Software
Houzz Logo Print
marianisha_isaac

Nahema and colette

5 years ago

Like to know the winter hardiness of nahema and Colette .I am in zone 5b

Comments (6)

  • 5 years ago

    I planted Colette this year in my zone 5 Colorado, after reading it is pretty hardy. Hoping mine will overwinter ok. It has grown a lot this summer considering it started as a very small band. Hope you have good luck with these if you decide on them!

    Crazyabout Roses thanked Sam CO z5
  • 5 years ago

    I have 3 Colette bushes from 5 to 18 years old and 1 Nahema, about 5 yrs old. Colette grows as a shrub here, but Nahema is a short climber to about 6'. Both are winter hardy. I don't winter protect at all. There is minor tip damage, and sometimes a black cane, but nothing major. This is a dry climate, if that makes any difference. We normally have a good insulating snow cover of several feet, but the last few years have been mild with freeze/thaw cycles and less snow, but that hasn't harmed these two. Good luck, I hope you love them.

    Crazyabout Roses thanked flowersaremusic z5 Eastern WA
  • 5 years ago

    Thank you sam and flowersaremusic.

    i am so happy to hear both these roses are winter hardy. we have snow cover most of winter in Illinois and i am definitely going to buy these 2 .

  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    If you buy Nahema get it as grafted like Floweraremusic. Nahema as own-root died twice on me in my heavy clay. Both own-root and grafted Nahema died on Kelly, zone 4 with good snow cover. Nahema is so wimpy that experienced rosarian in Pakistans can't root it.

    2 Nahemas (grafted) are stingy for another cold zoner. It died on a zone 7 person, it also died for a friend nearby. Nahema parent is Heritage, and Heritage does better for sandy & loamy folks than for heavy clay as own-root.

    Predfern nearby me with loamy soil has Nahema for many years, but it's NOT his top roses. I used to miss Nahema's scent after it died as own-root, but Princess Charlene de Monaco is way better in all aspects. PcDM gives 20 times more blooms than Nahema per flush, same with James Galway, Evelyn, Abraham Darby, Parfum de Paris, and Savannah .. all are just as fragrant and much more generous in my heavy clay & not much snow in winter.

    Crazyabout Roses thanked strawchicago z5
  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Thanks Strawchicago , i was thinking of buying own root but i better get the grafted Nahema from palatine roses.mine is heavy clay too.


    i have PCdM (planted in april’21) and right now it has one 6 feet cane and i had to use a step ladder to take this picture :) is james galway generous in flowers ? i was hearing the opposite - james galway and shropshire lad very stingy with flowers

0