Software
Houzz Logo Print
jeffkwill

New kitchen location and layout, looking for feedback

5 years ago
last modified: 5 years ago

Hi all - I'm looking for some feedback from the community here regarding thoughts on a proposed plan we have for our kitchen. We're working with an architect and design firm that we really like and they've put together a proposal for us, but I'm curious if people here see any pitfalls or design flaws that we may not be thinking about.

Current Floorplan


We moved into our current home a year ago and knew at the time we'd want to change the kitchen layout and design, as the kitchen is landlocked in the middle of the first floor with too much traffic flowing through it, with insufficient counter space, too much distance between the range and sink, and a lack of storage within the kitchen itself. The house is 80 years old and the kitchen originally was at the rear of the house. In the past 25 years or so, previous owners made an addition where the family room and half of the breakfast room sit. As a result the kitchen is in the awkward location with a pass-through to the family room. It also has a lack of natural light.

The goals with our project include:

  • Relocate kitchen to increase space, reduce through traffic, and receive more natural light
  • Improve function with better layout and workspace
  • Include kitchen island if possible for workspace, hub for people to gather around, and improved traffic flow.
  • Add second oven (currently have (an old) single 36" Wolf range with a single oven
  • Add a walk-in pantry for increased storage and place to get larger items out of sight (e.g., small kitchen appliances)
  • Add butler's pantry with place for wine fridge and beverage drawer or beverage fridge
  • Maintain usable breakfast area & table (we are a family of four with two young boys)
  • Keep large mudroom -- we live in the midwest with snowy winters and wet springs, and put a lot of value in a mudroom for weather/mess reasons as well as a place for storage of coats, shoes, kids items, etc. The reality is that the mudroom is our primary entry and exit point into and out of the house both when it comes to leaving the house as well as going into the back yard.

When we began exploring options, we had trouble imagining accomplishing this without another addition to create more space -- at least as long as we wanted a breakfast area and table plus a walk-in pantry. The firm we are working with presented us with a number of plans and we've decided we like the plan below best. They have done their best to talk us down from the idea of an addition as they don't think the additional cost is worth it (let alone the additional time).

We also did not want to sacrifice our dining room as it's part of the character of the house, or make any major changes to the family room, which is a great room with tons of natural light (the six windows in the back are all the same. We also don't see another feasible place to move the TV -- we are not "TV over the fireplace" people, and our fireplace is higher than normal so the TV would be extra high if we tried to put it there, let alone small given the design of the built in on that wall.



Proposed Plan



The things we really like about this plan are that we get virtually everything we're looking for, although maybe not to the extent we would if we did an addition. That said, I want to sense check what people think about this plan. Some items I'm thinking about are below, but welcome feedback on all items.

  • The breakfast table really only has one place to go, in the family room where the plan shows it. We envision (really, insist on having) a sectional couch in a layout similar to what's shown here, but that doesn't leave a ton of room for a breakfast table. The plan here assumes just a 36 inch table and 4 chairs. My concerns are: (1) is this enough space, and (2) making sure we can feel like the table belongs there and that's not out place and jammed into a corner. The plan also includes increasing the doorway and replacing existing French doors with a larger sliding door in order to improve outdoor access from the family room
  • The width of the path between the kitchen island on both sides is smaller than ideal. I'm less concerned with this on the cooking area side, but it's still pretty narrow on the side that flows from the mudroom to family room.
  • The design here means that the prep sink on the island will be the primary sink while cooking and part of the work triangle, while the main sink is on the other side of the island and will likely become just a cleaning sink. I'm curious how people feel about this
  • The refrigerator is now moved into a walkway that is a major traffic flow path through the house. There's plenty of space between the refrigerator and island here and I don't think this is an issue, but want to sense check my thoughts.
  • The flow from the kitchen to the dining room isn't as direct as I would like as it includes a couple turns to get around the refrigerator and cabinets and then go through the butler's pantry. I wonder if the lack of line of sight from the kitchen means that we're less likely to use the dining room on more of an every day basis.
  • The kitchen island seating is less than ideal. The original design plan included having 3 stools on the long side of the island between the island and main sink. We nixed this idea because of concern that the alley would be too crowded, especially for somebody working at the sink, emptying/loading the dishwasher, etc.

Those are my initial thoughts and concerns, but look forward to getting feedback here from the community!

