Current:

I like stone with black windows.
But really depends on the stone you go with.
You can just paint the house trim. As well as the window trim black.

Sweet house!

There’s really no way for us to say for sure, you’ll need to get a pro in to see about it. We can say if we like stone or not (I do), but that’s about it. As far as colors, I’m with you — earthy and warm. But I’d do bronze or taupe windows.

See? It’s just personal preference. :)

A good pro will be able to provide renderings so you can get a visual idea of colors, sizes, etc.

Some options:

Stone across top of garage

Grey tones:

Beige tones:

Stone on top and half sides of garage

Grey tones:

Beige tones:

Hubby's preference: grey tones

My preference: beige tones

I think it clashes with your brick, way too cool-toned. Makes the facade look choppy, instead of integrated. I’d want the stone to look like it was there from Day 1, going for an eclectic cottage look … which would have different materials, but still flow naturally together.

Of course, any other design ideas would be greatly appreciated. :)