Having a hard time deciding between three kitchen cabinet knobs. Please help! They are drilling the holes next week, so I need to get them ordered.

The island cabinet doors is what is shown in the photos. All the other kitchen cabinet doors have the same door style but are painted SW Dover White.

My concerns: (1) Does the 1-1/2" knob look too big on the 2-3/4" stile on the doors? (2) The 1-3/8" projection leaves a lot of finger space; but will it stick out too far and look ridiculous? (3) Would you go simple (e.g., Option 3) or go with a knob with some character (e.g., Options 1 or 2)?