Comments (8)

  • 5 years ago

    I share your concerns about aisle width and fridge placement. I don't see a solution for the fridge location, but I like that it's convenient to the living areas. I would make the cabinetry on the window wall shallower and add those inches to the aisles. You can use standard upper cabinets for the base, with a strip of counter, then add uppers on each end, to flank the windows. I like having the MW closer to the fridge, but if it's a combo, then the wall ovens are better in the spot where you have them drawn. An alternative would be to have a MW drawer on the end of the island, opening toward the fridge--convenient for taking leftovers from the fridge to re-heat, but adding to traffic in the fridge aisle.


    Re: the breakfast area--you could omit the cabinets on the kitchen window wall and put the slider there (or keep the window/door configuration as is, if it's structurally sound), with a window in the FR/dining nook. Use a bench to make it look more built in/deliberate, and to add some extra storage. Also, without cabinets on the kitchen wall, the island could be made deeper, with an extra run of shallow cabinets. Pull-outs opening to the sides would make access easier for all but the inside cabs. You said you have two young kids, so send them under the seating overhang to retrieve items from those cabinets. ;)



    Either of the options above keep traffic from moving through the work aisle, but decrease storage and counter space.

    NKBA guidelines

    New to Kitchens? Read me first.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    It would be nice to see the new plan in the same format as the old one so it is possible to see what changed I will say it is important that you make the measurements clearer and IMO no walkway in a kitchen should be less that 42" and walkways behind stools need to be 60" I dislike walkin pantries and for sure any that are outside the work area of a kitchen. IMO get an actual kitchen designer and architects are the worst KDs but even good IDs have trouble with kitchen design

  • 5 years ago

    I agree with mama's changes. While I LOVE separate cleanup zones and prep/cooking zones, I wouldn't do it if it sacrifices min aisles, and puts seats in one of those aisles. You will hate that.


    Regarding your breakfast nook - Your family room is huge. It's awkward as it is now with the table in there because there's no separation in the room. Your insistence on a sectional is driving this entire room. If you rearrange some things I think it would be lovely. If this were my space, I would add a cased opening to separate those spaces - it could have a bit longer wall on one side, where you could put some cabinetry for games/coffee/dishes/whatever, as you obviously don't need 14'-1" for a 4 person table. I would also put your TV on the fireplace wall, either over the fireplace or in the cabinets to the side. And then I would ditch the sectional. 4 people can comfortably cuddle on a long couch. Plus having a TV across from all those windows means constant glare/always having the blinds closed. And that TV location is also in the main traffic path through the room, which is usually not desirable. But if you can't let go of that arrangement, I don't see any other way for you to have a breakfast table and not have it be kind of awkward.

  • 5 years ago

    if this were mine i'd line up the back 19 ft wall of garage with the left to right wall in kitchen[ range wall] then do more with a long straight wall for the kitchen.I'd remove the kitchen/family room wall that has the small overhang? with a pass through? and I'd remove the kitchen/breakfast area wall. Within this space you could place an island and still have space for a little table by the doors to patio. do you need four doors to patio total anyway? Because you have separate living and dining rooms I dont see any drawback to opening family /kitchen / and adjacent "breakfast area" .

  • 5 years ago

    Can the garage entrance move to the far left upper corner (right by the stairs)?

  • 5 years ago

    Your removing the mudroom?

    Second point - I think if you are, you should have the pantry there. And open the wall between the KITCHEN, DR AND LR.

  • PRO
    5 years ago

    If you switch out the round breakfast table for a rectangular one pushed up against the window wall at the top, you'll have better access to the slider. Sliding the sectional up to the window wall will also provide for a larger seating area.


    As for the walk-in pantry, it's pretty remote from the kitchen and would seem to be better used as a powder room. The pantry could then be reach-in along the bottom wall in place of the counter which won't get used much anyway.

  • 5 years ago

    Dunno. I might do something more like this. Obviously not detailed. Overall more kitchen, can have stools, has a ton of cabinet and counter. It's about the same walk with groceries. Could also move the garage door to left hand side of the kitchen shown here - reduce the one cabinet run by about 4 feet. I might do a coffee bar thing in the passage to the dining room (we love our coffee) or just kitchen storage (as if the kitchen wasn't big enough!).