 6 years ago

    @chispa @beth h I agree. When we saw the fireplace we were thinking it’s so poorly done. And unfortunately, the builder doesn’t allow us to choose tile for the fireplace. They said it has to be the same as our countertops. I would love it if they let us customize a little bit more.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    how about you leave the fireplace for now. (it's really not that bad) and just get the countertops taken care of. since you're paying for all of the slab (yes?) ask them for the left over pieces. You can store them outside or in the garage.

    Then after you get settled, pick a tile or a look that you like and do the fireplace surround later. Maybe ask them for a small credit for leaving it as is and put towards something else? maybe upgrade the granite or something else in the home?


    what you could do later is go look for a 1/4 or 1/2 slab of marble. something really cool looking. and have it cut correctly for your surround. I love this black/white marble. they even did a piece on top of the mantle frame. (and the match up is pretty good). you could go to a fabricators shop and see if they have any (or ask them to keep their eyes open for you) leftover exotic marble or granite pieces. Smaller leftovers often go in the trash.



    I'd do something like this Zellige tile with a nice natural wood beam, but that's me.




    maybe you'd rather have something like this?






  • 6 years ago

    As a "constant remodeler" I sympathize with the feeling when something doesn't look the same in real life as it did in your mind. However, I can tell you that different light bulbs will make a huge difference in the colors of your granite. Experiment with several of the "daylight" LED's, and when you find one that gives you the look you want, buy enough to replace all the bulbs...twice. Builders put in the cheapest (and usually ickiest) bulbs. Our experience over the years is that these bulbs change constantly so you want plenty on hand if one or several go out before the others to avoid the polka dot look in your ceiling, so that's why the extras. This will not be inexpensive, but way less than replacing the granite. Also changing the color of the wood mantel and surround will change your granite, keep that in mind too. It doesn't have to be white, is easy to paint, and that goes ditto for the wall space surrounding your kitchen and bathroom granite. It's probable a different wall and/or ceiling color will "meld" your granite to your cabinets, and it's a lot easier to paint walls than cabinets. Appliance colors will also help, experiment before purchase if you can. Your granite is lovely, and just a few tweaks will probably bring it up to your expectations.

  • 6 years ago

    Sorry for the delay in responding to the later comments! I really appreciate it. Here’s an update on our granite.

    So it turned out that our granite did not work out after all. For some reason, the granite starting crumbling very badly in some areas of our master bathroom and kitchen sinks. At first the builder was going to epoxy the damaged areas but we pushed for a replacement. And thankfully the the company replaced all the granite in our home but we were afraid to take the risk of a “faulty granite” again so we upgraded to quartz (we only paid the upgrade price difference ~$1000).

    We were so relieved and really believe God answered our prayers. Now we can don’t have to look at blotchy countertops every day!

  • 6 years ago

    @rachelathome We do plan to change out our bulbs eventually because they are really yellow and dull!

  • 6 years ago

    That is wonderful! (replacement). We are now planning a kitchen remodel and probably will use honed granite or quartz (though I long for marble). I will keep your experience in mind while choosing. Your new quartz is lovely.

  • 6 years ago

    Definitely sounds like your prayers were answered. It all looks so beautiful and calm now. Enjoy your new home!

  • 6 years ago

    @rachelathome tyvm! Marble is beautiful. However, I did hear that it’s not as durable as quartz and more porous than other natural stones. Our real estate broker builds many homes and he says he prefers not using marble for these reasons. I’m assuming with proper maintenance, it can last long though! I hope this info and my experiences with granite will help you make your decisions for your remodeling!

    @msteezzy Thank you so much! We love it being so simple and calm. We can now actually see when the countertops have something on them such as splatter from cooking and pepper flakes :)

  • 6 years ago

    @E Weaver (and @Trem Wills), I can assure you that God did not answer your prayers about your build project, but that is off topic.

  • 6 years ago

    Very off topic

  • 6 years ago

    @strategery You may be right but it felt so at the time! I am pretty sure there are a handful of home buyers have gone through the unfortunate situation we did. We now know to be more selective in what we pick for our next home in the future.

  • 6 years ago

    @strategery -- You may be able to assure yourself of that, but I'm quite certain you're not going to be able to assure anyone of faith. Given that you can neither prove nor disprove what God did - or didn't do (or, quite frankly, whether God is or isn't)- then by definition, it is a matter of faith. You are of course free to choose not to have any, but it's a bit presumptuous, and incorrect, to try to dictate anyone else's (can't be done, by its very nature). And even if you could, I can't imagine why you'd want to. The OP is thrilled that her problem is resolved and whether she believes it to be divine intervention, universal karma or just dumb luck, why would that possibly make a difference to you, so much so that you took the time to come here to rain on her parade?

  • 6 years ago

    Beautiful and so much better. Thank God for small gifts as well as large miracles. Or don't. :)

  • 6 years ago

    @lettersatoz @crcollins1_gw thank you both! I didn’t want the topic of religious differences to become such a serious topic in this thread and didn’t really know how to respond to the other commenter. I tried to keep it as light as possible. God bless you both and everyone, whether we are the same or different in this aspect in life <3