Don't know what color it is now....but a mission stucco should be painted in a natural sort of "adobe" beige color. And I would paint the arrows the same color as the house. Charming house....would love to see the inside!

Thank you! I'll get pic of color:

It's currently tan but looks mauve-hinted times

Congratulations on purchasing a lovely home. It’s a bit pink now but a new paint job will make it shine. You could consider a soft taupe. Have fun.

Lovely!! What part of the world is it?

I wouldn't put contrasting paint on the arrows....the shadows accent perfectly. As for paint color....think California Mission pinkish-tan. probably that's very close to what it is now....the color of adobe clay.

Chattanooga, Tennessee!