Not quite a "modern" style home. I would look for something in the darker earthtones or an architectural bronze.

Thank you @Windows on Washington Ltd.

Earthtones would definitely be the safer choice, which I'm more comfortable with.

I found this home that is chicago brick like mine, with black windows. I just love the pop of the black windows, but totally different style home. I was looking for assurance to go black, but don't know that anyone would think it would work with my style home. Thanks!

Pretty home and I think that yours could be stunning with some color variances as well.

@Windows on Washington Ltd

I agree the earth tones (to match my home trim) would for sure be safe. I still want to think that black windows would work. Question - this metal trim piece around my front windows seems permanent. Regardless of what window color I choose, I believe it needs to be painted. See what I mean? It matches my home trim right now. This might be the decision maker, if painting it to match windows is the way to go - then all of a sudden I have a very thick black window rather than the thinner lines I like.

If, by metal trim, you mean the lentil above the windows at the brick, that can be painted in a matching color to the windows before or after the fact. I would do the prep before and possibly the prep and paint before.

For the record, architectural bronze is nearly black. Most will think it is from the street. If you are replacing the window, paint them up in a couple of different colors and see what works. They are coming out anyway.