Software
Houzz Logo Print
richmooremi

Advice requested for circular raised garden/fire pit

6 years ago

I bought a house in Michigan last year and have been improving my back yard. I have an 18' daimeter circular area that was being used as a small fire pit area and overgrown garden (I assume that there was a pool here at some point) that I want to fix up.

Essentially, I'd like to build 4 arc-shaped raised planters out of stone/brick, each with a smaller ledge for sitting, facing a fire pit in the center of the area. There will a 24" pathway between each planter to the fire pit area.

I have very little experience landscaping and have a few questions about this project:

As a beginner, is this a feasible project or am I setting myself up for failure? I'm willing to put in a lot of work, but would like to know if this is a bad design before buying the supplies.

Can I use rectangular or trapezoidal bricks (the rectangular bricks I was looking at are 14" x 7" x 5") or should I use Allan Blocks or something similar? Or something completely different?

If I place pavers in the center and walkway areas, should I create a bed of gravel and sand like is recommended for creating a patio? Should I do that under the entire area?

Would I be better off paying someone a local landscaping company to do this? I don't want to spend more thank $4500.

Thanks in advance!

Comments (2)

  • 6 years ago

    I can think of a few challenges. One is frost heave. Basically you're building lots of small retaining walls and, while their support doesn't have to begin at frost line, a sizeable bed of drainable gravel is usually suggested. See some online details for modular retaining walls. The second is how you plan to put your masonry together. You probably should use a product meant for short retaining walls that do not require mortar. Plan your detailing well at all the corners you're going to have.

  • PRO
    6 years ago

    You're trying to take advantage of a feature that already exists. No one would really know if this is the best place in your yard to put a fire pit, or if it's going to end up looking like one of those monster features that are out of place. In order to know, one would do a master plan of the whole back yard, considering all the future development, and see how it shakes out. Whether the location is in good proximity to other use areas will play a part in determining its success. What exists in the yard at the present, could actually be fairly easily reconfigured. Also, it's perimeter circle looks haphazardly done. I wouldn't let the existence of this control where I put a firepit. It would be better to pick the best place, create the best structure, and heal the lawn back into sod if it turns out this is not the best place.

    As far as the plan itself, the 24" paths are too tight. Given that the plan includes confinement, 48" would be a better minimum path width.I don't know what kind of fire source you'll be using and its size, but one complaint that recurs is when people cannot adjust their position relative to the fire in order to be at a comfortable temperature. Consider a simpler design that doesn't involve raised beds and built in seating, but is merely a patio with the firepit and that there is movable seating available. It would be a whole lot more versatile ... and probably less offensive to a future home buyer should the house ever be sold. I'm not sure that combining a veggie growing area with a firepit is a great idea. It may work, but may also be limiting, cumbersome and possibly unappealing to future buyers. It might be better to have a separate garden for veggies somewhere else in the yard.