Software
Houzz Logo Print
sgmsnewhouse

Dining Room Makeover - Lighten, modernize, change everything?

4 years ago

I first posted for ideas about my dining room in 2015! In the meantime I updated many other rooms, but it’s time to tackle my most challenging room. I am fortunate to have a large dining room and I use it a lot! But I inherited the furniture and have been unhappy with both the darkness of the room, the traditional furniture, and the horrible fireplace (I use that a lot as well).

I’ve checked out ways to modernize the room (and had hoped to do it in stages) but nothing quite felt right. But I have had time to continue to think about options and and ready to take the plunge and do it! I would love to get some thoughts regarding how I might go about changing and modernizing the room (and maybe in 2 stages). There are also some limitations: 1) no rug under table - husband nixed that long ago, 2) no lightening the floor, 3) need a cabinet for my crystal — It was suggested that the large painting be centered on the far wall but I would love to find some kind of more modern lit cabinet for the crystal that could work with it where it is if possible—its my largest wall. My thoughts right now are that I: 1) ditch the louvered blinds, 2) lighten the walls, perhaps a soft white (the room gets no direct sun), 3) change the fireplace surround and brick and modernize it, 4) introduce a modern chandelier. In terms of furniture, I wonder what will modernize the room more: changing the table or the chairs? If I keep the table for the time being I would want more modern chairs that could also lighten the room up. I have also played around with the idea of painting the chairs red and changing the fabric. It might be less expensive to just start from scratch, however. I have attached pictures of the room and also my feeble attempt to layout how changes might look (along with a chandelier I love!). Where should I begin?





Comments (10)

  • 4 years ago

    How modern do you want to go? That chandelier is setting the tone but it is quite small for the size of both the room and table. How about painting the brick FP satin black with a stainless or copper mantel? Modern art? My experience is that the table and chairs will not sell well separately but better as a set for someone who wants to go traditional. Is your crystal pattern traditional?

    sgmsnewhouse thanked decoenthusiaste
  • 4 years ago

    I like how the picture below mixes traditional and modern furnishings. I would definitely go with a larger and modern light fixture. I would only keep one if the China cabinets and add in some fun, lightness and texture with wallpaper and new shades or drapes (since you won’t be doing a rug).

    sgmsnewhouse thanked Val B
  • 4 years ago

    Here’s the picture I meant to include.

    sgmsnewhouse thanked Val B
  • 4 years ago

    Ugh! Definitely not what I meant to post!!! Not sure how to edit to delete the wrong picture. Sorry!!!

  • 4 years ago

    `If you want to keep the table or the chairs I would keep the table and try upholstered Parsons chairs or another type of simple chair. You don't say what colors you're using elsewhere in the house, but try to coordinate with your living room. It's such a large room you have lots of options for a new chandelier. I wouldn't paint the room white however, that sounds boring to me - unless that fits with how you have changed the rest of your house. Usually dining rooms are used in the evening so you can use a more dramatic color (if you like color) even if it is a dark room.

    sgmsnewhouse thanked kandrewspa
  • 4 years ago

    You really need a rug. My dining room rug is very thin, low pile and doesn't interfere with moving the chairs at all...if that's your husband's concern? I would get new chairs, the current ones have a bossy backrest that goes against anything updated you want to add. A large chandelier will anchor the space better, right now the fireplace gets too much attention. This could be a great dining room with some changes :)

    sgmsnewhouse thanked lucky998877
  • 4 years ago

    Agree with @lucky998877 on the rug - there are some fabulous ones now that resist stains and are low profile (even indoor/outdoor). We have a very long table in our DR ( and it's not the widest room) and I ended up doing 2 oversized lanterns rather than one fixture - just another option


    sgmsnewhouse thanked la_la Girl
  • 4 years ago

    You have three large pieces blocking the walls. In the far end of the room, you have a large work of art that does not show itself well. I would remove either the cabinet or the art. Know that you can paint the cabinet and move it. With lighter wall paint, the art would be stunning. If the art is abstract, you may use it horizontally and placed it in the middle of the table.



    sgmsnewhouse thanked Yayagal
  • 4 years ago

    Regarding your question about changing the table vs chairs: In my opinion, keeping the table and replacing the chairs with something significantly more streamlined would have the biggest impact (vs replacing the table). While my room is quite different than yours, I have a fairly similar traditional vintage dining table and have paired it with more contemporary styled chairs.



    I think the chairs you have now are so overtly formal and traditional that they would be hard to overcome with just changing the table. Also, you could add some lightness by choosing something upholstered in a lighter or even colorful fabric.


    https://www.potterybarn.com/products/pb-comfort-square-side-upholstered-dining-chairs/


    https://www.potterybarn.com/products/alcott-dining-chair-set-mp/


    I know you said you do not want a rug and obviously that is your choice. But I do think it would make a substantial difference in how dark the room feels. Right now the dark table and chairs just fall into the dark floor.


    I might be partial to linear light fixtures, but I do think like updating the chandelier to something more rectangular or linear would help the space feel less traditional.


    https://www.potterybarn.com/products/maisie-glass-globe-linear-chandelier/



    https://www.potterybarn.com/products/adeline-rectangular-crystal-chandelier/


    sgmsnewhouse thanked pricklypearcactus
Sponsored
J.Holderby - Renovations
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars4 Reviews
Franklin County's Leading General Contractors - 2X Best of Houzz!