Software
Houzz Logo Print
lilyfinch

Some pitiful roses , what would you do ?

Hi everyone! I have a few sad specimens planted in the ground that never took off . They are alive , but hardly healthy. Betty white , sharifa asma , and mill on the floss which I am most upset about . They have leaves but are honestly in such sorry shape .

what do you do when this happens ? Pot them up? pitch and start over ? leave and coddle for now ? They are so far behind and so sad .


Comments (26)

  • 6 years ago

    Lilyfinch, your garden is s new, i'd definitely give them time. Were they OR or grafted. My Pretty Jessica has been slow going, but going none the less. I think Sharifa is small to start with so may need a bit of coddling. Are they all getting enough water? I'm sure getting enough sun isn't the problem! LOL! :-)

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    I'm the wrong person to be doling Rose Advice....but I dug a scrawny one out, and planted a new one in it's place.

    It was only a 1 year BR, and there was not much feeder roots when I -gently- shoveled it out and repotted it. No idea if it's due to warmer soil due to it being potted or because I put a dash of starter fertz in the pot when I repotted, but strangely enough, it took off this year, in the pot !

  • 6 years ago

    In a pot here, Betty White was huge, had very fragrant flowers, and was gorgeous. I did get rid of mine though...because its flowers were always thrips damaged after the first few years. It was one of my first roses...so maybe it took that long for the thrips to find them???

  • 6 years ago

    Vapor , all 3 are grafted . And are in full sun . Also , ones planted at the same times in the same condition are blooming and at least 2 foot or more tall. These have been frozen in time ! The have those starter leaves and that’s about it .

    Carol , I definitely already have thrips . I’d love to see just one bloom on Betty before I decide . It’s so hard bc you never know what the outcome will be either way!! And every time I pass by I let it be a reflection of my skills and I know it’s not really my fault but I’m kinda picking on myself over these.

    A1an I think a pot certainly can’t hurt and I’m glad your took off for you ..

    I have to ask what is happening with your zone that it’s cooler on weekends?! Lol do you have two gardens


    ugh I shall post this and hang my head in shame


    To think I call myself a rose gardener

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Lily If you do not have any other rose right now that you absolutely need the space for I would give them more time. I have some times been amazed at the difference one more year makes. If after another year the issue does not improve then remove them. Mill on the Floss is brand new this year right? I read it is a very vigorous rose so maybe it is just a bit delayed this year. I would not however move them unless I am just removing them permanently.

  • 6 years ago

    Kiss Me Kate. That’s all I have to say. Kiss Me Kate. She has been the slowest, wimpiest plant EVER. But lo and behold she has two blooms. She’s never even had one.

    This is her chance to turn into Kenneth’s Kiss Me Kate. Her chance to finally grow up.

    So I think you should give them at least one more year. Some start soooooo slow. Just let them sit and figure out who they want to be. And perhaps next season or maybe even later this season they will finally get their act together.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Also, maybe a little dilute alfalfa tea? You could make up a gallon and try a bit to see if helps. For how long have these been in the ground?

  • 6 years ago

    I vote give them time...I have soooo many that improved leaps and bounds by the next year.

  • 6 years ago

    Prob since February? I certainly won’t throw them away . Maybe I’m just going through a phase in the garden where I’m making mountains out of molehills . I do have a lot doing pretty good !!! I have some compost concentrate I bought . I’ll give that a try . Thanks guys !!!

    Ben what did you do with Madame a ? Is she doing better for you ?

  • 6 years ago

    You are making me laugh! Barely three months!!! You are getting very spoiled there in CA. : )) Soon you'll be hoping for plants that barely grow and stay tiny. LOL! : ))

  • 6 years ago

    That’s exactly what I was going to say, Vap! I’ve had some pitiful looking roses that I just kept thinking about removing. Low and behold, they just needed time. At some point, you’ll be wishing for some sort of magic potion that will stop your roses from growing any more enormous than they already are. You’ll be pruning some twice a year, and cutting off long canes while deadheading between prunings. Since that’s not likely, you’ll be glad for the ones that stay small, or grow slowly before long:) Lisa

  • 6 years ago

    Jen,

    After three long years, Mme A got her act together.


    I can totally relate to wanting blooms right away. There are so many roses to try, and so little space!

    Lilyfinch z9a Murrieta Ca thanked BenT (NorCal 9B Sunset 14)
  • 6 years ago

    I have 3 own root Tamora starting their second year and they are a quarter the size of all the others planted at the same time.

    Ive had 1 bloom between the three.


    I also have a Chianti in its second year that is tiny and has never bloomed. It’s in a prime spot, too.


    I actually have multiples of every rose and some planted right next to each other are growing at different paces.

    I know it’s anecdotal but it’s happening to me right now.


