Durable Kitchen Dining Table

5 years ago

last modified: 5 years ago

Looking for advice on what everyone thinks the most durable kitchen table top is. Marble didn't last for us, and I've seen pencil marks on wood tables. i am strongly considering the Acero Table by Arhaus. It has a thin layer of oxidized iron on top. I would like any insight you may have on its durability/ esthetics. Would have to purchace by tomorrow to catch the Memorial Day sale. Acero Table

This is the kitchen where it will go. The floors will be refinished darker. The length in the room exceeds 13 ft so there is ample space.

I have these wood chairs form Pottery Barn that I plan on using.

Wynn Chair

Any advice is greatly appreciated!

Dana

Sort by:Oldest

Comments (11)

PRO
Patricia Colwell Consulting
5 years ago
I have no idea but what was the issue with marble I have seen marble tables in Europe that are 50 yrs old and still look awesome in homes with 4 or 5 kids
Dana Kinder
Original Author
5 years ago
Water stains and finish damage. This table has a thin layer of oxidized iron.
Related Professionals
Spanish Fork Interior Designers & Decorators · York Interior Designers & Decorators · Harrisburg Kitchen & Bathroom Designers · Louisville Furniture & Accessories · Hartford Furniture & Accessories · Brooklyn Furniture & Accessories · Provo Furniture & Accessories · Beckley Furniture & Accessories · Elgin Furniture & Accessories · Covington Cabinets & Cabinetry · Wichita Falls Cabinets & Cabinetry · Bartlesville Architects & Building Designers · Salinas Architects & Building Designers · Cody Architects & Building Designers · Trenton Kitchen & Bathroom Designers
ratherbesewing
5 years ago
I had a piece of glass cut to cover my wood tabletop 20+ years ago. The only limitation is adding/removing table leaves.
PRO
Patricia Colwell Consulting
5 years ago
Honestly IMO this table top will give yo more greif than glass. IMO get a nice wood table which BTW will suit the cahirs and get a piece of glass cut if your family can’t respect the table. or use a tble cloth when you use the table.
Maureen
5 years ago
You can’t beat a reclaimed table as marks just become part of its feel and there are finishes you can add to protect the surface. Look for darker shading throughout to work with your chairs.
apple_pie_order
5 years ago
"Oxidized iron" means rust. From the description: "As iron is prone to rust, avoid contact with excessive moisture." So that means not getting water on a dining table? And how do you wipe off spaghetti sauce or milk if you can't use soapy water or any of the cleaners they recommend avoiding? And if you wipe off the rust, your cleaning cloth will carry the rust so it could get rust on something else. What happens if your white sleeves touch the rusty top?

For my $3300, I'd rather have something easy to clean with just as much style. A live edge wood table with a water-safe finish would be much better, for example.
Dana Kinder
Original Author
5 years ago
OK!! Thank you for talking me out of it! I am glad i asked. I ended up with this beauty with solid oak!

Paired with a bench

and the truth is I am dying for this chandelier:

Can't step a foot again in that store, everything is jaw-dropping gorgeous!

Again, many thanks for your advice!

Dana
Maureen
5 years ago
Just lovely!
Ann Mhnson
4 years ago
How is the solid oak table working out. I was looking at the bluestone table top from Arahaus but hearing that is not durable either. We struggle with heat spots even when using hot pads currently on our PB bench Wright table. It has worn horribly but has been 8 years.
PRO
Jikoni Interiors
4 years ago
Hi,

We have a blog that talks about granite and wooden worktops, please do have a read and i hope it can inspire you.- Please see link below

Top 5 Kitchen Designs for 2022 - (jikoniinteriors.com)

Regards

Jikoni Interiors
L H
2 years ago
We are also considering the Mihaela that you got. How has it held up?