Software
Houzz Logo Print
kilkennyc

paint the brick? or replace the floors? or both?

4 years ago
last modified: 4 years ago

We are in a design dilemma. We are redoing our walk out basement and the floors are clashing with the fireplace and possibly the mohogany bar. There is over 1500 ft of this ceramic tile flooring, so an expensive endeavor to replace. We are looking for opinions to paint the fireplace and if so do you go black or whitewash ? Or suck it up and replace the floors? or both? thanks in advance for your thoughts!

The first image is the current state, the next images show the floors against the fireplace and mohogany bar/doors for color reference









Comments (36)

  • 4 years ago

    Nice room. Not a pro but I happen to love the fireplace. The floor not so much.

    kilkennyc thanked spindle22
  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    wow. I have a headache.

    Do you like either? obviously they don't work together.

    tearing up that brick floor is going to be a nightmare in demo costs, and replacement. 1500 feet? expect 20K min, unless you choose a 1.99 laminate. lol.

    but I see you have gray walls and black and white windows, and it doesn't work at all w/that flooring.

    So, if you can swing it, bite the bullet and redo it.

    The fireplace. will look nice if painted white.



    love the wood mantle.

    What I would also do is paint all of that wood trim in there. (but if you're going to replace the floors, forget it and just get all new baseboard, which would look 10X better)

    oh wait, its painted on one half of the room? looks good.

    another option, at least in front of the fireplace after you paint it, is to get a really large area rug that covers a good portion of that area. maybe a neutral sisal or jute so that it doesn't compete w/the brick pattern.


    if you don't care for the brick FP, paint it. bring in a rug. try the cheaper option first

    kilkennyc thanked Beth H. :
  • 4 years ago

    Wow. Yeah. Um. Fabulous room but..hrmmm. :)


    I wonder if you can put a floating floor over the tile.

    kilkennyc thanked Fori
  • 4 years ago

    I don't care for the floors at all.

    If you can replace them or cover them that would be nice.

    What will you be doing down there?

    You could get two sizable rugs or natural fiber or synthetic natural fiber lookalikes that will cover almost the whole floor.

    I would do that first and leave the brick wall intact.

    Then decide if you want to paint it.

    I like the manliness of it with your leather furniture and the ceiling beams and wood mantel.

    If you do paint it, you might want to consider a paint wash rather than a full-on opaque paint.

    A question- In some photos the beams look black and in others they look brown and your mantle looks brown.

    What are the true colors?

    kilkennyc thanked loobab
  • 4 years ago

    Hi thanks for your input the steel beams painted black is what it currently has
    previously they were encased in Cedar but made the ceiling height lower than what we wanted, so all of the wood trim has been removed or painted. The mantle remains in the original wood

  • 4 years ago

    Perhaps you can float engineered or LVT flooring without needing to remove the current floor. If you’re not sure, consult with a local flooring showroom. A wood-look would be lovely.

    kilkennyc thanked Therese N
  • 4 years ago

    Love the fireplace as-is. If you can use laminate, there are some very nice laminates for 2$ or less per foot (no laugh). HD has a laminate made in Germany that is very nice, and last I knew was 99cents/foot. I personally wouldn't put 20K into a basement floor unless it's an amazingly high rent district and you have any chance of a return of at least half of it. Depending on your lifestyle, how long you're keeping the house, what you're using the room for, etc., carpet can be a good choice as well. In the middle of winter, where I am at, carpet seems cozy at the moment --- headed to below zero temps :(

    kilkennyc thanked User
  • 4 years ago

    The floor looks like it is sheet vinyl, correct ? i would do nothing until the floor is replaced. A wood-look LVP would look great especially with some area rugs. Do not paint the fireplace. Changing that floor will give you great inspiration.

    kilkennyc thanked grapefruit1_ar
  • PRO
    4 years ago

    IMO a wood look LVP is the perfect answer and I think that is a vinyl not tile are you sure it is tile ? Even if it is tile I would just do the LVP on top of it something like Coretech with that good under body should work.

    kilkennyc thanked Patricia Colwell Consulting
  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    I too doubt if that floor is actual tile. Looks very vinyl to me. Easy to cover either way. Basement calls for broadloom. Basements are fabulous places for gas fireplaces, this makes painting white an option. White and real wood burning is not a great idea. Dark gray might be dramatic on your bricks if I were into painting brick.