  • 6 years ago

    The rose in your picture looks healthy enough. It doesn't look like it's in decline, just not growing . If it was declining, I'd dig it up and pot it up. Often I've saved a rose doing that. But I have also had some bare root plants that did nothing the first year and went on to grow the next year after the roots became established.

    I used to plant tiny own root plants directly in the ground but I pot them up now . They seem to do better in the ground once they have bigger roots on them, jc.

    Lilyfinch z9a Murrieta Ca thanked erasmus_gw
  • 6 years ago

    I'm with vaporvac--I'd mix up some alfalfa tea and feed the soil.

    Lilyfinch z9a Murrieta Ca thanked subk3
  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Erasmus, I think i have a couple of yours actually. I planted several in poor locations, against your advice, but they are still growing. Just a little slower.

    at this time in my life, I was worried I’d kill them if I left them in pots. I just haven’t had the free time I’d like to baby them all.

    having said that- I don’t mind waiting if my plans eventually turn out the way id hoped. And so far, it’s looking good.


    in the future, I will do that for sure Because I am generally inpatient!

  • 6 years ago

    After looking back on the number of original roses I still have from Day 1 (about 4 years ago now) I only have 8 survivors and 2 of them are in my section of good luck, I hope your desire to live and grow is greater than death. They are not totally neglected per se when placed in that section but they aren't coddled either. Black spot is allowed to run it's course as is anything else to come along. Those 2 (climbers that haven't learned to grow) are out of sight from the yard, have plenty of sun, but aren't determined to go. I don't have the heart to send them to an early death either.


    On the other hand, I ripped out a rose from a big pot that would not grow, or die on Monday and planted a Savannah rose in it's place. The doomed rose was entirely stagnant and life is too short to give it another chance to prove it's resolve to live and thrive.


    Some of the struggling roses in the years since starting responded extraordinarily well to earthworm compost placed around the plant. It snapped them awake from their slumber and lots of growth followed. But yet, some of the other roses didn't respond. I pulled a few up from their ground and gave them the garbage can treatment. If your roses have not taken to deep roots yet, I'd suggest digging them up, line the hole with the earthworm compost and give them another chance. My roses that were planted this way have all thrive very well. Lots of growth too.


    Lilyfinch z9a Murrieta Ca thanked DVS inFL (Zone 9a)
  • 6 years ago

    DVS - I've been trying to figure out why my roses did better a few years ago...and maybe it has to do with my having a worm tower contraption...I gave the roses worm leachate diluted with water every week and they got worm soil. Hmmm....I'll see how they do this year...maybe I'll get another worm tower.


    Lilyfinch - we always have cooler weekends. I don't know why. When my husband worked (he's retired now) he could never, ever mow the lawn during the weekend...it always rained. LOL I hope your Betty White does well...you'll love the fragrance...mmmm... And, nope, I have a perennial garden in the backyard. The plants there are funny...there's no room for the roots to go downwards...so the roots all spread outwards. Where there's a will, there's a way. I also have a cement planter in the front yard under the window. Probably 8 feet long. I have a John Davis there, my Holly Bells and the mystery rose we got from the backyard.

  • 6 years ago

    These are the ones I mentioned earlier. I have been pretty careful with them.


    Tamora



    Chianti


    Tess



  • 6 years ago

    My Tess has taken a long time to grow. I think it's just the variety, but she's so far worth it.

  • 6 years ago

    I have nowhere else to put most of mine, so they stay as long as they aren't dying off.


    My Tess had 1 bloom last year and it was really pretty. Nothing yet this year, even after I trimmed the tree to get more sun.

  • 6 years ago

    My Sharif’s asma is a wimp too. It has been 3 years and so I am going to pot her up and maybe die of neglect as I am not good with caring for pots.


    I will replace her with Moolight in Paris. I do worry about rose replant disease and whether that is another factor I have to consider when I replace a rose.


    The problem for me with the runts in my extremely crowded and shaded garden is that they get overshadowed by the companion plants. So I find putting them in a pot in the bed they are supposed to be in for a while lifts them up so they actually get more sun. Then I can actually see if they are getting enough sun to flower.


  • 6 years ago

    Jc , I think once tamora takes off you’ll be so surprised. I bought one last year own root and it has really grown and is quite pretty !!

    Tototoro I have the small problem with shade from companions . I have a few roses in ground that I don’t even know how they are doing anymore :( they are alive and hopefully planning on bursting through soon .

    DVs , I love the idea about the worm compost. I used to buy a lot in Tennessee and felt like it was magic . I forgot about it here , I’ll be on the lookout.

    I see my mill on the floss is growing more so I’ll let it be for now .

    It’s so hard when you don’t have much space to be so generous! Lol

  • 6 years ago

    I have had some experience with roses that didn't grow. Two things to consider: do you have voles, possibly, that could be eating the roots? Or even rabbits? Or second, black walnut trees in the vicinity.

  • 6 years ago

    You can buy worm castings from Amazon. Even subscribe and save!