No way should those be painted when the backsplash is the major issue.

“Painting” those properly would be more expensive than a backsplash. And they are beautiful cabinets that coordinate well with the stone counters. A simpler backsplash would be the most affordable and simple option

get a cohesive theme involving wall color/ backsplash /new hardware / new pendants and consider a paint job for the hood cover only. That could work to at least get this into a transitional aesthetic. Removal of the hood corbels , along w a paint redo of just that section...and the backsplash section you might insert there is a great opportunity.

Leave the cabinets and change out the counters and backsplash to something lighter.

New hardware, lose the crossword puzzle insert and rest of the backsplash, and consider replacing that hood insert and cover section with a different hood altogether. Repair the drywall and paint the walls something not so beige.

Agree with all this so far. Crossword puzzle backsplash is the WINNING description. I’ve hated it since we moved in, ha! Repainting walls is for sure part of the project!

What type of new backsplash would go with these busy countertops?

You only need to change the small area framed in black. Take a trip to a tile store. You can get anything without cost being a factor. Or a remnant of stone slab material to match your counter.

creamy white subway tile...the bigger dimension...[your doors are large and its a big swirly pattern in the counter].... it might be a little tricky prior to painting the walls .....see if they have a sample board ..or an actual tile not just a cut. to bring home. the photo from phone while in tile store can be quite helpful to hold up. I see how busy the current tile is...I'd get away from that .

Not a pro, just someone who’s had a few kitchens 😁. Ooh, I would not paint those cabinets. They seem very nice. Changing the backsplash will help and painting the walls, too. The granite is very busy and dark, but taken solely, the stone is pretty, especially on the island. With the right backsplash and wall color, thus could certainly work even if it’s not your total dream.

All great suggestions. I will start with backsplash and new hardware (and painting walls) and see how it looks afterwards. I know just those alone will make a big improvement.

Kelly: you now have a good plan for an update!! Those cabinets are beautiful and look to be in great shape. Please post pictures when you complete you project.