Software
Houzz Logo Print
elena_godin

Bathroom tile work cost - price check

4 years ago
last modified: 4 years ago

Would you mind helping me understand if the bathroom contractor is asking too much for the tile work? Or is it a fair price nowadays? I am so confused. Our bathroom is about 50 square feet, and the bath alcove walls are about 70 square feet. The contractor wants $2250 for the floors (ceramic penny tiles) and $4000 for the wall tiles that are straight laid subway tiles (12X3"). And he puts 88 square feet for the floor and 100 feet for the wall. We pay for the demolishing as well, this is a complete remodel project, and all his other jobs are priced reasonably, like $900 to install a bathtub. The tile work segment specifically where the pricing seems to be so much off, and the prices above do not include the material cost. Any suggestions are appreciated.





Comments (26)

  • 4 years ago

    If that includes the cost of the tile and all materials then I’d say that too low for professional tile work.

    Elena G. thanked thinkdesignlive
  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    It does not include the cost of our tile, grout, and caulk. Material cost is a separate expense. It is the price for the labor.

  • 4 years ago

    Are those prices included the tiles? In my new build I have 7 bathrooms and got an estimate from a very good installer who is going to charge me $12/SQF to install the tiles on any wall or floor, any shape or size I choose as long as it’s not slabs, and I will supply the tile myself. For outdoors I have 4000 SQF that needs to be tile 24x 48, so for that part I got another estimate from a different installer of $4/SQF, also not including the tile which I’m paying for myself. I’m in south Florida.

    Elena G. thanked Lila S
  • 4 years ago

    Lilla, thank you! the prices are for labor only, and then he adjusts it additionally for the tile price.

  • 4 years ago

    How does it compare to the other quotes you got?

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    What about cement board, waterproofing, permits, plumber, etc? How will he construct the shower? What does he say about flood test? Is he licensed and insured as a tile setter? Have you looked at his other work? Most professional tile setters will only take a project where they furnish and install their material.

    Elena G. thanked millworkman
  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    @strategery Walls: $1020 for "membrane" and $1600 for tile work.

    Floor: $1600. Those who provided this quote are not able to start working until spring.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    @millworkman, thanks for your prompts! the contractor is certified and registered. He never mentioned a "cementboard" and "flood test." I have seen the pictures of his other works and they look OK - this is one of his gallery pictures:

    The tiles are selected at the nice professional place, "Ann Arbor Tile and Stone," and he will pick them up ("furnish and install"). I just do not understand why he says 88' when the area is about 50? And why it is added to the labor cost.

  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago


    I sort of like the retro feel of your current bathroom

    You need a contract that outlines all the major steps to be done. Make sure you talk to the contractor about the materials to be used, eg. what goes on the walls in the wet areas, what in the rest of the bathroom, what will they set the tile in...some sort of thinset mortar is the only correct answer in a bathroom, what decoupling membranes will they use, what grout and caulk, where drains and shower heads go, will you need to frame for a glass enclosure?

    Permits and Inspections

    Demolition and disposal

    Electrical,

    Plumbing

    Framing and structural repairs,

    Shower/tub installation, what waterproofing system will be used

    Vanity installation and finish carpentry

    Floor decoupling membrane tiling and painting.

    When I had a couple of bathrooms done completely my contractor said $35k. He had done so many similar jobs that it was almost boiler plate, He outlined the steps in the contract but did not

    break out the cost. In the end it was $37k with a few change orders coming from me.

    Elena G. thanked Jeff Meeks
  • PRO
    4 years ago

    Need clarification: Is this a tub surround (you are removing the alcove tub surround, replacing with tub and tiled walls?) Or a full shower? Either way your reference to "materials" being tile, grout, and caulk is not a full "materials list". Much more goes into it than you are assuming. A wet area requires a very qualified contractor. You'll pay for that too. It doesn't sound unreasonable but we aren't clear on the scope yet. And do not forget that qualified labor is in high demand right now. In fact, consumers can expect to pay more in the future for qualified craftspeople as not enough young people are going into the trades and the highly experienced are retiring, hence, wait months. Or hire unqualified and hope you aren't unhappy with the result or need to replace it in near future. Kind of the reality.

    Elena G. thanked Dragonfly Tile & Stone Works, Inc.
  • 4 years ago

    Dragonfly Tile & Stone Works, Inc., thanks! we will remove the current bathtub and replace it with another bathtub + tiles on the walls. And of course, we do understand the workforce shortage, etc. I do not mind paying a fair price for the job being done by a qualified team, it is rather feeling odd about the $50 for something that is listed as "tile work." I did ask several times how comes that 70 sqft area costs $4000 to tile, and why there is a 100 sqft in the estimate, but never got a clear answer. And the contractor is not that good with calculations - like adding the sales tax to the entire project instead of material. You say, "much more goes into it than you are assuming" - but how I can know that?


  • 4 years ago

    One way to find out is get another tile contractor to quote

  • 4 years ago

    Jeff Meeks, thank you for sharing the cost of your projects (do you have pictures to look at by any chance?) Our bathrooms look much better in the pictures than in reality. So many things are just at the end of their lifecycle. In theory, we could save and reface the vanity, but it costs almost as much as installing a new one. The bathtub is old, has a crack, and I am not a big fan of plastic walls. We will keep the same layout, and we did look at other retro bathrooms designed by the same architect, David Osler. Penny tile is a bit out of the line, but modernists did use it in their decor, so hopefully, it will be OK. I will check on the things you mentioned:


    Framing and structural repairs - are there any.