    kilkennyc thanked arcy_gw
  • 4 years ago

    Get some furniture and area rugs in there first to see if you have to do either.

    kilkennyc thanked Lorraine Leroux
  • 4 years ago

    What is the floor? Vinyl? or in some photos it looks like it could be actual tile.

    kilkennyc thanked palimpsest
  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    thank you all for your input! To clarify, the flooring is tile. 1500 sq ft of tile! it is 40 + years old and was laid with 3/4 inch floating concrete underneath it and there is only 1 tile in the entire basement that has a hairline crack, so it was put in to last a lifetime. We removed some on the upper level and it took forever and we had to replace the subfloor when we were done. It is a huge undertaking to replace, but Luxury vinyl plank could likely go overtop.

    The floor fights with the fireplace. as it is a totally different color scheme and pattern. Painting the brick a charcoal seems like a possible solution, and then placing area rugs as some of you had suggested seems like a nice low cost option. I don't mind the fireplace color, not in love with the floor.

    The dilemma is the floor is 20k to replace, the fireplace could be painted for a few hundred. wondering if the fireplace is muted- by being one color would it calm down the conflict with the floor? and if so what color? Or would covering the tile with new flooring solve the whole problem?





  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    Yes, it definitely would help. But if you prefer the fireplace as is over the flooring, and it’s in your budget to replace the tile/do new floors, it seems like the best solution here. I actually like the retro tile, but I’m weird that way. :)

    Just from your posts here, I think you’d be happiest changing the flooring, and going from there. I think trying to work around the flooring would never feel ”right” to you. The tile is a strong statement for sure.

    What is the look you’d love for this room, if you could snap your fingers and it’d be done? How is the rest of your house decorated?

    kilkennyc thanked Jilly
  • 4 years ago

    Regardless of what you do with the fireplace…to paint it or not….I would embrace the tiled floor. AND….I would contact a carpeting company. And have them cute a HUGE rug for you from roll stock. And have it bound. The huge rug would cover most of the flooring (standard width around 11 feet wide.) The floor would serve as the perimeter, only, to your room. And once it is fully furnished… you won’t notice the floor. (Much!). Good luck!

    kilkennyc thanked ptreckel
  • 4 years ago

    Jinx definitely has the right idea. Don't fight the floor; it's the most unique, well built, largest area, and most expensive to handle. Painting the fireplace to tie into your black sectional then adding in some rugs in neutral and black to tie the flooring in as well will look cozy and great.

    Do you really want yet another greige-ish vinyl flooring like everyone else and their mother?? You'd lose all unique character in the room.

    kilkennyc thanked turtlexings24
  • 4 years ago

    great input thank you. Of course I would like to leave the floors, if I could find a way to make them less prominent! Your suggestions have all been very helpful! We are restoring this whole house- west coast modern, so I am trying to balance that, and modernize it as well without becoming a cookie cutter new build home.

    I understand that vinyl plank floors might be a solution, but reflecting on our "big plan" I would ideally like to work with these floors.

    So, on that note, suggestions on color for the fireplace? also any thoughts on painting the white trim out to black as Jinx suggested? More directly would you paint the baseboards black?



  • 4 years ago

    Is the rest of the house updated or does this floor fit with the rest of the house?

    A problem for me is that the floor is a very warm color and the walls are cool toned making everything look disjointed.

    Are you artsy? I wonder about painting some of the bricks on the fireplace colors from the floor. I'm thinking paint some of the white bricks a darker color from the floor. I think toning down the white will make the floor and fireplace lay better. I've told on here before about how my MIL did that to a brick ranch they lived in and it still looks great years later.

    I do agree about getting a large solid rug of some type.


    kilkennyc thanked RNmomof2 zone 5
  • 4 years ago

    Since its a basement - have you ruled out wall to wall carpeting? Yes installing the tack strips along the perimeter will need to be drilled through the tile. Just wanted to toss that out there as a suggestion as no one has raised it yet. Carpet is much warmer under foot for a basement floor than tile.

    Good luck!

    kilkennyc thanked Pauline G
  • 4 years ago

    I guess the question is why you painted gray and painted over the ceiling beam, but now want the floor to work? The floor worked well with maple/natural wood. I guess the gray/black you are going for go with the red brick but it didn't help in the long run. A natural wood beam matching the mantle a win win. What is this over all direction you keep talking about? Maybe that would help us.

