Software
Houzz Logo Print
heleneo1974

Sub Zero - Side by Side or French Door

4 years ago

Looking to purchase a SubZero for our kitchen rennovation project and debating between a french door or side by side. We have a french door right now and I don't love the freezer drawer. That being said, are side by side models dated?

Comments (19)

  • 4 years ago

    I don’t have a view about whether they are dated or not but I have had both the 42” s x s and the 36” FD. When I redid my NYC kitchen in 2012, I replaced the s x s with a 36” FD. I also had a neighbor who had the 36 s x s. These are my thoughts:


    1. Anything less than a 42” in a s x s is challenging for storage. Crowded and awful. My neighbor, who was a great cook, couldnt wait to get rid of it.


    2. Even with a 42” s x s, the freezer was too narrow to accommodate some common things, like a lasagna pan. The shelving is otherwise nice and better than the bottom basket. That said, in my experience, the fridge is opened at least 10x more than the freezer so that advantage of the s x s wasnt important to me.


    3. In the S x s, I don’t like the placement of the produce bins at the very bottom. i vastly prefer them at waist level like they are in the over/under.


    4. I have the 36” over over/under (single door) in my country house. The FD door shelves have slightly less total capacity than the single, but its not significant.


    So in my view, the FD wins as long as it is at least 42”.

  • 4 years ago

    Had a 36” over/under SZ for 26 years (still going strong when we moved), so we’re used to the bottom freezer baskets. Got the 42” FD SZ, for the kitchen we renovated when we moved. It holds a ton of stuff, and I can fit anything in the wide freezer draws. Now almost six years later, not one issue.

    As for whether or not side by sides look dated…beauty is in the eye of the beholder. To me, they’ve always looked so. I’ve never understood the appeal of a sxs…the freezers are narrow, preventing large items (like a full size lasagna pan, mentioned by @nycbluedevil_gw, and whether in the freezer or the more used refrigerated side, you’re always bending down to get things from the lower shelves.

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    The fridge is opened way more often than the freezer, so that should be your priority. I personally much prefer french doors with freezer below, both for the ease of retrieving items and for the amount of storage provided.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    If space and budget aren’t a constraint, I’m with Nidnay. I have SZ fridge and freezer in 36” each, and while they’re trash quality-wise at this point, I’ve become fully accustomed to the convenience and a downgrade would be tough. I don’t even store tons of food, it’s just nice not to have space issues pretty much ever.

    Short of that option, I’d go with bottom freezer, french door or otherwise. With a slight preference for ”otherwise” depending on the space.

    heleneo1974 thanked foodonastump
  • 4 years ago

    Thank you. Do you have a picture of the 36" panels?

  • 4 years ago

    Sure. This was done late 90’s I believe. Kitchen is ready for a remodel but 8 years of college coming up. If I knew I were keeping the footprint I’d start replacing appliances. And to replace the SZ’s would take cabinet modification which I’m not anxious to deal with at this point.




  • 4 years ago

    Wow that is really cool. I dont think I have space for this but love it!!

  • 4 years ago

    Remember….you can get smaller columns. A 36” all refrigerator column has more fridge space than the typical combo fridge/freezer French door or side by side. You could do a 30” column.

  • 4 years ago

    If you have room for a 36" refrigerator and a 36" freezer, it's the best of both worlds. I've had this arrangement in the past and loved it. I have also had two 30" refrigerator/bottom freezers stacked side by side. This was lovely, too. I've currently got a 48" side by side arrangement. It's my least favorite. I don't find the freezer to be particularly useful. I use my 36" FD garage refrigerator/freezer for most of my frozen food storage even though the side by side in the kitchen is closer. I just find it too narrow. This is the second side by side I have owned. I gave the last one away I hated it so much. Mostly because it kept freezer my fresh items against the common wall of the refrigerator. I couldn't count the number of vegetables and salad greens that unit ruined because of the common wall.

  • 4 years ago

    I have the subzero 42” French door and love it. It works for us. Also have a deep chest freezer in garage.

  • 4 years ago

    Hi Darbuka

    i see that you have had both the 36” and 42” SZ over under fridge/freezer. we are deciding between those 2 sizes. if we get the 42” we will only have about 22” of space between fridge and corner.

    how much more do you like the 42”? we are 3 at home now but have two in college that come home for vacation and might come back longer term someday (god forbid!).

    i will post pic of fridge wall for referencere

    also did you guys do standard or flush installation?

    thanks!

    We will move wall left of fridge 4” to left and also make flush with appliance wall.

  • 4 years ago

    Remember also that SxS builtin models cone in a 48” width which helps with getting the fredzer side wider. And if yoy dont have space for teo separate colunns, a SxS can be an alternative. As a designer, I remind clients that trends are for inspiration; not as a way to dictate how anyone uses their kitchen. To that point, while SxS models are less common now in mass market appliances and modest budget kitchens, they are still an important option in more luxury budget renovation since space constraints can always present challenges even in premium budget renovations.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    @Suzanne Giomi…The 42” FD holds a lot more than the 36” over/under. I really like how the interior is set up, too. With your size family, you’ll find the 42” much more useful.

    This was taken with the kitchen lights off. Click to enlarge:


  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    My previous house had a 48" SxS Kitchenaid that I hated. Both the fridge and freezer were too narrow and things got lost behind other things. It also didn't help that it was too close to a corner.

    When we remodeled I moved the fridge out of the corner and did SZ integrated columns, 36" fridge and 24" freezer. That was all I had room for. I loved that set up.

    We decided to move and build. New house has a good size kitchen, but I didn't want to spend as much on fridges or take up more room. I went with a 42" SZ FD and I'm pretty happy with it. There are only 2 of us home with one kid in college. I also have a 30" LG FD fridge in the laundry room because I feed my dogs raw and wanted separate freezer and thawing space for that.

  • 4 years ago

    I agree focus on the fridge part - it is easy and inexpensive to have a small chest freezer elsewhere in the home

  • 4 years ago

    I would not go side by side unless it was columns at least 30” each. We had the conventional SxS for 23 years and despite being 36” wide wide, 36” deep, free standing, and huge, it never had enough space. it died before our kitchen remodel began. We now have a temporary counter depth 36” wide Beko french door top with freeze drawer bottom and althugh the thing is far smaller than the behemouth fridge we had before, it is far more spacious as you can see everything, and it is wider so things fit! it will be moved to rec room and we will be installing a 30” SZ bottom freezer drawer - just one, as we are now empty nesters and the kitchen is smallish. After practicing with the Beko we know we can manage with the slightly smaller Subzero. With that said, i definitly prefer bottom freezer, and drawer, over hinged side opening. Easier to reach down and dig rather than crouch down to reach in. We also have a massive freezer in our garage so can keep kitchen freezer organized. Anyway, my $ .02.

  • 4 years ago

    Anyone out there have refrigerator drawers or an undercounter refrigerator or beverage fridge in their kitchen? do you like it? what do you use it for? def getting small wine fridge but debating if i need more than that with 36” SZ classic….

  • 4 years ago

    Forgot to mention above that we also have a beverage fridge! In the old house we had a 15" ULine and in new house we went with 24" SZ. DH drinks sparkling water, lots of it, so it is his water fridge. Could be used for lots of other things too.