Software
Houzz Logo Print
kam_bains81

Same or Different tile in spice kitchen and mudroom?

5 years ago

I am having a hard time deciding what would work if our spice kitchen (to the left) and mudroom (the right door) both are facing off the main kitchen, should both those rooms have the same tile? I had originally picked a white matte marble tile 24x24 size for spice kitchen and then a grey 5x5 hex matte tile for mudroom. The tiler thinks I should use the same tile in both rooms as you’ll see both rooms tiles when the doors are open. Is a white marble matte tile a bad idea for a mudroom? My main kitchen has oak flooring. What are your thoughts?

Comments (11)

  • 5 years ago

    are you talking about floor tile? and forgive me but is a spice kitchen similar to a butlers pantry? I don't think you need both, why not carry the kitchen flooring into the spice kitchen and then do your gray tile in the mudroom?

  • 5 years ago

    K.I.S.S. rule works: Keep it Simple Sally....think this through. Inside of 4 feet you will have THREE different floors. That's not something people normally do. The concept is 1floor everywhere. Kitchens are allowed to have their own flooring. That means two floors in one space = acceptable. Now think about adding a THIRD floor inside of a few feet of the TWO acceptable finishes. Right.


    Go with all the same tile as the kitchen and leave it be. Continuity is about materials continuing OR about COLOUR continuing. The only way you can have continuity = same tile.


    It is your house. You need to be happy in it. If you are TOTALLY IN LOVE with the GRAY TILE and have NOWHERE ELSE to put it...then put it in the mud room. And then leave the door closed.


    Remember: the more floors you have in a small area, the more it looks like you couldn't afford to do all the flooring at the same time...and you couldn't afford to purchase enough product to finish the project.


    Not trying to be mean...but it is what many people 'see' all the time when houses have 'piece by piece' renovations. It is something you want to avoid.

  • 5 years ago

    Thank you. Your feedback was very helpful!

  • 5 years ago

    Can I ask you about tiling a master en-suite, would you run marble on all four walls of the en-suite or just in shower and maybe behind soaker tub? We are doing a white statuario Calacutta tile on the walls and a grey tile on the floor. I want to put some oak floating shelves on the vanity wall next to the soaker tub, I’m worried if we run the Calcatta tile on all four walls our bathroom might look too busy, especially if we have black fixtures that are quite bold.

  • 5 years ago

    I like it behind soaker tub, so no to all 4 walls

  • 5 years ago

    Hi - I'd keep the left spice kitchen in the same oak as the kitchen and put the hex gray tile in the mudroom.

  • 5 years ago

    Those are EXPENSIVE panels. How much is your budget? The install is TRICKY. You MUST PAY to have your walls furred out (made flat and plumb and square). That can add $$$$ just to get something on them. They are beautiful tiles. I have no issue with them on the wall, but your budget just go MUCH bigger. The tiles are only one purchase point out of an extra dozen or so that you must pay for.


    When glossy tiles are applied to a wall that is NOT flat/square/plumb you get a VERY obvious difference or surface angle. It can be heart breaking to find out the wall - you did NOT pay for to be furred out - is the BIG issue.


    I like the idea of a focus wall behind the tub....but all 4 walls is going to be seriously expensive. Can you add several thousand more to your budget? Did you get a quote to get those walls furred out? If you did not, I suggest you ask to have that done BEFORE you ask for the tile on the walls be added.

  • 5 years ago

    Hi SJ, sorry to confuse you, we are actually not applying slabs to our en-suite shower walls, they are 24x48 tiles, I was just trying to show the calacatta design of our tiles. You got me thinking now, do 24x48 tiles require furring out the shower walls? Does the tiler furr out walls for any size gloss tile?

  • 5 years ago

    The 24x48 tiles are 13mm thick, that will probably shrink our shower a bit once they are applied if the walls aren’t furred out 😬 Or there is a slimstone option to apply a 5mm thickness calacatta tile, which weighs a lot less than the thicker wall tile.

  • 5 years ago

    @Jennifer Havin A spice kitchen is an enclosed secondary cooking space, usually equipped with a powerful extractor fan, where very "aromatic" food is prepared.

  • 5 years ago

    Holy cow bat man! A 13mm thick tile! That's 1/2" thick!


    @Summer S It is up to you to specify what is done with the structuring of the home. That is to say you must have a contract that clearly states you want work done that includes furring out the walls (level, flat, square). Some tilers will *try. But in the building world, a framer is the one to do this.


    And if you are a bit of a perfectionist and will disappointed with a wonky, wavy tile installation (especially glossy tiles...any change in plane will cause the tile to reflect light in a different direction = very noticeable), then you better revise your contract to include the walls.


    Is this a complete gut of the bathroom? Or is this a new build? Who is the GC? What does your contract say about the wall surface and the water proofing?