    Shower/tub installation - what waterproofing system will be in use

    Floor decoupling membrane tiling and painting - I never heard of it!

  • 4 years ago

    jackowskib, I did. Assuming membrane ($1020) and tiling ($1600), it was $2600 (not $4000). I am still mystified as to why the current contractor assumes 100 sqft instead of 70-80.

  • PRO
    4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Overage (extra tile beyond actual square footage) is standard, usually 10 - 20% depending on the tile and the layout/pattern. Penny tile is often an up-charge because it takes more labor to install correctly (as is the case with some other tile selections as well). I would be having this conversation with your verified, qualified installer. In the end, that relationship, and mutual trust (both ways) will be paramount in a successful project.

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    "Those who provided this quote are not able to start working until spring."


    Anyone with a 4 month backlog isn't charging enough. When they realize this in three months, they'll put a job that pays more in front of yours.

  • 4 years ago

    @Dragonfly Tile & Stone Works, Inc., I agree with your statement about mutual trust. And I know that there should be extra material for tiles to allow for cutting and matching; it is unclear why this extra is applied to the labor part. I'll talk to him more and ask for itemized outline for this work, but he is too busy to answer.


    Framing and structural repairs - are there any.

    Shower/tub installation - what waterproofing system will be in use

    Floor decoupling membrane tiling and painting - I never heard of it!

  • PRO
    4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    What does your contract or proposals detailed scope say about Industry and MFG standards that will be followed and met? layouts? corner wraps? finished edges? niches and niche placement. What are you getting in the end?

    Focus on the WHOLE start to finish project and stop looking at line items as if they are qualified and willing you are sure to scare them away SOON.

    IMHO this CONtractor has shared to much info w you already .

    Are they qualified as Dragonfly states?

    Elena G. thanked Mint tile Minneapolis
  • 4 years ago

    Thanks for sharing your perspective, Mint Tile LLC. We discussed the niche (we do not want one) and the layout - vertical straight with the bullnoses to finish the sides. Obviously, I did not see a word about "corner wraps, finished edges, and MFG standards."


    "IMHO this CONtractor has shared too much info w you already." - I do not feel this way. In fact, I see that we miss pieces that are important (like the waterproofing system.) Honestly, it is frustrating - and sorry, I can not do mind reading. If it is not on paper does it mean that it is part of the standard and will be done as such? Or he will say that he forgot to add it and put it to the estimate after the job would start?

  • 4 years ago

    @Helen - agree - you said "it is entirely appropriate to ask a GC, tradesperson, or your designer how the charges are calculated. I would do this in a non-obnoxious manner when I didn't understand an invoice and they were always happy to explain and their explanations always made sense" - and this is what I am trying to uncover.


    Everything else in the estimate appears to be very transparent and reasonable. The tile position is a mystery, and as I can learn from other answers to this post may in fact consist of more than listed. At the same time, if it says "Furnish and install new tile tub surround. Tile TBD." And he seemed to get annoyed when I asked.

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    to my point you need to understand How to hire and what to look for in a proposal and then a contract. Should always be a detailed scope and either A T&M or fixed price scenario.


    scope for tile scope for trim schedule, etc. etc.

  • PRO
    4 years ago

    I do have to agree with @Mint tile Minneapolis. I don't know of any contractor around here that gives that much of a price breakdown for the project. We don't do that at all. You get a list of what is being done and a final project price. It never includes decorative items like tile, fixtures, vanity, etc. Rough materials, removal and haul away are included.

    Our typical bathroom renovation Labor only is usually between $18k and $25K ( or more for large rooms, more elaborate tile, moving things around etc ).

    Hope this helps.

    Elena G. thanked Debbi Washburn
  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    On my bath remodel I bought the tile, medicine cabinet, shower head and wall light fixtures. Because it was the sort of update he'd done in lots of similar homes he suggested a few bath fixtures that would fit in the space ie Kohler cast iron tub, Kohler pedestal sink and Toto toilet and he provided those and everything else. I had a one page list of procedures and items he would provide and a single bottom line cost of $35k for two identical bathrooms. The final cost was $37k because of some issues and change orders...this was 5 years ago in New England.

  • 4 years ago

    Thank you all for your kind suggestions. Overall, I feel I know more than before. I also observed that consumers/clients prefer more details on the works being done, and service providers/contractors prefer to keep it simple and without too many details. That might be the major pain point in the communication process.

  • 4 years ago

    I think even in terms of consumer expectations there seems to be a misunderstanding of what a homeowner finds reasonable.


    I don't think most homeowners expect an itemized list of every piece of material that is being used for the job but a contract should contain enough specificity so that a third party looking at what is written would be able to determine what the contractual expectations of the parties are.


    Also - unless I am mistaken - OP is just confused as to why there appears to be a discrepancy in the square footage. I don't understand why asking politely what that means is out of line so long as one doesn't go in with an attitude that the tradesperson is attempting to cheat you.


    Also there is sometimes a difference of opinion as to when it is appropriate to ask for a breakdown of what the job will be in an estimate. I think again a rule of reason would prevail. When I had my HVAC replaced, I didn't need the same kind of bid as when I had a complete gut remodel. A simple statement of the HVAC unit being provided and the cost for installation was sufficient. However it would be ridiculous for someone to provide an estimate stating that the master bath was going to be remodel for $X as one would reasonably expect there to be a breakdown of everything that was going to be done in terms of the scope of the work.

    Elena G. thanked Helen