Of the two the second one. Although I’d personally choose a different material

A material other than leather?

I like the style of the first and the color of the second.

Why are you replacing brown leather sofas with brown leather sofas? Your other furniture in the room is fairly traditional, so I'd use the one with the small rolled arms. But maybe replace one of your current leather sofas with a lighter colored fabric sofa if you're just looking to make a change.

One of my existing sofas still has sone life but the seats on the other one each have a small tear. iwe have had these sofas for 21 years so they have served us well. we have 6 grandchikdren 9 and under and ghought we should get something that would hold up well. Do you have suggedtions for something other than leather? im interested in a lighter look if it can hold up to a bunch if little boys!. Thanks!

Maybe a happy medium would be a mid range color and a style that is a combination of the two you showed. Your first one felt too dark/not the right style for room and the second, too light/bulky.

I do have a suggestion for a brand and a different material which will hold up forever. Brand is Flexsteel and the fabric is Kashmira. You have to see and feel this product and look at the gorgeous colors offered. Flexsteel furniture will last you forever. I bought a sofa and chair in 2000, and both look brand new.

https://www.flexsteel.com/kashmira.inc

I highly recommend.

Maureen, is that Pottery Barn?

judianna, there is a Flexsteel dealer within walking dustance of me. i‘ll check it out. Thanks!

Check it out...the Digby is the style I want you to look at...it is sleek, tight back...

Have the salesman show you how amazing the kashmira is with stains.

Here it is in leather:

I really like the style of the Flexsteel and one that Maureen recommended.

You could try one leather sofa with one sofa in a lighter colored Sunbrella fabric. I'm not familiar with the Kashmira fabric, but there are a lot of hard wearing, anti stain fabrics available now.

I‘m not familiar with brand, but just liked the style. There are 26 reviews that may help and you may want to research as well. https://www.wayfair.ca/furniture/pdp/sand-stable-angie-genuine-leather-8248-square-arm-sofa-c004296809.html?piid=#a3haxlgul74-3