Do you have to paint all the rooms the exact same color? Of course they have various lighting so one color may not work in every room. And I will never understand why people are so stuck on overpriced paint. Go explore other brands and colors.

Have you considered BM Balboa Mist?

BM is is lil dark. Thx.

Check out SW Accessible Beige.

We have our whole house painted BM Edgecomb gray and love it. It reads a little more beige in natural light and more gray in less light but love it either way!

Glad to know I’m not the only one who goes down the endless rabbit hole of paint colors, my family thinks I’m absolutely crazy 😔 anyway this sounds exactly like what I just went through in my living/dining room. I tried all the same “no fail” light neutrals and none seemed to be right in that space. The only one I ever really liked was Gray Mist (BM) but when it was time for the painters to come I panicked and thought it might be a little too light so I ended up going with Olympic Mountains (which apparently is also called Fog Mist). I’m not totally in love but it is a nice neutral that I would say lands right between Classic Gray and Edgecomb Gray. Good luck and let us know what you choose!!

In the same boat trying to get a nice greige for my south facing living room. Tried quite a few including Clay Beige - too dark and more green/pink, Elmira White - bit too light and peachy, White Sand - nice colour but a bit too yellow, Natural Cream seemed too gray, Tapestry Beige too greenish. I wanted to try Manchester Tan but it may be too yellow so I am probably going with Edgecomb Gray which is the colour I have in all my bedrooms even though it looks a bit darker and more on the gray side when sampling on those south facing walls. If anyone has tried Wind's Breath or Ballet White or Classic Gray and can compare to Edgecomb Gray that would be appreciated.

One neutral wall color for the entire interior: B.M. Collingwood. Easy breezy.

We just did for the entire first floor of our home, love it! its a beigey gray, accessible beige by SW

I originally used BM Silver Satin but I didnt like its lavender undertone that most greiges have. The alernative greige undertone is ylw. One of my rooms has off white with a ylw hue that looks dingey to me. Yesterday, I repainted the entire room w SW Nuance that is a light neutral grey with a green undertone. Interstingly green-greyes are suppose to be the new nuetral. I didnt think Id go for something on the green spectrum since the original color was a horrid light green. Nuance appears white in comparison. I think its going to give me the beachy vibe that Im going for and will likely use throughout.

SW agreeable gray. Use a matte/flat sheen on the walls it truly shows off the color.

Benjamin Moore Picket Fence