Software
Houzz Logo Print
vlake23

Condo exterior repair

4 years ago
last modified: 4 years ago

Cannot locate matching brick for damaged brick wall repair. Several contractors have told me that cleaning/ reusing old brick is not cost effective HOA prefers not to spend $ on hiring a designer/architect to provide options, so basically owners (none of us are in the field) will act as designers 😟 So far the suggestions from owners are as follows: 1) use paint grade brick, then paint only the new brick or 2) repair with paint grade, then paint brick on whole building, which means the other 4 buildings will need to follow suit for uniformity-an expensive remedy due to one damaged building? Again, $ is an issue. 3) replace damaged brick with hardi plank siding because it’s less expensive. The complex has 5 separate buildings all similarly designed and any decision will affect 25 owners’ property values. Photos of building show blue tarped damaged areas would have either painted brick or plank siding. Can you think of any other options? Opinions please. Thank you.

pic 1- damaged brick areas under blue tarps- most of north wall, some of east wall(northeast corner) and double chimney


pic 2- building before damage


pic 3- large north wall design before damage. All brick to the left of windows are gone/damaged


1. Paint grade brick and paint new brick only
2. Paint grade brick and paint new and existing brick
3. Use plank siding painted to match existing wood trim (SW brush blue)
None of the above.

Comments (9)

  • 4 years ago

    "Several contractors have told me that cleaning/ reusing old brick is not cost effective"


    But potentially changing some wall cladding to Hardie on 5 buildings is cost effective? Painting the bricks on 5 building is cost effective? How were one select areas of brick damaged?

    vlake23 thanked millworkman
  • 4 years ago

    Whatever you end up doing, be sure to get all details, in writing, approved by HOA.

    I can't imagine any HOA not wanting to get involved in this. They usually are over-involved.

    Who is paying for this?


    Would this be an option? Take down what's left of the brick from the side of the building and re-use to fix the front of the building. Then siding on the complete side of the building.



  • 4 years ago

    Thanks for the input @millworkman damaged wall and chimney from hurricane Laura/Delta in August of 2020. I’m. quite certain the HOA does not feel they would need to match the other 4 buildings with Hardi . I’m trying to convince them that uniformity will help keep up the property value. Theyve indicated that they like the look of painted brick, but not sure they want to spend the money, which is why I’m searching for another possible solution. @Angel 18432 of course everything is in writing and will/will not be approved by the board.. The master hazard insurance policy has paid a portion of the claim and were’re not sure if/when they will pay more. Claim is still in progress. It’s been rough with everything in the last 1.5 yrs in our area plus back to back hurricanes, a freeze and a flood. Everyone on the board is worn out and they are involved as much as they can be with having to maintain their own full time jobs. I’m retired and trying to take care of the leg work for them. As I said, brick Masons and contractors have advised against cleaning and reusing the brick and designers have advised me against siding a wall that was originally brick because it will look like a hack job. Of course it can be done, but my concern is to keep the integrity of the original design or at least, if it has to change, then somehow integrate the design changes into the rest of the buildings . I’m not an expert, but I’ve been warned by at least 5 experts that an oddly designed/repaired building in the community will not help with any of the 25 owner’s property values. Hoping for a solution we can all live with.

  • 4 years ago

    We had a window moved. The brick had been discontinued, but the mason hunted until he found something similar. You might have to re-do the brick on the entire wall, but they should be able to get close.


    If insurance will pay to re-roof a house when the shingles are discontinued, this sounds similar. Maybe you need to talk to more masons. And maybe the HOA needs to dip into their reserves.

    vlake23 thanked latifolia
  • 4 years ago
    last modified: 4 years ago

    @latifolia thanks, may I ask if your new brick noticeably different from the old or close enough that it doesnt stand out? Ours is a fairly large section of wall that turns a corner and a separate section for a chimney, so wondering if we’d notice the difference in color that much. I’m being told by brick suppliers that production is way down right now and takes months to come in. We’re already behind and waiting longer wouldnt be a problem, except that insurance will terminate if not repaired by July 😟

  • 4 years ago

    Ours was prior to Covid, so can't speak to current supply issues. I think the mason found the bricks, rather than having them made. They are very close.


    Have you consulted a public adjuster to see what the insurance company ought to be paying you?

    vlake23 thanked latifolia
  • 4 years ago

    Have a brick cleaning party with all 25 members required to "chip" in. I won't take long to chip and shine those bricks up good as new. Do you think Europe was rebuilt with new bricks after WWII? A lot of chipping and cleaning.

    vlake23 thanked outpaientzero
  • 4 years ago

    @latifolia oh yes, we have that number.. which the insurance agreed to less than half the amount. the public adjuster started negotiations with insurance a year ago and was unsuccessful. Finally last month he suggested that we use an attorney.


    @Sigrid, the siding is actually dark blue, but thanks for the input..


    @kevin9408 that’s a great idea, except that we’re all either too old and too tired or too young and too busy. I should send out a letter just to see if anyone would actually show up. Don't know that i would want to chaperone that party tho 😉