Hi,

When I look at photos online of Berwyn, I see taupey colours, more than grey.

I went to tilebar to see what might go, since you state you don't want subway.

Here are a few ideas. You can order 5 samples for $5 so it is worth ordering some options and seeing them in real life with your counters and cupboards.

I wondered about this one. Has a few shades and tones going on, and the square shape makes it a little different from the norm.

Montauk Collection | TileBar.com · More Info

Same tile as above, this is the white, the other one I think they call it grey - looks beige and taupe to me.

Montauk Collection | TileBar.com · More Info

A little different texture here. I know it is subway shape, but the stacked rather than offset layout brings a different vibe to it.

Maya Collection · More Info

This one is so pretty. It is a bit distressed on the edges which may or may not work for you but I like what looks like a bit of iridescence

Beige & Cream Subway Tiles, Ceramic, Porcelain & More · More Info

This one comes in several colours. You can lay this one horizonally as well. Different but still very classic. I feel like the colour might work with the counters.

Manchester Hexagon Dove Gray 4x8 Polished Ceramic Tile · More Info

IMO a busy quartz needs a simple backspalsh maybe thing taupr glass subway tile in a stacked pattern with matching grout.

I hate subway tile. It's just not going to happen.

You do you! But I will say this, if by subway you mean the traditional 3 X 6 size, yes, it is a bit overdone. But there are lots of other sizes that are more interesting, 2 X 8, 2 X 10, 3 X 10, 3 X 12 etc.....there might be something in those sizes that might do it for you. But there are lots of other shapes out there too - Tilebar has so many ideas - it is a good place to look for a start.