Software
Houzz Logo Print
dsholt15

pocket window exterior trim

5 years ago
last modified: 5 years ago

Just got new pocket/insert windows installed on the upper level of my house, and I'm looking for opinions on the way that the installer did the aluminum exterior trim. Does this look weird to anyone else? I was not expecting that the trim would be protruding beyond the original window casing. The lower window in the photo is the original window for comparison.




Comments (10)

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Tough to say. The window edge looks pretty close to being flush with the exterior trim. That would definitely limit his options.

    dsholt15 thanked Windows on Washington Ltd
  • 5 years ago

    Thanks for the reply, Windows on Wash. A follow up question for you: am I correct that if we had gone with a window with a 3 1/4" jamb that the window would have been recessed enough that the window and trim would have fit properly within the existing exterior trim? The window we used had a 4 1/2" jamb.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Pocket window is a new term for me but I assume it means replacement window and from what I see i don't think there was a choice since the jamb was too large.

    dsholt15 thanked Patricia Colwell Consulting
  • 5 years ago

    Thanks Patricia. Yes, a pocket window, or insert window, is a replacement that allows the new window to fit within the existing frame, unlike a full frame/new construction window. I'm frustrated with the installer because I had specifically said that I wanted the window to fit within the existing trim and was promised it would. I'm trying to decide if it looks bad enough that I need them to do something about it, but it seems like I might be stuck with it.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    The narrower window could have been inset and a small trim return to the inside of the flat casing trim on the exterior would have more preserved the trim reveal.

    dsholt15 thanked Windows on Washington Ltd
  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Thank you HomeSealed for confirming everything I thought about this! That window is a Pella Lifestyle series. I did, in fact, have a discussion with the salesman about other window options after another installer told me specifically that they didn't use the Pella Lifestyle series for pocket replacements because of the larger jamb size. They told me the Architect series was made for pocket replacements. The Pella salesman assured me the Lifestyle would be fine and promised me it would fit the space. I don't know, maybe he had to hit a sales target on the Lifestyle series that month. I would have gladly paid more for the window that made me happy.

    I also pointed out that I was not happy relying on a single bead of caulk to keep out the water, because one of the replaced windows does not have the overhang protection (and as you point out, the lower units won't either) but of course I was told that it would be fine. I completely agree that the only solution is that the existing wood trim get fully cladded. I just have to convince my wife that it will look ok!

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    I cant make it out by the pictures as what they did nor am i familiar with the Lifestyles options. It would seem absurd to put in a new contruction window when they have inserts made for this.

    dsholt15 thanked toddinmn
  • 5 years ago

    Thanks toddinmin. It might be hard to tell from that photo, but they capped the gap between the new window and the existing wood casing with aluminum that juts out from the original casing about an inch. As I mentioned above too, one of these windows does not have an overhang for protection (added photo). I have scoured the internet and looked at houses around my neighborhood and can't find a single window that looks quite like this.


  • PRO
    5 years ago

    Now I see, the caulk joint looks to off in color. Never seen any one do that before.