Software
Houzz Logo Print
debodun

Mulch Or Don't Mulch

5 years ago

I've heard theories on both sides. Some say that mulch protects roots of plants from winter kill. Others say it smothers the plants. What say you?

Comments (7)

  • 5 years ago

    Who says it smothers the plants? Most horticultural sources consider mulching one of the best thing you can do for your garden. A properly applied mulch will suppress weeds, moderate soil temperature swings, conserve soil moisture, protect bare soil from erosion and compaction and if a good organic type of mulch, add to soil fertility. Nothing theoretical about it at all!

    You just want to avoid piling it on excessively - 2-4 inches is plenty (less than 2 is not worth the effort) and you want to avoid direct contact with any woody stems or trunks. But herbaceous perennials and bulbs will grow right up through it.

  • 5 years ago

    What are you using as mulch and what plants are you mulching?

    tj

  • 5 years ago

    Debodun, can you provide some examples of why mulching is bad? It's new to me! Overmulching, or piling mulch against plants/trees is bad, but I can't think of a disadvantage.

  • 5 years ago

    I have a lilac bush that the maple leaves get trapped at the base. They are whole dried leaves, but probably 5 or 6 inches deep.

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    6 inches sounds like a lot. To me, fallen leaves as not "mulch" just yet. I would rake them and shred them (with a mower) and then spread them under the bush in a 2-inch layer, making sure the leaves are not touching the base of the bush.

    I had to deal with lots of maple leaves in my previous garden. They get matted and slimy when wet, and smother any plants trying to grow underneath. Those matted leaves also provide a nice shelter for rodents that may want to chew on the lilac bark during the winter. So I would clean it up a bit, but don't discard the leaves completely. Shred them and turn them into mulch or compost.

  • 5 years ago

    Loose, dead leaf accumulation at the base of multi-stemmed woody plants is not really a "mulch" concern. There is still plenty of openings for oxygen exchange (no smothering) and unless they become saturated and compacted, there is minimal chance of rot. This happens all the time in forests or wooded environments with no ill effects,

    Piling a shredded bark mulch or compost or even shredded leaves up into the same location would provide a very different situation and potential outcome.

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    ...and it’s a lilac. I have one in the corner of my yard that leaves often blow into coupled with dead fern foliage that I never clean out and it does fine.

    tj