Software
Houzz Logo Print
marigold33_gw

Let's discuss Echinaceas!

6 years ago
last modified: 6 years ago

I have Magnus, Adobe Orange, which is a bright compact orange, it's great, I have two of them, I also have Sombrero Salsa Red, Hot Summer one died, one overwintered, and Rainbow Marcella one died one overwintered.

I recently ordered PowWow white and Magnus Superior.

I'm looking to add to my collection and I'd love to know if anyone has experience with any of these on my list. I'm looking for bright colors that would do well in my zone 7. Which coneflowers have done well in your garden? Thank you for any insight.

These are the ones on my list of considerations

Flamenco Sombrero

Tiki Torch

Kismet White

Kismet Yellow

Fine Feathered Parrot

Apricot Marcella

Sombrero Granada Gold

Comments (8)

  • 6 years ago

    I did have Cheyenne Spirit and it was lovely. But the following season although it came back strong but by mid summer it began to slowly decline. It turned brown, wilted until it finally perished. I have no idea what happened but I might give it another try.


    I love my Sombrero Adobe Oranges, I think I'm going to add Sombrero Granada Gold along with Green Jewel which looks interesting. I may also add Double Scoop Bubble Gum to my list and I'm considering Coconut Lime, thank you for the suggestions!

  • 6 years ago

    There are multiple discussions on the forum about performance, and a key seems to be making sure you get a cultivar of a particular species, and not a hybrid of two species. The hybrids are notoriously unreliable. One of yours listed above, Magnus Superior, I have grown from seed and it is reliable for me. I also have Bravado, Prairie Splendor, and the standard E purpurea, which have all done well, also from seed. Have tried and lost nursery-purchased Pow Wow Wild Berry twice.

  • 6 years ago

    I've had bad luck with the hybrids also, if they survived into and over winter (a rare event) they only lasted a year or two. I think Cantaloupe lasted 3. Pink Double Delight also lasted several years (and was a favorite plant) but then disappeared. Probably 8 others, if not more, were failures after the first season.

    Cheyenne Spirit is several years old, but though I took care to pick 2 that were in bloom so I knew that they had the varied colors, they have only bloomed the traditional purple/pink. Perhaps they died unnoticed, and some seed from a purpurea (which have thrived in the same planting bed for many years) took their place.

    White Swan and Green Envy are the only others that have persisted for many years.

    But I do have one surprise this year - a red one (either Tomato Soup or perhaps Salsa Red ) that I planted 2 years ago resurrected itself from the presumed dead (no sign of it last year!) and is blooming splendidly right now.

  • 6 years ago

    If I understand the breeding of the fancy colored ones correctly, the zone 7 isn't important, the NY is. They are not going to be fond of humidity, and that is the variable you should use to screen advice.

  • 6 years ago

    I've tried many of the seed strains and I'd consider those very reliable: PowWow WB and White, Prairie Splendor, Magnus, Ruby Star, Cheyenne Spirit, White Swan. Last year I added Mellow Yellow and they seemed to have all come back. Surprising for a yellow Echinacea. I've not found Echinacea to be particularly long lived so if you want to maintain the non-purple colors or certain other characteristics then you have to be willing to add them back every once in a while. They seem to have the tendency to reseed back to close to the species, though not always. I thought all my Pow Wow white were gone because I had no white flowers last year. Now that garden has a random white plant about 4 feet from the all the purple ones. Go figure.


    Of the hybrids, Hot Papaya has been very reliable for me and one of my favorites.

  • 6 years ago

    My White Swan reverted but all my others have kept their colors. Most of the seedlings that come up are bright purple (like the color of PW Wild Berry) but I've gotten some multi-color ones near the CS. I've got a dark orange CS, a red CS, and a straight E. purpurea all planted next to each other and I've gotten some and light orange seedlings from them.


    I love hot papaya, but I've tried it three times and it's never come back.

  • 6 years ago
    last modified: 6 years ago

    Thanks very much for the insight everybody. I'd like echinacheas that don't act like biennials. I already have Denver Daisies and a few others which I know are biennials.

    I don't have many coneflowers but when we moved here it seems there's a coneflower that's been here for about 10 years, then I bought Magnus which has been here for about 4-5 years and more recently Adobe Orange which are in their second and third seasons and they appear to be going strong.

    As mentioned I just planted Magnus Superior and PowWow White. The others which I have Rainbow Marcella, Hot Summer and Red Sombrero appear to be more tender, I hope they continue returning.

    I definintely want to try Double Scoop Bubble Gum and Coconut Lime but it seems they're sold out everywhere.

    The "Kismet" series I was interested in for their long bloom season and their trials saying they've overwintered to zone 4 had me want to give them a try. But the places I wanted to purchase them are all sold out, so until next year on those too.

    I already bought Green Jewel. I'm about to purchase Double Scoop Raspberry, Green Twister, Delicious Candy and Cara Mia. I looked into whatever information I could find about them but I can't attest to their hardiness so I guess I'll see what happens.

    If you have more recommendations for the more reliable long lived coneflowers that would be very helpful, thanks again.