  • 4 years ago

    I thnk the floow has to be addressed first. Since it is low traffic area can you paint it and put down some huge rugs?

    kilkennyc thanked Rachelle France
  • 4 years ago

    ptreckle has a good idea. bound carpeet cut to your room dimension w/just a sliver of a border so there won't have to be tack strips. (or do wall to wall)


    the other thing you could ask about,,,floating a concrete overlay over the entire floor. since that brick is well secured to a cement foundation, could they just do an overlay on top of it? (putting laminate over it might not work because of the larger grout lines may transmit through) Then you could do a diff tile or a nice LVP.


    Or maybe some type of epoxy coating that could then be refinished?

    kilkennyc thanked Beth H. :
  • 4 years ago

    Get professionals from a flooring company to tell you if another product - like LVP - can be floated on top of the tile. Ask the cost of a bound piece of carpeting. Find out what wall to wall will cost. Knowing the numbers will help you decide if you want to cover this floor or try to embrace it. You can definitely decorate around it, but do you want to?
    Leaving the tiles and painting the brick to complement them would go far to get rid of the disconnect between those two elements. An area rug that is a solid color (again, one that matches the tile) would be another possibility. Your black couch is neutral which helps.
    My only concern with the tile is the coldness factor. If you have rough winters, a basement room with tile will never be cozy.

  • 4 years ago

    A dark color masonry stain would tone down the fireplace brick without giving it the solid color painted look.  Perhaps one of the darker tones from the floor would work. I woud also consider darkening the grout. Large rugs and perhaps a different wall color will get you a much eifferent look.

    kilkennyc thanked Lyndee Lee
  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    To give a better context here are images of the ceramic tile floor against the fireplace and the mohogany bar. All doors in the home are mohogany and will not be changed. To answer questions regarding the remainder of the house and its style we have new white oak floors throughout. The fireplace on the main floor is stacked stone in a charcoal color. I am including some images of the main floor for reference to our style of home that we are trying to keep in line with. Also showing the tile as it meets the white oak at the bottom of the stairs. Thank you again for your thoughts!









  • 4 years ago

    Oh cool, it's ceramic tile. Maybe just darken the grout to the darkest tile color and leave the brick (sorry I am a fan of leaving brick alone in 99% of cases) alone. Add some plain area rugs :)

    kilkennyc thanked User
  • 4 years ago

    Save your $20k for a fabulous vacation somewhere. Or for the cost overruns of your upstairs. Get a bound rug so you leave that tile floor in excellent shape.

    kilkennyc thanked Sarah
  • 4 years ago

    I know nothing about the cost, but I recently saw a floor redone with epoxy and it seems that could be an alternative for you.

    kilkennyc thanked decoenthusiaste
  • PRO
    4 years ago

    Simply replacing the floors is a great way to brighten up that room and bring it into the 21st century. Make sure if you do paint the brick that you clean the surface prior to painting and remember to use a good primer for your base coat.

    kilkennyc thanked Blue Oak Painting
  • 4 years ago

    I picked a lighter tint of one of the floor colors for a wall and trim color, and a darker shade of one of the floor tiles for the brick fireplace. If you wanted to deemphasize the fireplace altogether, you could paint it the wall color


    kilkennyc thanked palimpsest
  • 4 years ago

    Just a thought, I am not a Pro.


    Painting the grout lines on the floor may be an option, something you can try out in a closet if the floor was continued in there.

    kilkennyc thanked njmomma
  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    I have never heard of painting grout lines before as a few have mentioned- has anyone ever done it? how is it done? easy or hard? The wall colors were matched to the grout lines trying to tie the two together.

  • 4 years ago

    Your floor is kinda great!

    I was just offering an option, but if I had that floor, I would paint my brick dark and keep the floor as is. You already picked the grout color that is there as your wall color.

    kilkennyc thanked njmomma
  • 4 years ago

    Applying grout colorant is tedious but not difficult. Fortunately, the setup is easy so the job doesn't need to be done in one session.  If you like to occasionally zone out on a mindless task, this definitely fits that description.  Or, find some companionship,  put on some good music, and consume your favorite beverage and get busy. You might want to find some kneepads because tile is hard on the knees

    kilkennyc thanked Lyndee Lee
  • 4 years ago

    I feel that the flooring really goes with the rest of your house and the fireplace not so much so!

    I vote for making the fireplace darker to mimic the one upstairs and blend with the floor.

    Neat house!

    kilkennyc thanked RNmomof2 zone 5